Aside from something with a clear right or wrong answer, like the correct option on a multiple choice test or the only possible answer to an algebra problem, grading can be an arbitrary exercise. It’s easy to see two or more sides to an issue and while there’s a right range in which an answer can fall, there isn’t necessarily a singular, right answer.

Pitt’s 2016-17 season, when viewed as a whole, was underwhelming. A team returning six of its seven leading scorers, a squad that would eventually feature two of the top five scorers in the ACC, posted the program’s first losing season since 2000, its worst in-conference win percentage in 40 years and a handful of dispiriting losses, from a 55-point rout at the hands of Louisville to its first City Game loss since 2000, against a Duquesne team that would go on to finish last in the Atlantic 10 and fire its coach. There were highs, sure, but they were outnumbered by more than a few head-scratching lows.

So if it struggled as a unit, how did its individual pieces fare? It’s a question that brings us back to the arbitrary practice of grading. There isn’t an exact formula I used, but I made it a combination of production, where that production stood in comparison to past production (that is, did they get better and if so, how much?), defensive play, efficiency and the overall impact their play had on the team’s successes and failures.

In short, it’s a really, really, really arbitrary exercise.

Advertise with us
Matt Freed/Post-Gazette Pitt's Jamel Artis passes the ball against Gardner at the Petersen Events Center November 12, 2016. (Matt Freed / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Jamel Artis: A-

Artis was as much of a punching bag as there was on this team, with some of it — the suspension for the entirety of the Duquesne game and the first 10 minutes of the season finale against Virginia — being self-inflicted. He wasn’t fit to be a point guard, many said, a sentiment that isn’t entirely wrong.

How he showed out in that role is notable, however; Artis, for all the criticism he faced, performed admirably in a situation in which he could have easily failed spectacularly. A 6-7 wing who hadn’t played point guard since his days in prep school averaged 3.3 assists per game (to 2.6 turnovers) while emerging as the team’s most accomplished and efficient shooter, making 47.5 percent of his field goals and 39.2 percent of his 3-pointers. He had his flaws, of course. His shooting numbers faded in the final six weeks of the regular season and his sometimes slow decision-making when manning the point undoubtedly hurt the Panthers at various points. When one looks at his numbers, though, and adds a degree of difficulty because of the role he inherited due to a dearth of better options, he was very likely Pitt’s best player this season.

Mike Young: B+

Pitt’s only all-ACC honoree, making second-team all-conference, Young was his team’s most consistent offensive presence, leading the team in points per game (19.6) and coming within five points of holding on to the ACC’s scoring title on the final day of the regular season. He scored fewer than 10 points only once, a game in which he had to wear a makeshift mask that obstructed his eyesight, and routinely displayed an offensive game that looked NBA-ready for extended stretches. He was, arguably, the Panthers’ best offensive talent and was certainly its steadiest.

Advertise with us

There were shortcomings, though. Young was bad defensively and, even worse, looked apathetic on that end at times. His offensive numbers weren’t as efficient as his per-game totals would lead one to believe. Concerns about his increased reliance on 3s — going from 12 attempts in 2015-16 to 123 last season -- were overblown, but while he emerged as a nightmare matchup as a muscular, 6-9 player with range, his percentage from beyond the arc (34.1) wasn’t quite high enough to justify his high volume of outside shots. While that doesn’t mean he should have settled for 2-point jumpers, he could have made more of an effort to get high-percentage looks at the rim.

Pitt's Cameron Johnson drives to the net against Florida State's Jarquez Smith in the first half Saturday, Feb. 18, 2017, at Petersen Events Center. (Matt Freed/Post-Gazette) (Matt Freed / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Cam Johnson: B

No Panthers player improved in the way the gangly 6-8 sophomore did, raising his scoring average from 4.8 points per game to 11.9. In the process, Johnson was able to do what so few players we peg as potential breakout players actually do -- that is, actually break out in a meaningful way. His shooting percentage and overall efficiency didn’t dip with a significant increase in minutes, which is no small feat.

