AMELIA ISLAND, Fla. — In the middle of a four-hour meeting in which the ACC football coaches discussed topics ranging from time demands on their players to how their schools can best accommodate television production crews, time was devoted to a foreboding issue that continues to hover around not only college football but the sport as a whole — head injuries.
Concussions have become part of the popular lexicon surrounding football, but the message passed along to coaches at the ACC’s annual spring meetings was one of patience and restraint.
Dr. Brian Hainline, the NCAA’s chief medical officer, spoke to coaches about the concussion research currently being conducted by the NCAA and the Department of Defense, but he also issued a warning of sorts that the fear of concussions and their effects is outpacing medical research on the subject.
“Justifiably, people awakened and asked ‘Wait a minute, are concussions dangerous?’ and ‘Is repetitive head contact dangerous?’” Dr. Hainline said. “Those are valid questions and the valid response is let’s really put it to the test and in the meantime, let’s do what’s reasonable in a consensus-driven manner.”
“If you really want to make decisions, it just shouldn’t be about one scientist giving speculations or one person giving his or her hypothesis,” he later added. “Let’s put everything out there and make data-driven decisions.”
One of the coaches present at the meeting, Pitt’s Pat Narduzzi, said Dr. Hainline stressed the need for more concussion data before jumping to any overarching conclusions. Narduzzi then offered what appeared to be his take on the issue.
Read More
“I think when you look at all the results and all the talk, I think it’s media-hyped,” he said. “They’re talking about how they need to get more data and feedback on really what it is that’s causing these injuries.”
Hours later, Narduzzi apologized for how his comment came off and clarified he was reiterating the crux of Dr. Hainline’s talk, not stating a personal belief. While he didn’t disagree with the interpretation of his overall message — that more data needs to be compiled — Dr. Hainline said he never used the term ‘media-hyped’.
“I don’t talk about the media when I speak,” he said. “I think someone else may have said that, but it certainly wasn’t me. You can imagine the coaches feel under attack.”
When Dr. Hainline mentions how more research must be conducted, he points specifically to the Concussion Assessment, Research and Education (CARE) Consortium, an ongoing and wide-ranging study being spearheaded by the NCAA and Department of Defense. Athletes at 30 colleges, including Pitt, are taking part in the project, which hopes to create universalized data from NCAA schools.
Thus far, the year-and-a-half-old study has analyzed over 20,000 college athletes and tracked over 1,000 concussions. They likely will have their first round of major data analysis in the early fall, but for now, Dr. Hainline shared with the coaches lessons he has learned, such as athletes who don’t report concussions immediately return to play an average of two days later than those who report them immediately.
“One year from now, we’re going to know stuff about concussions we didn’t know before because we finally did do this study,” Dr. Hainline said. “We’re not waiting 30 years for the study to be completed. We’re going to have data every year that’s going to shift policy, rules and recommendations. Right now, we’re at the very early stages of that becoming a reality.”
Dr. Hainline’s comments about the rapidly increasing fear of concussions are similar to ones espoused by Dr. Michael “Micky” Collins of UPMC, who previously has said the “hysteria” over head injuries should not cause parents of prospective athletes to live in fear.
Though Dr. Hainline is not analyzing data from the CARE Consortium because he believes it to be a conflict of interest, the NCAA is helping fund the $30 million initiative. UPMC, meanwhile, previously has received grant money from the NFL to study concussions.
While clarifying his prior comment Narduzzi, who said he never suffered a concussion as a football player, noted he and his coaches are proactive about removing players from a game if they believe they’ve suffered a concussion. Things he learned from the discussion Tuesday will help him guide his program once he arrives back on campus.
“I’m not the doctor; I’m just the coach,” Narduzzi said. “We take concussions and really anything medically related very, very seriously. When you look at the city of Pittsburgh and what concussions mean there, that’s where it starts. There couldn’t be a better place for our kids to be located for any problems as far as concussions or anything else. It’s just a matter of getting more information.”
Craig Meyer: cmeyer@post-gazette.com and Twitter @CraigMeyerPG.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.