After Penn State lost at Iowa Saturday night, its second lopsided loss to a ranked opponent this season, the Nittany Lions dropped out of The Associated Press Top 25 when the new poll came out Sunday. Penn State was the third of the area's three Division I-A teams to drop out of the poll after starting the season ranked.

It is the first time since the fifth week of the 2005 season that Penn State, Pitt and West Virginia are all unranked. That year, Pitt was the only team of the three to start the season ranked and lost to Notre Dame in the season opener. Penn State and West Virginia had strong seasons and finished No. 3 and No. 5 in the AP's final poll.

This season, Pitt started at No. 15, Penn State No. 19 and West Virginia No. 25. But Penn State and Pitt each have two losses after the first five weeks of the season and West Virginia has one.

For the second week in a row, no teams from the Big East are ranked. West Virginia is 11 points behind No. 25 Air Force.

Advertise with us

Air Force is one of three teams from the Mountain West Conference that are ranked. No. 5 TCU and No. 10 Utah are the others. Two teams from the Western Athletic Conference are ranked. Boise State is No. 4 and Nevada is No. 21.

The Mountain West and WAC do not receive automatic bids to the Bowl Championship Series, but their teams have been gaining more respect among voters this season as the Big East and Atlantic Coast Conference are receiving negative reviews from the pollsters.

The ACC only has two ranked teams -- No. 13 Miami and No. 23 Florida State.

The Post-Gazette canvassed the voters in the AP poll. The combination of the mid-major conference success stories of recent years and an all-time negative rating of the Big East has factored into the voting process.

"It probably is the lowest the Big East has gone in my estimation, but I didn't think it was going to be this bad," said Steve Conroy of the Boston Herald, who has the lone AP poll vote in Massachusetts. "I had both Pitt and Connecticut in the preseason Top 25. The fact that it has gone down the tubes this year is a bit of a surprise. And, yes, I am giving non-BCS schools stronger consideration because of the recent track record of teams like Boise State and Utah."

Advertise with us

"I can't recall ever having a lower opinion of the Big East," said Jon Solomon of the Birmingham News. "This is only my second year as a voter, so it is hard to say if I am voting for more non-BCS teams. Teams like Boise State, Utah and TCU have opened the door for others, but I still vote based on the merits of a team each season."

How bad has it been for the Big East this season?

The Big East owns a 2-10 record against schools from the other five BCS conferences. West Virginia and Connecticut each won one game apiece. The Mountaineers beat Maryland and the Huskies beat Vanderbilt.

In addition to that poor record, there have been some lopsided defeats. Pitt lost by 28 points at home to Miami. South Florida lost to Florida by 24 and Syracuse lost by 21 to Washington. Plus, there have been some head-scratchers such as Rutgers losing to Tulane and Connecticut losing to Temple.

Pitt coach Dave Wannsteft said the way to improve the Big East's reputation is simple: Start winning some non-conference games.

Advertise with us

"When we get opportunities to play non-conference games, we need to make a good showing," he said. "Obviously, two weeks ago was a tough week for us when we played some top-ranked teams. But we're only one-third of the way into the season, so we have some time."

Meanwhile, teams from the Mountain West and WAC have impressed.

Boise State beat Virginia Tech and Oregon State, TCU beat Oregon State and Utah beat Pitt. Other teams from the Mountain West and WAC have piggy-backed off their success.

Air Force is ranked this week for the first time since 2002, and Nevada debuted in the poll last week for the first time since 1948.

Wannstedt said he did not see a correlation between Pitt, Penn State and West Virginia being unranked and the state of the high school football talent base in Western Pennsylvania. He said more than likely it's the fact that all three schools are breaking in some new players at key positions.

"Things go in cycles," Wannstedt said. "When you look at West Virginia, they're breaking in a new quarterback, so is Penn State and so are we. We all just happened to get hit with a cycle of graduation this year. We're all working out some issues with our teams."