Pitt’s first eight basketball seasons under coach Jamie Dixon worked out about as well as things could have without winning a national championship or making it to a Final Four.

The Panthers were 216-60 (a .783 winning percentage) and went 98-38 in conference games (.721) in those eight seasons. More important, they made the NCAA tournament all eight seasons, earned four trips to the Sweet 16 and one Elite Eight trip in 2009.

Add in a Big East tournament title in 2008 and two regular-season conference championships in 2004 and 2011, and it was clear the program was on the verge of becoming one of the nation’s best.

But things haven’t been the same since, and the program that was on the precipice of greatness is now mired in mediocrity.

Advertise with us

In the past four years, the Panthers are 91-50 (.645 winning percentage), and 36-36 in conference play, missing out on the NCAA tournament twice. This past season they finished 19-15, ending with a lackluster home loss to George Washington in the first round of the NIT to break Dixon’s string of 11 consecutive 20-win seasons.

In the past four seasons, the Panthers are 7-21 against top 25 teams and 3-11 against top 10 teams after going 37-31 against top 25 teams and 20-9 against top 10 teams in the previous eight seasons.

So, what happened?

There is no simple answer. The Panthers changed leagues, missed on a couple recruiting classes and lost a key player to the NBA after one season, and all of those issues contributed to the slide.

Dixon said nobody has higher expectations for the Panthers than he does, and he still believes the program’s best days are still to come. “The guys are working hard already like they do every year,” he said. “Nothing has changed here about what we do and what we need to do to be successful.“

Advertise with us

Recruiting misses

Dixon’s 2011 recruiting class was supposed to be one of his best. But three of its players — Khem Birch, John Johnson and Malcolm Gilbert — were gone before they could make an impact.

The fourth member of the class, Durand Johnson, is leaving the program, the school announced earlier this month. Johnson missed half of the 2013-14 season with an ACL injury and was suspended for the 2014-15 season.

Had the class stayed intact, it likely would have had a big impact the past two seasons. Perhaps Gilbert and Birch more than the others, because, as big men, they would have filled the team’s most glaring weakness — its lack of size.

In 2012, Dixon brought in Chris Jones, James Robinson and the marquee player of the class, 7-foot center Steven Adams, one of the highest-ranked recruits the Panthers have signed. Adams had a solid freshman season, but then bolted for the NBA. Without Adams, Birch and Gilbert, the Panthers lacked a center heading into 2013-14.

Advertise with us

"I think it is ridiculous that people think Jamie, who is a fantastic basketball coach, all of the sudden forgot how to coach."

Dixon tried to find a transfer to fill the void. But junior-college transfer Joseph Uchebo’s chronic knee issues limited his effectiveness and availability, and Rutgers transfer Derrick Randall and junior-college transfer Tyrone Haughton didn’t pan out, either.

“Continuity is a good thing, continuity is what every program strives for,” Dixon said. “Retention of your players that you developed is, in general, a very good thing, and that is something that we have to get back to.

“I mean, obviously we didn’t have the senior class we thought we were going to have four years ago so we weren’t the team [this year] we thought we would be four years ago. But we also didn’t have the team we thought we were going to have in September.”

The signings of elite prospects such as Birch and Adams were signs Pitt was taking another step toward the upper echelon of college basketball. But often those players leave the program for the NBA or transfer. Dixon said he didn’t adequately replace either player but said it wasn’t for lack of trying. And he fights the notion that he is unwilling or unable to go after the “one-and-done” players in the future.

Advertise with us

“People want to label you, they say, ‘You are against one-and-done guys,’ and my answer is we had a one-and-done guy and we have had other guys leave early as well,” Dixon said. “We want to recruit the best guys. We want to keep recruiting the best kids we can find, and we feel like we can and have and will continue to do so.”

Dixon said there is a “new world” in college basketball where transfers allow teams to “seemingly start over almost every year.” That has been a game-changer for teams like Pitt that were built on continuity.

There are about 475 Division I basketball players looking to transfer this offseason, and many will be eligible to play next season. Dixon said the Panthers coaching staff is working hard to find a few players to fill out the roster for next season, and the Panthers already have signed one to a scholarship — Sterling Smith, a 6-foot-4 guard from Coppin State.

But Dixon has not had a lot of success with transfers, with two notable exceptions: Mike Cook, who transferred from East Carolina in 2005, and Sheldon Jeter, who transferred from Vanderbilt in 2013 and has two more seasons of eligibility.

