Jason Mackey: Hello, everyone. Welcome to my weekly Pirates chat. Sorry we're a day late. Every day is Tuesday. These days at Pirate City make it tough. Anyway, we're back. We'll get started in about 15 minutes.

MUNKEEFIST: Have the Pirates made any statements about what kind of pitch limitations Paul Skenes will have in the WBC?

Jason Mackey: And away we go ...

Jason Mackey: They have not. Nor would I expect them to explicitly say something like that. His last outing was 3 innings. Would imagine he gets to 4 next week.

Advertise with us

EHW: Are you getting the sense that the third base search is over and they are solely focused on adding a starter now? When would be considered too late into spring training to add a new player to the mix?

Jason Mackey: I don't think it's over, but my sense is that they're perfectly fine with Triolo there and aren't gonna sell the farm to get something. Only if they can get someone with power potential and club control.

I think adding a LH starter is probably more likely.

JuniataKid: Given Cruz’s awful season last year, is there a scenario (other than injury) where he loses his starting job during spring training? Mangum is a good on-base guy with speed and good defense. No power, though. If he has a great spring, any chance he’s our opening day center fielder?

Jason Mackey: There is not, no. Cruz will be your opening day center fielder, as long as he's healthy.

Advertise with us

JuniataKid: I haven’t heard much at anll about Endy. What’s his situation and is he the opening day catcher at Indy?

Jason Mackey: I expect him & Flores to split time at Indy. His situation is catching, staying healthy and trying to hit. Talked to him a few days ago. He's doing great. Here's one quote: "I’m getting there, man. It’s been a long time without swinging a bat. I’m getting there."

George T: Hi Jason, with the new player who can hit does that make much harder for pitchers to pitch around someone and maybe give guys better pitches to hit.

Jason Mackey: Yes. Lineup protection. That's what they're going for.

Jimbo: Robin Yount was only 18 and only played 65 minor league games before starting in the majors, why can’t Connor start at short opening day?

Advertise with us

Jason Mackey: *Konnor.

Jimbo, 22 players in the history of baseball -- yes, including Yount -- have made their MLB debut at shortstop at age 19 or younger. In the history of baseball.

I'm not saying Griffin can't. But the odds are stacked against him. Let's see games to find out which way this goes.

Mike: Any Chance that Pirates will resign Cutch at some point this year? If not will Cutch probably shun the Pirates henceforth?

Jason Mackey: I would be surprised if Cutch signs here. I don't think they have a role for him on the team, and I don't think he would want whatever tiny one they could carve out. Just not a fit roster-wise.

Advertise with us

ACE: First time chatter. After all these years, finally excited enough to join. I saw a possible Bucco lineup which had Bart, Gonzales and Trioli batting bottom third. Not really Muders row!!! I hope not.

Jason Mackey: That could be your bottom-three, yes. I don't have an issue there, provided Griffin is coming up and Bart reverts back to 2024 form. As bottom-threes goes, it's fine, so long as the top-six does more.

Meowmix: If you had your pick of any two remaining free agents to add to the Pirates, who would they be, and why?

Jason Mackey: Realistically, I'd probably add a starting pitcher, Tyler Anderson or Patrick Corbin. Max Scherzer would be fun, but I don't see it happening. Second one, I wouldn't force a sign. I would use the money to acquire a 3B via trade.

Douggy18: really appreciated your recent article on Jack S. Is there a team chaplain and who are some of the faith leaders in the clubhouse?

Advertise with us

Jason Mackey: Thank you. Not my business to relay players' religious beliefs unless they're comfortable or consent. I only mention Jack because I did a story on it; it's obviously out there. Would certainly imagine someone replaces him as chaplain, though I don't know who that would be. Also possible Jack returns in a non-roster capacity.

Eustace: Hi Jason, in your humble opinion, what do you think was the driving factor that finally saw notorious cheapskate Bob Nutting loosen the purse strings and finally spend some money on this team? The constant "Sell the Team" chants? Pressure from the league to spend? Pressure from GMBC? Pressure from Paul Skenes?

Jason Mackey: I don't know, Eustace. I've wondered that question myself. Could be a little of all of these above: wasting two years of Skenes, possible lockout looming, tired of the planes flying and criticism ... I don't know 100% for sure but have to imagine all are inputs.

TheConfluence: Hi Jason, kudos to you and Colin on your coverage down there. In reference to Griffin, do you think that the PPI 1st round pick may be a tipping point if Griffin is close to making the team? As you know, the Bucs blew the PPI pick in '24 with Skenes because he didn't make the team out of spring training. Thanks....

