WASHINGTON -- The head of the Bowl Championship Series told college and university presidents that the Obama administration was unlikely to challenge the legality of its selection process -- and argued that even if the system were to be found illegal, so would a playoff.

Bill Hancock, the BCS executive director, made the assurance in a Feb. 4, 2010, memo to the group's presidential oversight committee after the Obama administration said it was considering several steps to review the legality of the BCS. The Associated Press obtained a copy of the memo from a state open records request filed with Western Kentucky University, whose president, Gary Ransdell, serves on the oversight committee.

Hancock's memo offers some insight into the thinking of those who run the top tier of college football's postseason and are charged with setting up a No. 1 vs. No. 2 national title game. He wrote it in response to a Jan. 29, 2010, letter the Justice Department sent to Sen. Orrin Hatch, a Utah Republican and BCS critic who had asked for a DOJ investigation to determine if the BCS violated antitrust laws.

Assistant Attorney General Ronald Weich told Hatch in that letter the department was reviewing his request and other materials to determine whether to open such an investigation, and was considering other options such as asking the Federal Trade Commission to review the legality of the BCS under consumer protection laws.

Advertise with us

But Hancock told the school presidents that a government investigation was unlikely.

"Given all the other issues facing our country, we find it doubtful that the White House is seriously considering contemplating action on the series of items outlined in the letter," wrote Hancock, who said he had discussed the DOJ letter with BCS advisers in Washington. The Justice Department declined to comment on the BCS memo.

The government's interest in the BCS has continued this year. In May, the DOJ's top antitrust official sent a letter to NCAA president Mark Emmert asking why there was no playoff at college football's highest level, saying that "serious questions continue to arise suggesting the current Bowl Championship Series system may not be conducted consistent with the competition principles expressed in the federal antitrust laws."

Two days later, the BCS pushed back, issuing a news release titled, "WHAT THEY'RE SAYING: About Government Intervention in College Football." It included a sampling of commentators criticizing the idea of the Justice Department poking around on the issue.

In an email obtained by the AP under a Freedom of Information Act request with Northern Illinois University, the school's president, John Peters, forwarded the news release to a colleague with the note, "Take that DOJ." Peters is a member of the presidential oversight committee.

Advertise with us

Emmert responded to the Justice Department that its questions were best directed at the BCS, and the DOJ later called Hancock in for a voluntary meeting with 10 officials from the department's antitrust division in Washington. To date, the department has not launched an investigation. In addition to the DOJ review, the Utah attorney general, Mark Shurtleff, has said he plans to file an antitrust lawsuit against the BCS.

Critics and playoff proponents who have urged the Justice Department to investigate the BCS contend it unfairly gives some schools preferential access to the title game and other premier bowls -- along with the money that comes with it. Under the BCS, the champions of six conferences have automatic bids to play in top-tier bowl games; the other five conferences don't.

Hancock and other supporters of the BCS, which was established in 1998, say the system has improved access to the bowls for those other five conferences, and has benefited all schools that play college football. In a recent interview, Hancock said his 2010 memo still reflects his views on the issue.

Nebraska Chancellor Harvey Perlman, who was chairman of the presidential oversight committee at the time of the memo, said the logic behind concluding a playoff system would be equally suspect under antitrust laws is simple. "If it was held that it's illegal for us to get together [to create the BCS], it's hard to see how getting together to create a playoff wouldn't reach the same result," he said.

But some sports antitrust experts challenged that conclusion.

Advertise with us

"I don't think that's true at all," said Gary Roberts, dean of the Indiana University Law School in Indianapolis. "I think you could craft a playoff system that would not have many of the anticompetitive aspects to it that the current BCS system has."

Matt Mitten, a law professor and director of the National Sports Law Institute at Marquette University in Milwaukee, said that what makes the BCS legally vulnerable is that some conferences have preferential access to the BCS bowl games over other conferences.

"That's the thing that makes it a potential antitrust violation," he said. "Not simply because there is an agreement to try to come up with a championship game. The antitrust laws don't prevent colleges from getting together and trying to devise a means to create a national championship game that consumers want. It's only when it unreasonably restrains trade."