Though not due to a lack of effort, he struggled both defensively and in areas of his offensive game that went beyond outside shooting. When Artis and/or Young weren’t on the court and the offense centered around him, those limitations were visible. Still, a player some theorized could emerge as a future building block showed himself to be just that (if he decides to stay).

Sheldon Jeter: B-

Advertise with us

Jeter’s a player I often referred to as being under-appreciated, if only because I felt he was maligned by some to a point that seemed unfair given what he had shown capable of providing on the court. Those criticisms weren’t entirely invalid. Jeter could be undeniably brilliant in one game only to turn around and be largely invisible the next time out. It’s an occupational hazard when playing with two scorers as talented as Young and Artis, but it emerged as a frustrating trend for anyone who followed the team, and particularly for Jeter himself.

What’s left out of that analysis, though, are some impossible-to-overlook truths. At just 6-7, he was the team’s best interior defender and by far its best rebounder, routinely having to try to overcome his physical disadvantages against much bigger, burlier opponents, and getting the better of them more frequently than one would expect. Much like Artis, he was a player thrust into a difficult role out of necessity and he inhabited that niche not as well as he possible could have, but came close to it.

Matt Freed/Post-Gazette Pitt's Chris Jones dives for a loose ball against Notre Dame in the first half Saturday at the Petersen Events Center. (Matt Freed / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Chris Jones: C+

Jones was a steady but rarely spectacular presence in the Panthers’ starting lineup this season. The fact he averaged 32.1 minutes per game -- more than all but one member of the all-ACC first team averaged for their respective teams -- speaks to the sparsely filled roster Jamie Dixon left behind when he departed for TCU.

He wasn’t particularly fast or athletic, wasn’t a great shooter, didn’t really excel in any one area of the game and never seemed to progress from his sophomore season, when he averaged a career-high 8.5 points per game. Jones did, however, prove over the course of the season to be one of the team’s better dribble penetrators and finishers at the rim, and his field goal percentage of 47.2 was the second-best among Pitt’s starters. That’s worth something.

Advertise with us

Ryan Luther: C+

Luther presents a difficult case because of a foot injury that forced him to miss 12 games, a stretch representing most of ACC play. In his first 17 games, he averaged 6.6 points per game and shot 56.3 percent. In the final four games of the season, he averaged just 2.2 points per game and missed five of his seven shots. He appeared healthy enough, but whether it was because of rust or lingering pain, he wasn’t the player he was.

When he was at his best, though, Luther was a strong and dependable sixth man, someone who could come off the bench and provide a level of energy and tenacity (I’m ‘high basketball IQ’ and ‘grit’ away from achieving White Basketball Player Bingo). He was a strong rebounder and a decent offensive contributor who, despite some inherent limitations, became a piece in the rotation whose absence became glaring once he went down, at least initially.

DURHAM, NC - FEBRUARY 04: Rozelle Nix #25 of the Pittsburgh Panthers reacts after a play during their game against the Duke Blue Devils at Cameron Indoor Stadium on February 4, 2017 in Durham, North Carolina. (Photo by Streeter Lecka/Getty Images) (Matt Freed / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Rozelle Nix: C-

Nobody on Pitt’s team has a story quite like Nix, who was a fan favorite before he ever stepped on the court in his first game. Some of the loudest cheers in the Petersen Events Center this season came when he checked into a game, which says as much about Pitt’s underwhelming season as it does fans’ love of the junior center.

Advertise with us

Nix struggled offensively, shooting a dismal 37.5 percent, was too slow to keep up with most any big man he defended and the aggression that made him such a valuable rebounding force (and a beloved figure) often got him into foul trouble in mere minutes. One can’t help but be impressed with his rebounding figures, though. His per-game average of 2.6 won’t raise too many eyebrows, but his offensive rebounding percentage of 17.2 would rank him third nationally (if he played enough minutes to qualify) while his defensive rebounding percentage of 30.2 would rank him seventh.