Jason Mackey: Thank you. I don't think it will be a tipping point. I could be wrong. But I think if it's even remotely close, they send him to Triple-A and prioritize his long-term development. All of this is so speculative. Let him play some, then let's assess more.

Advertise with us

Wayward: Jason, first, thanks to you and Colin. The content you have put out this week has been great. I know in your column today you referenced that you thought the Bucs would still add a LP. What is your take on 3B? It looks like Mayo may be out of play with the Westburg injury; the Astros don't seem inclined to deal Paredes, and it has been quiet around Jung. Do you think the Bucs will add someone and who may be reasonable remaining targets that are upgrades?

Jason Mackey: Thank you very much, Wayward. I'll say they add a LH starter but stand pat on a 3B. They still could add there, but rosters are kinda set around MLB at this point.

Reece: Happy to have you back in the beat, Jason. Is it safe the pirates will have Triolo at 3rd when we kickoff in New York next month?

Jason Mackey: Great to be back. They have made no determinations before the start of games, I can promise you that.

Paul: Are the bucs this confident in Triolo or are the asking prices just too high from Mets, Astros, etc?

Advertise with us

Jason Mackey: Asks either too high or not the right ones, yes. I don't think they're offering what the Mets want. With Paredes, I think the salary is higher than they want to pay for that spot.

Ethan: Is it looking like Reynolds in LF and O'Hearn in RF when they're both in the outfield? Is there any confidence he can handle PNC LF again?

Jason Mackey: Yes, it is.

I actually think he'll be fine there. He knows it. Is he a Gold Glove candidate? No. But just keep the ball in front of you. I think people might be pleasantly surprised by Reynolds in left field. He was better after the All-Star break last year.

Wayward: Jason, I know we never know but what would your guess as to what a potential early contract extension for Griffin would be? 8/120 or would it need to be closer to 140? Thanks

Advertise with us

Jason Mackey: You're right, we don't know. I have a tough time seeing the Pirates go to $140 million, though. Maybe that scuttles a deal, I don't know. I just think going that far beyond the biggest contract in franchise history for a kid who's never played in MLB is probably unlikely.

Pav: With a real upgrade at 3B feeling more unlikely, would adding someone like Ramon Urias be something they could be interested in? The left side infield depth is pretty shaky if Griffin doesn’t start in the majors

Jason Mackey: It could. I guess I just don't see what Urias gives you that Triolo does not.

Guest: You and Colin both listed Ozuna as an Outfielder in a recent article. Do you see him getting playing time in the OF or will be strictly be a DH?

Jason Mackey: Strictly DH. That was more for housekeeping, because that's where he used to play.

Advertise with us

Rich: Jason, what are the chances any of the following things happen now that we’re getting ready for spring games to start

  1. The Pirates acquiring a 3B
  2. The Pirates acquiring a lefty SP
  3. A Konnor Griffin extension

Jason Mackey: I can't give you percentage, Rich. If I ranked them, I would say SP, 3B, extension. But I don't even know how odds work, let alone have the ability to apply them here.

GPT: I know he doesn't have the power you want from a corner OF, but is Jake Mangum in the mix for a starting role?

Jason Mackey: He's not, no. At least not starting every day. He's depth. Might play against lefties, come on as a sub & spell guys. But your starting OF should be Reynolds, Cruz & O'Hearn.

Marc: Hey Jason, thanks for the chat. If Bart is traded as you've predicted, who backs up Henry? Endy is probably better defensively than Flores but I think both of them need regular at bats at AAA. Do you think the Bucs get a quality defensive backup off the scrap pile?

Advertise with us

Jason Mackey: Yes. If they trade Bart, I think they sign a veteran safety net. Or just bring Jacob Stallings out of retirement. Half-kidding.

Sam: Hey any word on getting a lefthanded starter ? Do you think they will go into the regular season without one

Jason Mackey: I know. Big question. Trust me, telling you everything I can. We don't withhold info. I think they'll sign someone. I just don't think it'll be a splash.

Cody: If the pirates add a fifth starter who could it be

Jason Mackey: Tyler Anderson, Patrick Corbin ... aren't many left out there.

Advertise with us

bucsfan607179: Have you heard any discussion of a Griffin extension that would enable him to start the year on the team and protect PPI draft pick eligibility?

Jason Mackey: I have heard no discussion of anything Griffin/extension related. Trust me, if it happens, you'll know. Not gonna save that one.

Defense: if KG doesn’t break camp with the team, why not Triolo at SS (higher value defensively) and Gonzales at 3B?

