AMELIA ISLAND, Fla. — Jamie Dixon and Pat Narduzzi were able to use the NCAA’s graduate transfer rule to beef up their rosters this offseason.

But if their incoming boss had a choice, that won’t be the case for much longer.

At the ACC meetings, which have been relatively low-key this week, this is the one topic that seems to have drawn the deepest line in the sand.

Currently, players who earn their undergraduate degree from one school can transfer to another institution for graduate school without having to sit out a year. But incoming Pitt athletic director Scott Barnes said that rule “has developed a culture of free agency.”

Advertise with us

“I believe that we need to make a change,” Barnes said.

Even though Narduzzi has pursued graduate transfers this offseason, he said he supports a change in the rule.

“Let’s say Tyler Boyd got to his fifth year, he graduates, we know he’s a great player,” Narduzzi said. “But he says, ‘I think I’m going to go play at USC my final year.’ What does that do for Pitt?

“Here we are trying to graduate our kids early and get them out before the three-and-a-half years, and all of a sudden, now they’re leaving you.”

Dixon has added two graduate transfers to Pitt’s basketball roster this offseason in former Coppin State guard Sterling Smith and former Brown forward Rafael Maia.

Advertise with us

Dixon said Smith and Maia differ from most graduate transfers, since most switch schools after earning a four-year degree. Smith needed only three years to earn his undergraduate degree, and Maia would have been ineligible to continue playing in the Ivy League as a graduate student.

“To put those two guys in the graduate transfer conversation is doing a disservice to the conversation because they’re different,” Dixon said.

He also was less adamant than Barnes and Narduzzi that the rule needs an adjustment. Dixon saw it more as inevitable than a necessity.

“I think that’s where it’s headed,” Dixon said. “It’s hard because every situation is different. But for the vast majority of them, I think the reasoning is the rule is not serving its purpose.”

And that last point is why Barnes is so opposed to the current rule. While the spirit is for players to work toward a graduate degree, few actually do so. According to the NCAA, less than a third of graduate transfers in football and men’s basketball actually earn graduate degrees at their new school. For football, almost half are gone by the end of their first semester after the season concludes.

Advertise with us

One tweak Barnes suggested is to make graduate transfers ineligible for their first year on campus, forcing them to work toward the graduate degree.

“That’s the loophole that needs to be closed, in my mind,” Barnes said. “Have them transfer, have them sit out a year, have them really work on getting a degree, then have a year to play.”

Not everyone in the room agrees with him, though. Few athletic directors will have their football programs more affected this offseason than Notre Dame’s Jack Swarbrick, as Irish quarterback Everett Golson announced last week he would be playing his final season elsewhere.

But even though his football team is losing it’s starting quarterback, Swarbrick doesn’t think the rule needs a major change.

“I think if our primary mission is educational, and we certify that a young man has earned a degree from our university, I’m certifying that they’re OK to work for Pricewaterhouse  or a bank somewhere or to go into a graduate program at another school,” Swarbrick said. “I’m certifying that they can go do stuff elsewhere. I don’t think I ought to be limiting that in an athletic sphere.”

Advertise with us

Similarly, Clemson coach Dabo Swinney hasn’t taken too many graduate transfers, but says he doesn’t have a problem when his players leave for their final year.

“Mostly, they just wanted an opportunity to play more,” Swinney said. “He’s earned his degree, and if the rules allow that the way they are right now, hey, good for him.”

Sam Werner: swerner@post-gazette.com and Twitter @SWernerPG.