Paul Zeise: OK, let's get started - start firing away some questions. I'll start by giving my thoughts on Pitt -- I think the Panthers are very lucky to have the draw they got. I think Wisconsin is a great matchup for Pitt because they aren't overly athletic and they aren't overly big and they don't score at a high rate. Those are the teams that seem to give this Panthers team the most problems.
Guest: Paul, what measurement do you think was used that got Syracuse into the brackets? Do you think criteria changed from prior year Tournament committee selections?
Paul Zeise: The Committee chair claims it was that Syracuse had five wins over the Top 50. That is nonsense - the Orange had an RPI in the 70, lost, what, five of their last six games. This was a classic example of the committee taking care of a big name program from a power conference. I love, for instance, people who are trying to compare Monmouth's losses to those of some of the bubble teams from the major conference. Pitt loses to NC State, by all accounts one of the worst teams in the ACC, but the Wolfpack are like a 120 RPI team or something. If Monmouth or any low major gets upset in their conference, naturally it is going to be a situation where the team likely has an awful RPI. Syracuse should not be in the NCAA Tournament. I know they won the Battle 4 Atlantis - they finished 9th in the ACC and basically -- like Pitt at Notre Dame - are propped up by a win over Duke on the road. It is silly.
Alex: How does Pitt matchup with wisconsin? And your thoughts on the key omissions.
Paul Zeise: Pitt matches up well, like I said, with Wisconsin because - like I just wrote - the Badgers aren't a high-level athletic team nor are they overly big and phyiscal in the middle. They defend well, they don't give up a lot of driving lanes -- but they do give up 3-point attempts. So really, this game probably comes down to one thing - Pitt's ability to knock down 3-pointers. If they shoot like they did against Georgia Tech or Virginia Tech, they will probably go home. If they shoot a reasonably good percentage, they will probably win.
Paul Zeise: My thoughts on the omissions - I assume you are talking about bubble teams that didn't get in. In general, bubble teams are bubble teams because they didn't do nearly enough to be considered locks so the annual crying about teams that did or didn't get in is silly because all had the opportunity to win one or two more games and put themselves over the top.
Read More
The one exception I will make is Monmouth -- I am not going to cry a river for them like some people are - but the message that the Committee has sent to the low and mid-majors in the past is that they have to go play somebody in the nonconference. Monmouth not only did, they BEAT somebody in the nonconference. USC, Notre Dame, Georgetown, UCLA -- they beat these teams. Whatever you think of UCLA and Georgetown, Monmouth isn't supposed to beat those teams on the road, ever.
And the fallacy of "well they lost to three sub-180 teams!!!" is two fold -- one, again, the teams in their conference aren't propped up in the RPI like the teams in major conferences so naturally a loss to one of them - no different than a loss by a major conference team to a bad team from its conference - is going to be a "bad loss" --- but also, the strength of Syracuse is supposedly wins and they supposedly trump losses.
Kevin: Do you ever see Jamie Dixon actually jumping ship after a tournament season?
Paul Zeise: Anything could happen, but the fact that he is signed until 2023 tells me he isn't likely to be leaving any time soon. He has it good here, he likes it here and frankly, he is making so much money now that the number of schools that could hire him away and pay him has dwindled to the point of just a handful. So, no, I think he will be here.
Carl: Biggest NCAA snub? I'll go with the Bonnies
Paul Zeise: For all the reasons I just laid out - I will say Monmouth. Look, St. Bonaventure falls into the category of teams that were supposed to be left out -- they didn't play anybody in their nonconference (only game was Syracuse and they lost) and so they don't have a leg to stand on against the power conference bubble teams. The powers that be can't make that claim about Monmouth.
Kelvin: Your thoughts on the bracket being leaked/two-hour selection show?
Paul Zeise: I think it is tremendous - I hated the idea of sitting there for two hours and thought it was a ridiculous money grab to try and make people do it. The fact that it all blew up was somewhat poetic justice. Now, I do feel bad for the teams that had the "suspense" moment of seeing their selection live on TV stolen from them but my guess is they all got over that really quickly
Tim: Pitt beat Syracuse 3 times and yet both are 10 seeds. What happened?
Paul Zeise: Syracuse was way overrated by the NCAA Selection Committee and Pitt was slightly overrated, that's what happened. I wouldn't have put them in and Pitt would have been a First Four team. Again - Syracuse was rewarded for playing a reasonably good nonconference schedule and winning the Battle 4 Atlantis. However, the message from the committee of "play someone" is nonsense when you consider that Pitt's nonconference schedule was an embarrassment, they lost to the one legitimate team they played, yet they get a 10 seed? Both teams were overvalued, in my opinion.
