History says the euphoria Mount St. Mary’s enjoyed Tuesday night after dramatically beating New Orleans in an NCAA tournament play-in game will be fleeting. The No. 16 seed the Mountaineers will take into the main draw has never defeated a No. 1 seed, posting an 0-128 record all-time.

The streak’s got to end sometime. There have been several near misses over the years. At some point the law of averages figures to bend for a least one of the little guys.

When that bend happens, though, probably won’t have anything to do with the “growing parity” of the sport that coaches and pundits like to talk about in broad strokes these days.

KenPom.com ranks teams throughout each season by “adjusted efficiency margin,” defined as “the difference between a team’s offensive and defensive efficiency. … It represents the number of points the team would be expected to outscore the average Division I team over 100 possessions.” (You can read more about the methodology here.)

Advertise with us

Somewhat complicated math for the layman, but the important thing to know for the purposes of our look at No. 16 seeds is that it gives us an easy way to compare them from year to year, not just with their peers in a given season, but with each other.

And the last five years show no trend whatsoever about the relative strength of No. 16 seeds changing in any meaningful way.

This season, KenPom’s ratings suggest the average national ranking of the six bottom-seeded teams (we’ll include losers of the play-in games for better sample size purposes) is 192 with an average AdjEM of -2.25, or 2.25 points worse than the average Division I team.

That compares favorably with last year, when the average No. 16 seed was ranked 237th with an AdjEM of -6.74. But No. 16 seeds were much better in 2015, when they posted an average ranking of 178 and AdjEM of -0.99. Similar fluctuations occurred in ’13 and ’14 as well.

There are myriad reasons for these shifts, but chief among them is the fact that some of these teams are bid-stealers — runners-up or worse in their conference in the regular season but winners of the automatic NCAA tournament bids that small conferences award in their tournaments.

Advertise with us

There are two such teams among the No. 16 seeds this year. South Dakota State and UC Davis both fell short in the regular season but went on to win the Summit League and Big West Conference tournaments, respectively, and drag down the overall strength of bottom seeds in the process.

An upset is more likely to happen, then, in a year when all of the No. 16s are at least the best teams in their respective conferences. It’s less likely to happen in a year when Jackrabbits or Aggies crash the party and give top seeds an easier matchup than they might have drawn otherwise.

It’s also more likely to happen in a year when the bottom seeds are closer to the Division I average in efficiency. A group that’s one-point worse than that average, for example, is more likely to do well than a group that’s six or more worse.

All of which is a long way of saying we have no idea when that historic first upset will finally happen. But it’s not something the sport is working toward on a linear path. Sometimes the chances will be better. Sometimes they’ll be worse. And in the end, a No. 16’s victory over a No. 1 — perhaps one by Mount St. Mary’s Thursday against Villanova in Buffalo — will probably be more a story about an amazing accomplishment for an individual team than a broader shift in the college basketball landscape.