The Pirates weren’t close to the playoffs in 2025. They never dug out of their early-season struggles, never clicked offensively and never threatened for the final wild-card spot.
But the Pirates were close in at least one aspect: close games. The Pirates played in a major league-high 60 one-run games in 2025, finishing with a 25-35 record in those. Only the lowly White Sox (15-36) had more one-run losses.
It’s not a surprise that the Pirates had so many close games, as the combination of a strong pitching staff and the lowest-scoring offense in the majors made for plenty of low-scoring games. Now that the Pirates have taken steps to improve their offense by trading for Brandon Lowe and signing Ryan O’Hearn, it’s worth asking: Are those two acquisitions alone enough to help the Pirates win more one-run games?
There’s certainly more to do, and the Pirates are still trying to make further moves. But Lowe and O’Hearn should help the offense — we’ll try to quantify how much.
2025 numbers
The Pirates played two more one-run games than the second-place San Francisco Giants (28-30). Eight teams — the Rays, Orioles, White Sox, Mariners, Braves, Padres and Giants — played more than 50 one-run games.
Of those, only the Padres and the Mariners had better than .500 records in one-run games. Those were the only two teams to finish better than .500 overall, and both made the playoffs.
Read More
Like the season overall, the Pirates had significant home-road splits in one-run games. They were 16-9 in one-run games at home, compared to 9-26 on the road. Road teams had just a .366 winning percentage in the 714 total one-run games leaguewide (per a Baseball Reference search), so while a slight split was expected, such road struggles are significant.
The Pirates’ losses in one-run games were generally low-scoring, with the exception of the 17-16 adventure in Colorado. Twenty-four of the 35 losses came by a 4-3, 3-2 or 2-1 margin, not including the Pirates’ four 1-0 losses.
And for some overall stats, the Pirates were 25-70 when they scored fewer than four runs. They were 12-13 when they allowed exactly three runs, 6-16 when allowing exactly four runs and 4-11 when allowing five runs.
The 2025 Pirates were 20 games under .500, but if not for their pitching, it could have been much worse.
So did they fix that?
In 2025, Lowe batted .256 with 31 homers, 83 RBIs and 79 runs scored. O’Hearn batted .281 with 17 homers, 63 RBIs and 67 runners scored. If only it were as simple as adding Lowe’s 131 runs scored (runs plus runs batted in, only counting homers once) with O’Hearn’s 113 to say the Pirates would have scored 244 more runs last year with the duo.
A better metric may be FanGraph’s runs above replacement (RAR), part of their wins above replacement (fWAR) metric. By that, Lowe was worth 17.1 RAR and O’Hearn was worth 29.6 RAR. While the “replacement” is a generic player, instead of a generic Pirate, adding Lowe and O’Hearn would be worth essentially 46 more runs in a full season.
So those 46 runs can all go toward one-run games, improving the Pirates’ record in one-run games to 60-0 and the Pirates’ season record to 106-56? Not exactly. That said, 46 more runs certainly marks an improvement.
Baseball Reference uses an equation called the Pythagorean winning percentage, which takes the amount of runs a team scored and allowed and turns it into an expected winning percentage. By that equation, Baseball Reference determined the 2025 Pirates should have gone 74-88, a slight improvement.
If they had scored 46 more runs, the amount Lowe and O’Hearn are theoretically worth according to FanGraphs, the Pirates’ expected record would have been 79-83. That would have been the Pirates’ best record since 2018, but it still wouldn’t be enough for a playoff berth.
Of course, there’s always room for over- or under-performance, especially in one-run games. By Pythagoras, the Rangers (and their similarly strong pitching) should have gone 90-72 last season. Instead, they went 81-81 partially because of a 21-29 record in one-run games. The Guardians should have gone 80-82 but went 26-20 in one-run games, got hot in September and ended up with 88 wins and the AL Central title.
With similar pitching in 2026, an improved offense and success in one-run games, the Pirates could do what the Guardians did. That’s still a lot left up to chance. Another major offensive addition and some pitching reinforcement would certainly help.
Enough about 2025 … what about 2026?
FanGraphs released its depth chart projections for the 2026 season and forecasted extreme parity: Every team, except for the historically bad Rockies, is projected to win between 69 and 93 games. The Pirates are expected to have a .497 winning percentage, which corresponds to 80-82.
In that projection, Lowe is worth 2.0 fWAR with a 25-homer season. O’Hearn is worth 1.3 fWAR and bats .269 with 15 homers. Oneil Cruz and Bryan Reynolds come closer to their career norms, and Konnor Griffin debuts and plays 94 games as an essentially league-average hitter (a 98 wRC+). It also includes some conservative pitching projections, as Paul Skenes’ projected ERA is 2.92 and every Pirates starter other than Skenes and Jared Jones has a four-plus ERA.
By those marks, the Pirates have the league’s sixth-best rotation by fWAR and its 26th-best offense. Those ranks will shift as free agents sign elsewhere, though it shows models believe the Pirates rotation will be strong even without Johan Oviedo and Mike Burrows.
But a key in one-run games is a strong bullpen, and the Pirates are currently below average, per FanGraphs. New signing Gregory Soto is projected to lead the bullpen in fWAR, but the model is low on Dennis Santana, Isaac Mattson, Justin Lawrence and others who had success in 2025. The Pirates have found relievers who have over-performed external projections in recent years, but they’ll need to avoid regression for success in one-run games in 2026.
While those projections don’t include full run totals, it’s clear that the Pirates’ additions this offseason have improved the team offensively. Considering the amount of low-scoring, one-run losses in 2025, those additions should help the Pirates in close games in 2026, especially if the bullpen can be a strength.
There’s more to do if the Pirates want to push for the playoffs, but they are closer than they were. If they improve in 2026, improvement in close games will likely be a reason why.
Around the horn
The Pirates on Tuesday acquired 18-year-old third baseman Francisco Loreto from the Phillies for Chase Shugart, who was designated for assignment after the signing of Ryan O’Hearn became official. Shugart went to Philadelphia in the transaction. Loreto hit .237 with 10 doubles, five home runs, a .728 OPS and 16 RBIs in 47 games with the Phillies’ Florida Complex League team this past season.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.