LA Matt: Do you agree with Jay Bilas that, instead of the conference tournament champion getting the automatic bid, it should go to the regular season champions? Maybe that would eliminate bids being taken away from legitimate teams like Monmouth and St. Bonnie?
Paul Zeise: No, as long as there are conference tournaments, there has to be a reason to play them and a reward for winning them. Conferences love the money grab and exposure that comes from having a conference tournament so they need to live with the fact that their best team might get left behind. That's part of the give and take of it. You can't have it both ways - you can't love the fact that your teams get TV games for a week and sell tickets but then complain when the wrong team wins.
Either get rid of conference tournaments or live with the results and understand that the winner gets the automatic bid.
If you take the automatic bid away from the conference tournaments of one-bid leagues, what exactly would be the point?
Now, the one thing I will say is the Ivy League may be on to something - they have a conference tournament now, but only the top four teams in the conference get to participate. So at least the regular season still matters and whoever wins it will be a team that has had a pretty good year
Ben: If the good Pitt team shows up this weekend any chance at a Sweet 16?
Paul Zeise: Yes, but good Pitt could also still lose to both Wisconsin and Xavier. I mean, Pitt could play really well but the Panthers still have limitations in size and athleticism and overall talent. Pitt will have to play well in order to advance but again, I think the larger question is -- will Pitt's good shooting show up. If Pitt shoots well Friday, they will win.
Zag: e did seeding the teams?
Paul Zeise: The committee doesn't look at matchups but magically look at some second-round matchup potential - Texas-Texas A&M, Kentucky-Indiana (absurd that they might play in second round), Michigan-Notre Dame followed by potentially Beilein against WVU and then perhaps Pitt against WVU.. Again, I could go on and on and on about all the ways they screwed this up (FOUR AMERICAN TEAMS???? I'm thinking, C'mon man....) but I'll spare you the details.
Guest: If they beat Wisconsin, Pitt's chances vs Xavier are?
Paul Zeise: I think Xavier will be a very tough matchup for Pitt - they athleticism, they have really good guards, they can score, they can defend - they are a really good team but here is the thing: I think all of the Big East teams are extremely overrated. I don't see a ton of huge wins out of conference for any of them and I think they will be exposed as such in this Tournament. So I give Pitt a better chance here than I would against a lot of of other teams.
Matt: Pitt seems to match up well with Wisky...No potent big men, no stable of ridiculous athletic guards. Your thoughts?
Paul Zeise: Yes, I would agree. I think, like I wrote, it will come down to Pitt's ability to make shots.
LA Matt: Does Pitino survive this latest scandal in his career? If so, what does that say about athletics and its place in the world of higher education?
Paul Zeise: I think he does and it says nothing about the state of athletics - and says a lot about the state of athletics at Louisville. They have 20,000+ seat arena to fill every night, as long as he is there they will fill it because they will be good. So it seems like the administration there is committed to holding its nose and keeping him around.
Skip: What are your thoughts on the Final Four?
Paul Zeise: I haven't looked at it close enough yet to really have a good feel for it so I'll go about it this way - if every team plays it's absolute "A" game, then North Carolina will win. I think they have the best combination of size, athleticism and experience. Other teams have more high end NBA talent but it is all young. So I like the Tar Heels but the problem is, we haven't seen them play 40 whole minutes for six games in a row yet. I do think, however, they will get out of that region. The Midwest, everyone loves Michigan State for obvious reasons (they are really good) but here is another reason to like them: That region stinks. I mean, are they serious with this? If Virginia and Mich State aren't playing in the Regional Final there is something wrong. I see a lot of junk in that region. The West is a Region where I could see one of those teams in the middle - like Texas - emerge and mostly because the best teams in that region are all defensively challenged and way too reliant on shooting and that is usually a recipe for disaster. The South is Kansas region to lose. I don't think there is any question about it. The "sleeper" pick everyone is in love with is Cal because Cal has two legit NBA lottery picks and a bunch of other guys with high level talent. But I don't think they are coached particularly well and that will show up more often than not at some point and usually early on in the NCAA Tournament.
LA Matt: Doesn't the Ivy League's regular season champ (this year, Yale) get their automatic bid, not the tournament champ? Although I agree that the reason for post season conference tournaments would be diminished (as would ESPN's money monopoly with them) without an automatic bid, the winning teams take bid away from legitimate NCAA teams with every upset. take up biwould still give lit menm m0 tourIp get ozsalra se
Paul Zeise: The Ivy League voted this year that starting next year, the top four teams will play in a conference tournament and the winner will get the automatic bid.
Paul Zeise: OK, on that note I have to run, I have a lot of work to do. Thanks for chatting, we will do it again soon.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.