BRADENTON, Fla. — In baseball, there’s no such thing as too much starting pitching.
Even after trading from their depth this offseason, the Pirates have some options for whom their starters will be. Paul Skenes is assured of a spot, as is Mitch Keller. It seems reasonable to pencil Bubba Chandler and Braxton Ashcraft into the rotation, based upon their 2025 successes.
But the Pirates have enough pitching that there’s a competition for the No. 5 spot, if not for more. On Tuesday, manager Don Kelly didn’t want to rule anyone or anything out in terms of how the Pirates align.
“It’s going to be a competition and it’s going to be a while until we’re going to be able to fully nail that down,” Kelly said. “I don’t want to start to get into names at the expense of potentially leaving somebody out that should be in there, because there are a lot of guys competing for that spot [or] those spots.”
Two of the Pirates’ top options for that role could be two prospects who made their debut in 2025: right-hander Thomas Harrington or lefty Hunter Barco. Here’s a look at how both have fared early in spring training and their mentalities moving forward.
Barco in ‘a really good spot’
Based on results and profile alone, Barco would seem to have a decent chance to make the team. He’s the only lefty starter on the Pirates’ 40-man radar, had a 2.81 ERA in the minors last year and threw three scoreless innings in two September major league appearances.
Read More
For Barco, his biggest win was staying healthy in 2025. He had Tommy John surgery in 2022, rehabbed for much of 2023 then suffered a July 2024 injury to his left leg and missed the rest of that season. The Pirates were careful with him in 2025, limiting him to 102 1/3 innings, which allowed him to enter the offseason healthy.
Last offseason, Barco spent time working on strengthening his lower body to avoid a repeat of 2024. Those efforts were apparently successful, so he built on that this year.
“Had a really good offseason,” Barco said. “[The focus was] really just taking care of the body and everything that I needed to do to be ready to throw 150, 160-plus innings this year. [I’m] in a really good spot to go out and compete.”
He’s excited about the potential competition for the rotation. Over the last couple of years, Barco was just one of a talented generation of Pirates starting prospects. Now, they’re all here.
“We’re all working toward the same goal, and that’s win a World Series,” Barco said. “So whoever ends up being the five rotation spots, bullpen, whatever, it really doesn’t matter, as long as we’re all moving toward the same thing, and that’s going to compete and go win a World Series in Pittsburgh.”
So what does he need to do to win that rotation spot, starting the season alongside the likes of Skenes, Chandler and Ashcraft?
Barco didn’t overthink it.
“Go out and show what I can do,” Barco said. “And show that I’m a guy that can help the team win.”
Harrington’s ‘roller coaster’ 2025
While Barco ended 2025 on a high, Harrington had the opposite experience. He made his major league debut on the opening road trip, earned a four-inning save in his lone PNC Park appearance then was sent down to the minors. In his only other major league outing, he pitched two-thirds of an inning and allowed six runs, all earned.
He struggled in the minors, too, finishing with a 5.34 ERA. In August, he was shut down with a groin injury. It wasn’t the season he was hoping for.
“The best thing about baseball is there’s another season, right?” Harrington said. “It’s very important to take a step back and look at what kind of went wrong, why did it go wrong and then how do we fix it? That’s just a really big thing in baseball and sports in general.”
Still, Harrington thinks he learned some lessons. He believes the “cup of coffee,” in his words, showed him what it takes to be a successful big leaguer and what he needed to work on in the offseason.
“I think it’s going to make me a better player, obviously going through some roller coaster of last year, some ups and downs,” Harrington said. “So I’m excited to see the steps I’ve taken in the offseason, how it translates to spring training and just get ready for the season.”
Harrington had an eventful offseason. He got married, went on a Caribbean honeymoon, put the groin injury behind him and got back to “focusing on getting better at baseball.”
He also had a different approach, now that he knows what the big leagues are like. The time in the majors, while short, was informative. He said he now knows what he needs to do to help the Pirates win, which showed him what steps he needed to make and how he could make them.
To make the rotation, Harrington said the most important thing is staying healthy.
“Just going out there and competing, showing my stuff, showing some strides I made in the offseason,” Harrington said. “And then just trying those out against hitters and seeing how hitters react.”
Others in the competition
Barco and Harrington aren’t the Pirates’ only options. Free agent signing Jose Urquidy has major league experience. Right-hander Carmen Mlodzinski made 12 starts last year and seemed to find something after a move to the bullpen, which could translate to starting. Recent 40-man additions Antwone Kelly and Wilber Dotel show potential. An outside addition could still be made.
The Pirates have options. It’s a sign of successful pitching development: Skenes, Ashcraft, Chandler, Jared Jones, Harrington, Barco and others have all come up together.
“It’s really cool to look around and see guys that I’ve been super close with throughout my entire time in the [organization], and for all of us to be here and just fighting for a championship,” Barco said. “So it’s cool to see that common goal.”
Now that they have all arrived, there’s not enough spots for everyone. That will have benefits, too.
“That competition is gonna make all of us better,” Harrington said. “It’s really exciting to have a group that’s so deep and that are able to compete with each other and then obviously make each other better. So yeah, just excited to get rolling. It’ll be a great spring.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.