CHARLOTTESVILLE, Va. — At a certain point, the question will no longer be what has happened to Pitt since the Panthers started the season red-hot. The question will be what happened in those three games that allowed this team to look so dominant.

That point might have come Saturday night.

Pitt couldn’t overcome a lifeless first half and a couple of key mistakes as the Panthers lost their third game in a row, a 24-19 defeat at the hands of Virginia.

“A lot of it does come down to making those plays in those moments to give yourself a chance to win the game or not,” Pitt coach Paul Chryst said. “That’s what it comes down to. When you convert on third down, when you find a way to score.”

Advertise with us

Voytik showed some flashes in desperate situations, but was mostly uneven and finished 16 of 30 for 195 yards, two touchdowns and a key interception. And trailing early, Pitt never really had a chance to get its running game — the staple of the Panthers’ offense — moving.

James Conner finished with 83 yards on 21 carries, his second consecutive game under 100 yards after going over 150 in five in a row.

Pitt’s defense mostly contained the Cavaliers offense, but was done in by a couple of big plays in the second quarter, a 15-minute stretch in which Virginia turned a 3-3 game into a 24-3 halftime lead.

For as dismal as the Panthers looked in the first half, they came out with a fire in the third quarter. After forcing Virginia into a three-and-out, Dontez Ford blocked a Cavaliers punt that gave Pitt the ball at the Virginia 31-yard line.

Even then, the offense moved in fits and starts — including a key false start penalty on 3rd-and-goal — but Voytik salvaged the drive by throwing a 17-yard touchdown pass to Manasseh Garner on third down to cut the Cavaliers’ lead to 24-10.

Advertise with us

“We didn’t make any changes,” Voytik said. “We knew what we were doing was working, we just needed some time to get them the ball and eliminate those pre-snap penalties.”

After another defensive stop, Pitt looked poised to make it a game heading into the fourth. Running back James Conner took a handoff on 2nd-and-goal from the Virginia 2, and stretched the ball across the goal-line as he went to the ground. After a review, the officials rules that his knee was down before the ball crossed the line, and a snap infraction penalty and failed third-down pass followed. Chryst said he thought about going for it on 4th-and-goal from the Virginia 6, but ultimately settled for the field goal to make it 24-13.

Pitt added a late touchdown after an electric 45-yard punt return by Tyler Boyd, but failed to recover the ensuing onside kick, ending any hope of a miraculous comeback.

“It’s tough to keep your head up after one loss, you know what I’m saying?” Voytik said. “Every one hurts, hurts the same. Doesn’t matter how many there are in a row.”

Ultimately, though, the game was decided by a 10 minute stretch in the second quarter.

Advertise with us

For the first few drives of the game, it looked like the teams were poised for a repeat of Pitt’s ugly 14-3 win at Heinz Field last season. Neither offense could generate much momentum, and the teams swapped field goals to end the first quarter tied, 3-3.

But once the second quarter started, Virginia’s offense took off, while Pitt’s remained stalled.

With 10:51 left in the second quarter, Cavalier running back Kevin Parks sprinted through the middle of the line for a 48-yard touchdown run, the second-longest run the Panthers have allowed this season.

Pitt, meanwhile, was struggling to even move the ball forward. The Panthers’ first drive of the second quarter went backwards 13 yards thanks to a sack and tackle in the backfield, and their next one moved the same direction thanks to a false start penalty on TJ Clemmings.

The Panthers finished the game with 10 penalties for 75 yards.

Advertise with us

“Virginia, their defense, they created some of the negative yards and then we compounded it with the pre-snap penalties, that makes it harder,” Chryst said.

The Cavaliers added another touchdown to extend their lead to 17-3 with 3:58 left in the first half on a three-yard touchdown pass from Matt Johns to Khalek Shepherd. The key play of the scoring drive was a 28-yard trick play where receiver Miles Gooch took a lateral and tossed it downfield to tight end Zacahary Swanson to set up the score three plays later.

Just as it felt like Pitt needed to show some sign of life heading into halftime, the Panthers did just the opposite. On the third play of Pitt’s ensuing drive, Voytik scrambled right and threw a ball right into the arms of Virginia linebacker Max Valles, who returned it 35 yards for another Virginia touchdown to put his team up 24-3 heading into halftime.

Pitt has an off week next week before returning to ACC action with a Thursday night home game against Virginia Tech.

While the ACC’s Coastal Division is still wide open, the Panthers are trending in the wrong direction. After a 3-0 start, the primetime game against Virginia Tech seemed poised to be a chance for Pitt to announce its presence as a legitimate division contender. Instead, it has almost become a must-win game if the Panthers want to salvage their season.

Advertise with us

“You always want to play again and go with it, but we’re going to make the most of [the off week],” Chryst said. “We’re going to make it a good bye week for us and a chance to come back and play a good Virginia Tech team.”

Sam Werner: swerner@post-gazette.com and Twitter @SWernerPG