During his tenure at Alabama, legendary coach Paul "Bear" Bryant always insisted that his salary stay $1 below that of the university president.
It was a noble idea, but in the current college football climate, it is hard to envision such a scenario playing out. Coaches command million-dollar salaries and often are the highest-paid employee at their school. In a sport where players constantly come and go, a head coach can be the fixture that defines a program.
Each of the three schools in the region -- Pitt, West Virginia and Penn State -- will enter this season with questions at the head-coaching position. Not all of the questions are the same.
THE MONEY TRAIL
Schools whose football teams produced the highest revenue for the 2009 season -- the most recent season for which data was available (dollar figures in millions):
1. Texas, 93.94
2. Georgia, 70.83
3. Penn State, 70.20
4. Michigan, 63.18
5. Florida, 68.71
Graham will take over at Pitt after being hired in early January. The school originally hired former Miami (Ohio) coach Mike Haywood to replace Dave Wannstedt, but fired him two weeks later after he was arrested on domestic-violence charges.
At West Virginia, Dana Holgorsen was supposed to replace Bill Stewart as head coach in 2012 after serving as Stewart's offensive coordinator for one season. Instead, Stewart resigned in June, giving the reins to Holgorsen a year early.
And then there is Joe Paterno, who is 84 and entering his 46th year as Penn State's head coach. Compared to Pitt and West Virginia, the Nittany Lions' coaching situation might seem like the model of stability. But 2011 is the last year of Paterno's current contract, and questions persist over how much longer he should keep coaching.
In the current college football climate, coaches are responsible for more than just Xs and Os. They have to promote the program, maintain a squeaky-clean image and manage an entire support staff. In many ways, the job description of a BCS-conference football coach is similar to that of a CEO of a Fortune 500 company.
"The CEO is one of the most visible emblems of an organization, and college football coaches typically are in the same situation," said John Delaney, dean of Pitt's College of Business. "They are the face of the team and the organization. In some instances, even the face of their university."
Graham has used that spotlight to promote his brand of "high-octane football." The phrase appears on billboards and in television commercials, and the web address highoctanefootball.com takes you to Pitt's official football site.
He has the credentials to back it up. Last year, Graham's Tulsa team ranked sixth in Division I-A with 41.4 points per game.
Graham will be tasked with awakening a program that had started to stagnate. The Panthers won at least eight games each of the final three years of Wannstedt's tenure, but never made a BCS bowl game. He also faces the unique challenge of winning back fans who may have been turned off by the Haywood saga.
"Anytime you go through a little adversity, it's just so important to regroup and come together," Graham said at his introductory press conference. "I just want to ask them to come together to give us a chance to earn their trust. And we're going to do that."
Donald Hambrick, a management professor at Penn State's Smeal College of Business, said it was important for any incoming executive to set realistic initial benchmarks.
"You can't do everything at once, but there's a persuasion process that has to be followed," Hambrick said. "You have to demonstrate and convince people of the merit of the changes you're trying to make and provide some compelling evidence for why they need to be made."
Delaney added that the most important early task is clearly and effectively communicating goals, strategies and objectives, which Graham has done by promoting his "high-octane football."
Holgorsen has taken a more reserved approach. Unlike Graham, he is not gracing the cover of the team's media guide. Holgorsen and athletic director Oliver Luck have tried to make its coaching transition as seamless as possible -- the way it was supposed to be.
West Virginia hired Holgorsen as its offensive coordinator in December and designated him as head coach-in-waiting, set to take over in 2012.
Such a concept has gained popularity in recent years. Florida State, Texas, Oregon and Wisconsin are among the schools that have tried it -- with mixed results. Hambrick said this was a very common strategy in the corporate world.
"The advantages, of course, are continuity, an opportunity for the new person to work in the shadows and be mentored by the outgoing person," Hambrick said. "The drawback is that sometimes this anointment occurs two, three, four years before the incumbent is going to take off, and things can change a lot in the meantime."
For West Virginia, it was only a matter of months before things changed. In May, Holgorsen allegedly was asked to leave a casino because of unruly behavior. A few weeks later, a former Post-Gazette reporter said Stewart told him to "dig up dirt" on Holgorsen. Stewart resigned under pressure a few weeks later.
A disciple of former Texas Tech coach Mike Leach, Holgorsen is known primarily for his pass-heavy system. As an offensive coordinator at Oklahoma State last year, he oversaw an attack that averaged 44.2 points per game, third-best in the country.
Holgorsen faces many challenges similar to Graham but also must adjust to being a Division I head coach for the first time.
"It will be a new experience for me," he said. "Everyone has a time to be a first-game or first-time head coach, right? You've got to be in that situation at some point."
When he was hired, Holgorsen brought in his own offensive coaching staff. Coordinator Jeff Casteel's defensive staff, though, consists of all holdovers from Stewart's regime. From a management perspective, Delaney said it was important to build camaraderie and trust among the two groups right away.
"You want people to maintain their confidence in the team and organization and not begin to wonder whether someone who doesn't understand the approach made a bad decision," Delaney said.
While Holgorsen has gone about installing his own offensive scheme, he has embraced the traditions of West Virginia football. He spoke multiple times in his introductory press conference about how Mountaineer football was "bigger than him." The emphasis has been on putting the program first, for the sake of continuity.
Hambrick said that the correct approach to a new leadership position varies. While Graham may need to differentiate himself clearly from Wannstedt and Haywood, Holgorsen's best bet could be trying to maintain the status quo.
"What you don't want is to come in with kind of a swashbuckling approach, [saying] 'We've got to change a lot,' if that's not called for," Hambrick said.
While Pitt and West Virginia break in new coaches, Paterno will return at Penn State
Earlier this month, he was hospitalized after a collision with a receiver at practice, once again raising the question of how much longer he would be able to coach.
Paterno is in the final year of his three-year contract, but there are no indications his career is near the end.
"Is this the last year of my contract?" he joked at Big Ten media day. "I don't even know I got a contract. I don't pay attention to that."
Hambrick compared Paterno to former General Electric CEO Jack Welch. While most CEOs last eight or nine years, Welch led GE for 20. Hambrick cited Welch's ability to adapt to changing business climates, specifically his implementation of a modern approach to quality control. Similarly, Paterno has had to shift his offensive strategy. Over the years, the Nittany Lions have moved from a "three yards and a cloud of dust" offense to a more wide-open system.
"The prescription would be to adapt," Hambrick said. "But the reality is that long-term people have a hard time doing that because they, almost by definition, can point to their successes to date and the formula that got them there."
All three coaches will be critical to their teams' success this fall. Graham and Holgorsen will have to avoid any hiccups installing their systems, and Paterno must avoid the "should he, shouldn't he" retirement debate if Penn State loses a few games.
They have to be tacticians, motivators and public-relations experts, all rolled into one.
That's why they pay them the big bucks.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.