Today marks the end of a quarter century that was not too kind to the Pirates. In 25 seasons from 2001 to 2025, the Pirates made three playoff appearances and finished over .500 just four times.

Because of those struggles, it’s no surprise that the Post-Gazette’s Pirates quarter-century team has plenty of representation from the 2013, 2014 and 2015 clubs.

Ten of the 26 selected players, matching modern-day roster construction, played on the 2013 team that ended the Pirates’ 20-year playoff drought. Yet five players from the 2025 Pirates make the team, too, even if their biggest contributions largely came earlier in their careers.

Below is our Pirates’ quarter-century team. Each selection includes the bWAR (wins above replacement) they accumulated during their time in Pittsburgh.

Advertise with us

Outfield

LF Starling Marte (28.2 bWAR), CF Andrew McCutchen (42.6 bWAR), RF Brian Giles (26.1 bWAR)

Reserves: LF Bryan Reynolds (21.1 bWAR), LF Jason Bay (15.1 bWAR)

The outfield was the easiest part of the roster to construct. McCutchen is a legend in Pittsburgh, the best player on the Pirates’ best teams since 2000 and likely the last Pirate to ever wear No. 22. The 2013 National League Most Valuable Player is a simple pick, as is his left field partner, Marte.

Marte played his best baseball in Pittsburgh, and his ascension from top prospect to everyday outfielder was a big reason why the Pirates won 94 games in 2013.

Right field was more difficult, but Giles is the choice. He played for the Pirates from 1999 to 2003 and spent most of his time in left field, but he started 36 games in right in 2000. The Pirates haven’t had a true standout in right field and this team needs some early 2000s representation, so Giles it is.

Advertise with us

Infield

3B Josh Harrison (14.1 bWAR), SS Jack Wilson (21.3 bWAR), 2B Neil Walker (15.8 bWAR), 1B Josh Bell (2.9 bWAR)

Reserves: 3B Freddy Sanchez (12.9 bWAR), 2B Adam Frazier (10.5 bWAR)

The infield was trickier. Wilson’s and Walker’s longevity made them easy choices, though the success of Walker’s teams, plus his local ties, made him undeniable. Harrison did his best work as a utilityman, but he gets the start at third over Pedro Alvarez for his versatility, his defense and his stellar season in 2014.

But don’t worry, Alvarez is still a starter, just in a different role.

Bell is a surprise selection, but he qualifies for one simple reason: someone has to play first base. Just two Pirates first basemen have finished a season with better than 1.5 bWAR — Bell, who finished with 2.6 bWAR in 2019 after batting .277 with 37 homers and 116 RBIs, and Spencer Horwitz, who had a 1.6 bWAR season in 2025. Perhaps Horwitz will have a spot on our 2050 Pirates quarter-century team.

Advertise with us

Catcher and DH

C Russell Martin (9.8 bWAR), DH Pedro Alvarez (4.0 bWAR)

Reserves: C Jason Kendall (30.7 bWAR)

While Kendall may have had more longevity, Martin earns the start behind the dish for how important he was to the 2013 and 2014 playoff teams. Besides, some of Kendall’s best years came before the quarter century began. Martin was a leader on those playoff teams, a free-agent signing that helped the Pirates get over the edge and gave them “some street cred,” as former manager Clint Hurdle said.

Alvarez gave those teams some thump, leading the National League with 36 homers in 2013. He was never the best defender, making him the perfect designated hitter with modern-day roster constraints.

Starting rotation

RHP Paul Skenes (13.5 bWAR), RHP Gerrit Cole (11.0 bWAR), RHP Jameson Taillon (8.6 bWAR), LHP Francisco Liriano (7.9 bWAR), RHP A.J. Burnett (7.2 bWAR)

Advertise with us

Yes, Skenes has been so impressive in two full seasons that he’s both the clear ace and bWAR leader since 2000. Combine him with the Pirates’ previous young phenom in Cole, the edge of Burnett, the craftiness of Liriano and the steadiness of Taillon, and the Pirates have a solid rotation.

Paul Maholm, Kip Wells, Mitch Keller and Zach Duke were among the leaders in bWAR and were also considered for the quarter-century team, though they all largely benefitted from their longevity with the Pirates. Each had success, but none reached the heights of the selected starters.

Bullpen

LHP Tony Watson (9.3 bWAR), RHP Mark Melancon (8.0 bWAR), RHP David Bednar (6.4 bWAR), LHP Mike Gonzalez (5.6 bWAR), RHP Joel Hanrahan (5.5 bWAR), RHP Richard Rodriguez (4.5 bWAR), RHP Jason Grilli (2.4 bWAR)

A combination of Pirate closers over the last 25 years builds a pretty good bullpen, but who would have thought that Watson would be the statistical leader? Of course, having 450 appearances helps. Watson combines with closers Melancon, Bednar, Hanrahan and Grilli to build a formidable ‘pen.

Gonzalez may not have the same national name recognition as the others, but a 2.37 ERA in 168 appearances earns him a coveted spot. On a team with so many leverage options, the only question is this: Who’s got the ninth?