Mike Brey walked into his post-game press conference at the Petersen Events Center Saturday and, before even sitting down, said "ACC basketball, baby. Whoooooo."

I think he spoke for a lot of us with that, even if, for Pitt fans, it didn't turn out quite how they would have liked. The Panthers impressed Saturday in perhaps their stiffest challenge of the season, but they gave away two five-point leads in the final three minutes of a period, first in the second half and then again in overtime, in a 78-77 loss to Brey's Notre Dame team.

There's a lot to digest and -- since it's New Year's Day -- a lot to get out of your hungover mind, so let's look at how the everything unfolded yesterday afternoon.

Turning point: This one's kind of obvious, right? With his team down, 77-75, with about five seconds remaining in overtime, Steve Vasturia caught a pass from a tumbling Matt Farrell in the corner, pump-faked Cam Johnson and cooly buried a 3-pointer with 2.5 seconds left to give the Fighting Irish a 78-77 lead and, as we saw, the game.

Advertise with us

The folks in charge of the PA system at the Pete didn't do Pitt any favors by playing twenty one pilots before the game, either. The Panthers were doomed before the ball was even tipped.

Game ball: Jamel Artis. He and Mike Young both scored 25 points, but Artis did so in seven fewer shots (17 to 24). The senior point guard, who also tied a season high with nine rebounds, scored his points in some of the game's most crucial situations, tallying 14 of Pitt's 32 second-half points and five of its nine overtime points (so, in all, 19 of Pitt's 41 points in the final 25 minutes). If there was one player who put his team in a position to get a crucial win to open ACC play, it was Artis.

Notable stat: I usually try to zero in on a single stat with these, but to highlight the disparity between Young and Artis' production against that of the rest of the team, I'll focus on a theme instead.

Points -- Young/Artis: 50, other seven Pitt players: 27

Made field goals -- Young/Artis: 19, other seven Pitt players: 8

Advertise with us

Made 3-point field goals -- Young/Artis: 9, other seven Pitt players: 3

Field goal percentage -- Young/Artis: 46.3, other seven Pitt players: 25.8

3-point percentage -- Young/Artis: 52.9, other seven Pitt players: 21.4

This, of course, isn't to say other Pitt players did nothing -- Sheldon Jeter, for example, was excellent in certain areas of the game, finishing with 13 rebounds and two blocks -- nor is it starting that Pitt is wholly reliant on two scorers, particularly since Cam Johnson has proven himself as a nice and capable third option. But, from an offensive standpoint, Pitt had the two best players on the court Saturday, but lost the game, in part, because it had little else.

What it means: There are two ways to look at this loss. Like it is across sports, a game like this isn't necessarily an 'either or'; it's a 'this and that.' Pitt both looked the part of a team that can contend in the ACC and it also coughed away an opportunity at a win that would be valuable both in the present and in, say, 11 weeks when it's awaiting its NCAA tournament fate.

Advertise with us

I left non-conference play with the impression that Pitt is a team capable of playing with most anyone on the right day given the kind of scorers it has in Young and Artis, but that it's also a group where something just appeared to be missing, whether it was from a physical or psychological standpoint. A great team doesn't give away huge leads on such a consistent basis, even if it lives to tell about it each time. In some respects, I didn't really know what Pitt was. After Saturday's game, I feel like I have a better grasp on it. I saw a team that competed harder than it has all season and was within a last-second 3 of beating a top-25 team on a day in which it didn't even shoot 40 percent, a position that it got in only after quickly coming back from an eight-point deficit with 7:43 left. There was a lot to like and I genuinely mean that.

But for a team that spoke so much of taking advantage of chances that are presented to it during a conference schedule that guarantees little, if anything, that was a blown opportunity. Pitt twice had five-point leads late in a home game in which they trailed for just 7:25 of a possible 45 minutes. The Panthers controlled the game, yet still lost. For a team that has to play, in order, against Virginia, at Syracuse and at Louisville in the next 12 days, that's an especially difficult loss to accept, partially because of just how damn close it was. There were the five missed layups in the second half, four of which uncharacteristically came from Young, the team's best offensive player. Then there was the available rebound after Vasturia's game-tying shot attempt with 21 seconds left in overtime, a loose ball Vasturia ultimately corralled himself. If Pitt gets that ball, and it had the chance to, you figure that game is, at worst, going to a second overtime. The game was, in short, there until it wasn't.

What's next: A home game Wednesday against No. 12 Virginia, which is coming off a two-point home loss Saturday against a really good and talented Florida State team. Pitt has lost to the Hoos all four times since joining the ACC in 2013-14. KenPom has Virginia as a 71 percent favorite, with a projected final score of 63-57.

Notable quotables: "We fought so hard. We were right there, up five with two minutes left. It's a tough way to lose for us. We feel like we had the game in our hands and just kind of let it go. You never want to lose, but it hurts even more when you pretty much let the game go." - Mike Young

"That's the hardest we fought and competed all year." - Young

Advertise with us

"It hurts to lose a game like this. It's a game we felt like we could win, but we also feel like we can win every game." - Chris Jones

"The guy has made more big shots in his career. You've just got to keep coming back to him. I really thought if he got a clean look, I would have been shocked if it didn't go down. We've seen him many so many big ones." - Mike Brey

"The one thing we did talk about was not to have anybody else really go off. [Cam] Johnson got 14 points, but he was four of 12. Nobody else got going. I didn't think we were going to be able to stop these guys. They're really gifted. They're men, they're winners and I'm so impressed with both of them." - Brey on Young and Artis

"I'm glad we only play Pitt once. We see them once a year and I don't want to see them until next New Year's. They're really good." - Brey

"Fellas, this is what we do. There's a great psychological advantage for us right now because we've had success in overtime. I think that helped us." - Brey on what he told his team entering overtime

Advertise with us

"We could point to a number of things that hurt us, but I think as much as anything, it was all the layups we missed in the second half. We just kept getting to the rim and the ball would hang on the rim and fall off. That's what enabled them to get an eight-point lead. We felt like we got great shots, but didn't have a great shooting day." - Kevin Stallings

"When it becomes a one-possession game, you need to come up with a loose ball or come up with a rebound. We didn't come up with that last one and it ended up costing us." - Stallings

"We need some more offense from people. Our bench didn't give us much today, aside from half of our turnovers. We have what we have and we had enough to win today. We just didn't make enough plays." - Stallings

"We got great shots against their zone and missed them. In terms of getting stops, it did get stops against us. I thought we got easier shots than we were getting against their man-to-man and yet we didn't make them. I don't know what to do. All I can do is ask them to get good shots. They were getting them, they were taking them and they weren't going in. That's nobody's fault; that's the nature of the game." - Stallings

"I guess if you want to focus on it, you can drive yourself crazy with it. I'm pretty sure Virginia is the next team that comes in and I'm pretty sure they're pretty good. I don't think you have any time to wallow in your booboos. You have to get up, be a man, look in the mirror, ask what you can do better and get ready for the next one. There are 17 more just like that one that are going to come flying at us. None of them are going to be easy." - Stallings

Craig Meyer: cmeyer@post-gazette.com and Twitter @CraigMeyerPG