Jason Mackey: Because you're playing two guys out of position instead of one.

Cullen: I have to say I'm very impressed with how Ben handled this offseason. They earned my business back and I feel good about pur chances with genuine improvement in key areas plus depth to cover injuries and regression. Do you still expect a trade for a 3B and a SP? It seems to have gone quiet

Advertise with us

Jason Mackey: I expect them to do something else. I think a LH starter is more likely. Certainly a larger need. Could be a trade or FA.

62 Stack Monster: Jason, with all of these trades and free agent signings, (I feel as though the Pirates have a bunch of Aaron Rogers playing this year.) what does that say about internal development of our "Prospects" that we've garnered over the past 7 years.

Jason Mackey: I'm not sure what you're getting at. They have Skenes, Chandler, Griffin, Seth Hernandez and others. Not sure if I'm gonna say their prospects are lacking here.

Cullen: I really feel for Cutch and am sad it ended this way. I have to say, from purely a baseball perspective Ozuna is a far and away better hitter. I just wish cutch could accept reality in a more mature manner and realize he is a 26th man at this point and swallow his pride and come back. It would mean more to this City if we win with him and frankly he isn't a guaranteed starter and a $5m dollar player anymore...

Jason Mackey: I understand both sides. I don't think the Pirates are wrong for doing what they're doing. I don't think Cutch is wrong for being upset about it. Just an unfortunate scenario. I just hope long-term the relationship isn't ruined -- and I don't think it will be.

Advertise with us

Cody: If the pirates sign Patrick Corbin wouldn't that be bad because of the projected 5 era he's supposed to have this year according to prediction websites like fan graphs

Jason Mackey: How can they project an ERA when they don't know where he'll pitch?

GPT: I understand that pro sports are ruthless and unemotional, but do you think the Pirates did Cutch dirty? I would think Cherington had some kind of discussion with Cutch last winter along the lines of 'If there's a fit and need, we'd love to have you back, but we're always looking to upgrade if possible.'

Jason Mackey: I don't. They need better production from that spot. Statistically speaking, he was one of the worst DHs in MLB last year. Are they required to sign up for that again because people bought his jersey? Absolutely not. They need to win. They haven't and should be criticized for that. But I care far more about that than if someone's feelings are hurt.

That being said, if I'm Cutch, I understand why he's pissed given what he's done for this city and team. There's just no good answer here.

Advertise with us

Ryan: how has Jack Brannigan looked during spring training i know he was injured last year and probably won’t make the team Let’s go Bucs

Jason Mackey: Hi Ryan, I'm sorry. With so much to track, I haven't followed Brannigan a ton. What little I saw has been fine, but I'm well-aware that's not helpful.

Cullen: If the Pirates roll with Triolo is the plan probably to see who performs and what gaps need filling at the deadline and then make a move then when teams are more likely to accept prospects?

Jason Mackey: Cullen, let's get to spring training games before charting a plan at the deadline. Please, I beg of you.

Mangum: Was I a throw in or did Cherington see me as a game changer?

Jason Mackey: Probably somewhere in the middle. I love having Mangum on the roster. I wish he had more of an opportunity, honestly. But things like this have a way of working out.

Jason Mackey: Pirates were at $87.8 M last year on opening day, per AP numbers. Believe I saw Ethan Hullihen projecting $102.9 M. And I think it'll go up some with a LH starter move. Let's say $105 M and round to $88 M. You're looking at an uptick of around $17 M.

62 Stack Monster: What is the NET difference between expected payroll this year vs last year? Everyone thinks that they're spending but ignored is the fact that the Pirates traded away Falter, Hayes and Bednar, whose 2026 salaries are 3.6MM, 7MM and 9MM respectively.

DaquidoBazzini: Has there been any updated mentions of Paul Skenes occasionally coming to the plate? I wouldn't want to over do it, but they might be wasting someone that could add even more to an offense that still needs help.

Jason Mackey: He's not hitting. He doesn't wanna hit. It's not a topic. There will be no updates. That would be like asking for updates on whether Skenes will be performing open-heart surgery. Ain't happening.

Friend in PA: Why not Mlodzinski as a closer or 8th inning? His numbers the first time through line ups are terrific even when he was starting - rarely giving up a run let alone a hit the first inning or two.

Jason Mackey: Dennis Santana is their preferred closing option, and I have zero issue there. Maybe Mlodzinski becomes a late-inning option. I like that. You could also use him as a hybrid. One time through, middle of the game. If your starter is out after five, boy would I not hate him going 6-7 or 6-7-8 with a lead.