A new league

Advertise with us

Pitt’s move from the Big East to the ACC in 2013 has led to a period of transition for the basketball program.

Dixon said the move is good for Pitt in the long run because he believes the new-look ACC is the best basketball league in the country. But, in the short term, Dixon has had to rebrand his program and focus on different geographic areas to build a recruiting base.

“It is true, it’s no big secret, that changing leagues changes what you can do in recruiting and who you recruit and what you are selling,” Dixon said. “So we have had to adjust, and we feel like we have adjusted.

“Our thing was always selling playing in the Big East tournament and playing in New York and getting guys from those areas, but we had to make some changes.”

Dixon said the ACC is an easy sell for Pitt because of its prestige, but some question where it’s a good move for Pitt basketball because the ACC does not have strong ties to the urban areas in the Northeast where the Panthers have had recruiting success.

Advertise with us

Four years ago, while most Pitt fans and observers reveled in the move from the Big East to the ACC, Sporting News national college basketball writer Mike DeCourcy wrote a column titled, “A move to the ACC might destroy Pitt basketball.”

DeCourcy, who grew up in Pittsburgh and has followed the program for nearly 40 years, heard a lot of negative feedback about the column because the ACC was seen as the lifeline Pitt’s athletic program needed to survive when the Big East started to crumble. While that might have been true for football and other sports, DeCourcy’s opinion was that the basketball program was moving away from its identity by leaving the Big East.

“I think it is ridiculous that people think Jamie, who is a fantastic basketball coach, all of the sudden forgot how to coach,” DeCourcy said in an interview. “But my point back then was Pitt’s program with [former coach] Ben Howland and Jamie Dixon was built on selling the Petersen [Events] Center and the Big East.

“And the Big East was important because it was the league the players in the areas that Dixon went to recruit — like Philadelphia, like New York — grew up with. And now they don’t have that component, and what’s left for them to sell to those players?”

What makes it more challenging, DeCourcy said, is the Western Pennsylvania basketball talent pool often runs dry.

Advertise with us

“What people don’t understand is that Pitt is a really, really good program, but to get players, they must go places where players have to choose to drive past several other really good programs to get to Pitt,” DeCourcy said. “It is not an easy problem and ‘just recruit better’ is not an answer.”

Dixon is no longer able to sell high school prospects on the idea of playing at Madison Square Garden in the Big East tournament, which means he has to focus less on recruiting the Northeast.

“And so now, where do they go to find players? North Carolina? Virginia? Those kids all have plenty of options in their own state if they want to play in the ACC, and kids from the Midwest look at the Big Ten or Big 12.”

"It is very rare that you can have the continuity in college basketball that was part of the game in the past."

Dixon does not believe Pitt’s move to the ACC has closed the door to Northeast recruiting, saying the coaching staff will still recruit those areas. And, he added, the ACC has allowed him to expand his recruiting base to areas he could not have gone before.

Advertise with us

Looking ahead

Though Pitt has had to alter its recruiting tactics, Dixon said he plans to protect its identity as a program rooted in toughness and defense. The defensive struggles last season had more to do with injuries and depth than anything else.

“Offensively, the numbers were better than the defense this year, yeah, but I don’t know that means we are becoming an offensive team,” he said.

DeCourcy doesn’t believe Pitt is in serious trouble, but he believes these next few years are critical for its survival as one of the nation’s top 25 or 30 programs.

Though the Panthers are coming off a tough season, Dixon said they are only one year removed from a trip to the ACC tournament semifinals and the Round of 32 in the NCAA tournament. And, as he looks ahead to next year, the Panthers have eight of their top nine scorers returning, four of five starters, a recruiting class that includes a 7-foot junior-college transfer (Rozelle Nix) and two more scholarships to fill.

Advertise with us

He said the returning players — with another summer of weight training, conditioning and basketball workouts under their belt — should improve, and with new players arriving, the team should have better depth. And most of the returning players are juniors, sophomores and freshmen, meaning the Panthers should enjoy the type of roster continuity Dixon had in his first eight seasons. 

“I think the reality is nearly everybody is starting over every year, and it is very rare that you can have the continuity in college basketball that was part of the game in the past,” Dixon said. “We have a chance to achieve that again over the next few seasons, and that will give us a chance to get back to where we have been in the past.”

Paul Zeise: pzeise@post-gazette.com and Twitter @paulzeise.