On an afternoon when he was peppered with dozens of questions, there was one that stuck with Pat Narduzzi a little longer.

Attending his first ACC football media day as Pitt’s coach, Narduzzi was asked about being a part of what the questioner termed “the Pittsburgh-Syracuse rivalry.” He collected his thoughts, took a deep breath and answered.

“Is it a rivalry?” he asked, cracking a smile. “I guess it’s a rivalry.”

The son of a football coach who grew up 70 miles from Pittsburgh, watching the Panthers regularly square off against regional rivals such as West Virginia and Penn State, Narduzzi’s confusion wasn’t feigned. It was understandable.

Advertise with us

During an era of widespread change in college athletics, where schools have bolted to new conferences for the promise of heartier paydays, rivalries have suffered, and local college football fans don’t have to look far to see the damage. Pitt, Penn State and West Virginia have seen their rivalries vanish as a result of conference realignment.

Some worry the disappearance of rivalries means an otherwise thriving sport is missing an important part of its appeal.

After all, what’s college football without a little hate?

“It’s a tragedy,” ESPN college football analyst Ed Cunningham said.

“We’ve allowed the money-grab that has become college football and television money and the changing of conferences to try to get bigger television footprints to really harm the game. It has harmed it for the people we shouldn’t be harming it for, which are the players and the fans.”

Advertise with us

Some of college football’s most fabled matchups, ones that divided families and dictated the national-title picture, have been abruptly erased from schedules in the past decade, leaving fans and programs with nothing but memories.

Gone are Texas-Texas A&M and Nebraska-Oklahoma, both of which were once Thanksgiving weekend staples. Locally, Pitt and West Virginia, two schools separated by 75 miles, no longer play. Even Kansas-Missouri, a fierce rivalry dating back to when the states argued about the morality of slavery, has vanished.

Though the death of rivalries has accelerated during this recent wave of conference realignment, Penn State and Pitt suffered its effects more than 20 years ago when the Nittany Lions joined the Big Ten. The two teams had played annually from 1935 to 1992, but that ended in 1993, the first year Penn State played in its new conference. The teams briefly renewed their series for four years and are scheduled to meet four times in the next few years, but it isn’t the same.

Nearly any rivalry that is now defunct didn’t end because the hate that bonded two schools magically evaporated; rather, one or both of the institutions found a home in a new league, eliminating a guaranteed meeting.

These moves were largely financially motivated, and for many schools, they have paid off.

Advertise with us

Pitt, according to a report this year from USA Today, received $18.9 million from the ACC, nearly double what it made in its final year in the Big East. In its fourth year as a Big 12 member, West Virginia received $23 million from the conference. Once an independent, Penn State is part of the money-printing Goliath that is the Big Ten, which paid every full-fledged member $32 million in the 2014-15 fiscal year.

Those gains, however, haven’t come without losses.

Pitt’s Backyard Brawl with West Virginia is extinct, and though the Panthers will resume their series with Penn State from 2016-19, no promises have been made beyond those four meetings. West Virginia now gets annual frays with Oklahoma and Texas, but it regularly plays schools in places such as Lubbock and Waco, Texas, instead of one about an hour north on I-79.

“As far as fan participation and fans getting really into it, those close rivalries, that’s what makes college football,” former Pitt coach and current Fox Sports analyst Dave Wannstedt said. “Times change. I remember at Pitt, I used to enjoy the Pitt-West Virginia week because it gave me a chance to talk about the history of Pitt and the great tradition at Pitt and some of the great games versus West Virginia.

“It was an opportunity to really educate your players a little bit more about your own tradition. For a lot of reasons, I think they need to get that back on the books. They need to play that.”

Advertise with us

The Nittany Lions, too, are in a curious position. A university with an East Coast footprint that plays in a Midwestern conference, Penn State can’t claim a primary rival in Ohio State or Michigan, both of which are too preoccupied with one another. And much of the vitriol that exists between Penn State and new conference mates Maryland and Rutgers — two schools the Nittany Lions are a combined 58-4-1 against all time — is largely one-sided.

But athletic director Sandy Barbour is not convinced Penn State even needs a rival.

“No, we’re Penn State,” she said. “I love college football. I love talking about rivalries, but what happens on Saturday afternoon with 107,000 people in a stadium is what our fan base, what our community, what our alumni and what our university get fired up about. I’ve seen over the course of one year that it really doesn’t matter. It’s about us.”

Of course, the death of bygone rivalries doesn’t preclude new ones from sprouting. TCU and Baylor have rekindled some old Southwest Conference animosity in their three years together in the Big 12, and both enter the upcoming season as consensus top-10 teams. Texas A&M may have lost Texas, but it has started to develop new feuds with Alabama and LSU in the SEC.

The creation of new rivalries, though, can feel forced. Connecticut infamously created a trophy for its “Civil Conflict” against Central Florida, a team the Huskies have only played since 2013 — and even then, Central Florida coach George O’Leary bristled at the idea, openly wondering why there was a trophy for a game against a team he wasn’t sure was even a rival.

Advertise with us

The existence of such meaningless trophies led Minnesota and Nebraska to create the “$5 Bits of Broken Chair Trophy,” an idea spawned by a Twitter exchange between Minnesota mascot Goldy the Gopher and Faux Pelini, a parody account of then-Cornhuskers coach Bo Pelini.

Politicians have even entered the fray, proposing legislation in states such as South Carolina and Texas to protect non-conference rivalries within state borders. So far, those efforts have been fruitless, but they stem from a fear that non-conference rivalries, even ones as storied as Clemson-South Carolina, are increasingly in jeopardy.

The Big 12 and Pac-12 already play nine-game conference schedules, while the Big Ten will adopt that model beginning in 2016. There’s increasing speculation about whether the SEC will make the switch, and former Miami and North Carolina coach Butch Davis said the ACC is “probably very close to that.”

With only three non-conference games on the schedule, the worry is that existing rivalries such as Georgia-Georgia Tech may be threatened and dormant ones such as Pitt-West Virginia will be that much more difficult to reignite.

Ultimately, some believe that hurts the quality of the game.

Advertise with us

“I think it becomes bland,” Davis said. “Whether it’s Oklahoma-Oklahoma State or Georgia-Georgia Tech, every school has got a rivalry game on their schedule that the fans for decades and decades have cherished, argued and fought over. It’s critical to the future appeal of college football. You want to try to keep those things alive.”

Audrey Snyder and Sam Werner contributed. Craig Meyer: cmeyer@post-gazette.com and Twitter @CraigMeyerPG.