Snowbird: Big fan of your coverage, Jason. Had the chance to go to spring training on Wednesday and watched Konnor’s HR on field 3. But the biggest thing for me was seeing Donnie Kelley everywhere! At the infield drills, back and forth between the Bo cages, and then again for the live pitching. Relentless energy from the guy! I’m old enough that I watched games at Forbes Field, and I’m ready for good things this year.

Jason Mackey: Donny gets his steps in, that's for sure. Ha. He's always going. Gonna miss Pirate City.

Buc: Jason, I know that you are generally a glass half-full kind of guy (which I always appreciate in your coverage...but if you had to pick one person who will regress from last year's performance, who would it be?

Jason Mackey: Maybe Isaac Mattson. Not rooting for it, believe me. He couldn't be a nicer human. Just saying that if I had to pick one, which you're making me do, a guy who throws one pitch that's counted upon to be invisible is a fairly easy answer to that one.

DaquidoBazzini: I'm aware of the turmoil between the Pirates and Andrew McCutchen, but I'm still not clear on what it is based on. I'm guessing money?

Jason Mackey: No. Actually has nothing to do with money. McCutchen think he should retire a Pirate. And they want more production from that spot. McCutchen also hasn't been willing to say this is it.

Guest: why not Triolo at short and Nicky G at third

Jason Mackey: Because you're playing two people out of position.

Wayward: What is your take on Cook and/or Yorke? Can either contribute to the Bucs or are they purely AAAA type of guys who are blocked but other players.

Jason Mackey: I would keep Yorke. I think there's enough versatility there. I just don't see where Cook would play. Not sure they can get enough ABs for Password. Maybe they Cook as depth and not care that he's gonna sit a bunch? I'd rather him play in Triple-A.

Cody: Could they go with barco or Harrington instead?

Jason Mackey: They could, yes. Right now it's probably Urquidy/Barco/Mlodzinski/Harrington in some order. I'd have Urquidy first based on resume and how he's looked.

Smitty: Without an injury, how likely are we to see Password and Mangum on the 26-man roster at the same time?

Jason Mackey: Without an injury, it'll be tough. Not enough OF plate appearances to go around.

Eustace: I disagree with all the Cutch sympathizers. It's time to win now and he's done. Also, everyone seems to forget at the end of last season he didn't sound like he wanted to come back. Now that we signed a few new guys and he suddenly wants to come back? No Cutch. Plus his petty social media whining isn't doing him any favors. I think the Pirates FINALLY got it right with what they did.

Jason Mackey: Like I've said, I understand both sides to this.

Paul: Love your work, Jason. Thanks. Any thoughts on innings limits with so many SP this year? Jones, Hunter Barco, Chandler, Ashcraft, Urquidy, etc. Seems like all could be limited in Sept/Oct unless managed all year?

Jason Mackey: Yeah, it's gonna be a thing. And thank you, Paul. Urquidy might just be his own health, but they're gonna have to be conservative in some stretches, hence why it might make sense to deploy Carmen as a secondary starter or to add LH starting depth.

GPT: If Bubba Chandler ends up a solid #2 starter (or better), then the whole 'spread the money around' strategy from Davis' draft year is a success, right? Even more so if Henry can provide a league average bat to go with his improved defense.

Jason Mackey: I would agree with that. If Henry Davis develops offensively to match what he's done behind the plate, he's gonna hold a lot of value.

Drunk uncle: Hey jack how’s the family.bring any bourbon down south in Bradenton. Or you buy in Florida which I would think is real expensive

Jason Mackey: Didn't bring any down. These days are too long.

Snowbird: Do we get over the 82 game wins hump this season?

Jason Mackey: I think they will. I'll go 84.

Gary: Hey Jason I saw bar restaurant in Bradenton made USA today one of top restaurants is in yesterday’s edition, I forgot the name

Jason Mackey: Come on, Gary. Now you're gonna make me Google it.

2013: The buzz around this team feels a lot like it did in 2013. I caught the comment Skenes made about projecting how many innings he needed to get through the post season. I hope they can live up to their expectations. That said, the division also got better. How many wins does it take?

Jason Mackey: It's not totally like 2013 because of the expanded wild card situation, but I think they'd need at least 87-88 for the division and almost assuredly more. That would be if the division kind of beats up on one another. But they could challenge for a WC with 84ish, in my opinion.

Jason Mackey: OK, folks. That does it for today. Thanks so much for adjusting to the day. Can't wait for games to start tomorrow, and I would imagine yinz are in the same boat!