Jonathan Milligan: D

This is where we start to wade a little deeper, beyond the players who became regular parts of the Panthers’ rotation by the end of the season. Milligan was a bit of a one-trick pony, someone who shot 3s and did little else, either offensively or defensively. Of his 63 shots this season, 50 came from beyond the arc, where he shot just 32 percent. The junior guard had his moments, like when he came off the bench to drain two 3s against Clemson, but he was a small player who was easily beaten on defense and a 3-point specialist who largely struggled to make 3s.

Corey Manigault: D-

As I was writing these grades yesterday, Manigault announced he was transferring, a move I had been told was imminent earlier this month. The 6-8 forward came in as an intriguing prospect, coming out of talent-laden Paul VI High School in Virginia and holding an offer sheet that included Georgetown, Maryland, Xavier and Wake Forest.

Advertise with us

Manigault was never able to establish a place in Pitt’s rotation, usually looking overwhelmed, slow and out of shape when he went on the court. As the season went along, he was clearly and undeniably passed by Nix on the pecking order. He may very well go on to find success elsewhere, but it likely wasn’t going to happen with the Panthers.

Damon Wilson: D-

Even before the season began, Wilson looked like a player stuck in purgatory, someone who clearly wasn’t a point guard but who also didn’t have the outside touch to be a shooting guard. After a freshman season that provided glimpses of promise, he regressed badly as a sophomore, seeing his scoring average plummet from 3.3 points per game to 0.8 and his already unsightly shooting percentage of 34.5 fell by nearly nine percentage points. By the final stretch of ACC play, he was passing up open 3s and was seldom able to finish when he got to the rim. He was a player who, based on everything we saw, had lost any kind of confidence he had in his shot.

Wilson is well-liked by Pitt’s staff as a person, but he and Milligan are the two most likely candidates to transfer on a team rapidly shedding players from last season.

Justice Kithcart: F

Advertise with us

Seen by some as the point guard of the future entering the season, someone who could make Artis’ move to the position a temporary arrangement, Kithcart floundered in most any way he could in his lone year in Oakland. His shooting numbers — from field goal percentage (30.4) to 3-point percentage (19) to even free throw percentage (31.8) — were abysmal. When he did utilize his excellent speed to get to the basket, his shots were easily rejected or he was simply pushed off from getting a good, stable look. The strong perimeter defense we heard so much about in the preseason was rarely apparent.

Most of all, his attitude made it difficult for coaches and even some of his own teammates to embrace or like him. Those problems were, ultimately, what caused him to be dismissed from the program the day before the season finale, ending his Pitt career before it could even begin.

Kevin Stallings (Matt Freed / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Kevin Stallings: C-

The most difficult grade to assign, by far. Most anyone who regularly reads my work knows my thoughts on coaching. We often heap too much praise to a coach when the team is doing well and are too quick to bury them when things take a turn for the worse. It’s a mystery when a bad team plays well and a good team plays poorly, so the easiest way to solve that riddle is often by praising the aspect of the game we least understand -- coaching.

Stallings, even after just one season at Pitt, exists as a polarizing figure. Heck, he may have even been that way before he ever coached a game at the Pete. To some, he’s single-handedly responsible for destroying a once-proud program. To others, he’s faultless, a helpless actor who inherited a dumpster fire that burned beneath the surface before fully exploding as the man responsible for creating it (Dixon) left.

Advertise with us

At the risk of sounding overly high-minded, there’s nuance to be had in this discussion. Stallings took over a roster that wasn’t decimated, but was poorly constructed, from being ill-fitting at the top to embarrassingly thin at the bottom. This is also a team that lost one of its top seven scorers and won five fewer games than it did the previous season. That speaks some to the importance of James Robinson, but it’s also a reflection of how this team was managed at times. Stallings took over too messy and tenuous of a situation to be the abject failure some try to paint him as, but he also had a hand in the worst Pitt season in nearly two decades. Because of that, he falls right in the middle, with a minus added because, well, these things are arbitrary.

Craig Meyer: cmeyer@post-gazette.com and Twitter @CraigMeyerPG