At this time next year, Major League Baseball will officially be in a lockout.

Maybe. Probably. Almost definitely.

Sure, at any point between now and 11:59 p.m. EST on Dec. 1, 2026, the owners and the Major League Baseball Players Association (MLBPA) could agree to new terms. However, owners and the league itself have seemingly telegraphed their intention to lock the players out when the current collective bargaining agreement (CBA) expires a year from now.

A lockout is expected, with many believing or fearing games could be missed. It could result in the league’s longest work stoppage since the players’ 232-day strike in 1994-95.

Advertise with us

For some, the game is in a healthy place. Baseball just had one of its most entertaining World Series of all time, as the Dodgers defeated the Blue Jays in a seven-game thriller that included two extra-inning games, including the decider. The league said Game 7 averaged more than 51 million viewers across the U.S., Canada and Japan, its most watched game in 34 years. Those Dodgers drew more than four million fans to their ballpark, while overall attendance rose and 21 of 30 teams averaged more than 25,000 fans per home game.

With the success of the 2023 World Baseball Classic and the expected success of the 2026 edition, which will be played in March and feature Paul Skenes on the U.S. team, baseball has more international momentum than ever before.

However, the sport certainly has its issues. Competitive balance is one, as the Dodgers have won back-to-back World Series championships while spending $266 million on payroll in 2024 and $350 million in 2025, per Spotrac. The Dodgers have drawn criticism for deferring money, as $68 million of three-time reigning MVP Shohei Ohtani’s $70 million annual contract won’t be paid until the 2030s. In general, it’s become harder than ever for a small-market team like the Pirates to compete.

Which brings us back to the looming potential lockout. Owners have made clear they want a salary cap, ensuring team payrolls are between two definite marks instead of the current, uncapped (but taxed) system. The MLBPA has no interest in a salary cap, claiming it would limit what its players could earn. It’s a stance the union has always had — in 1994, the league’s attempt at a cap led to baseball’s longest strike.

The MLBPA has made its anti-cap stance clear many times, including as recently as July. At MLB’s All-Star Weekend in Atlanta, MLBPA president Tony Clark told reporters as much.

Advertise with us

“A cap is not a partnership. It’s not about growing the game,” Clark said. “That’s not what a cap is about, as is what’s been offered to the public. A cap is about franchise values and profits. That’s what a cap is about. A salary cap, historically, has limited contract guarantees, literally pits one player against another and is often what we share as the definitive noncompetitive system.”

MLB commissioner Rob Manfred has never outright said he wants a salary cap, though he has talked of changing the current economic system.

“When I talk to the players, I don’t try to convince them of a salary cap system,” Manfred said in July. “ ... I never use the word ‘salary’ within one of ‘cap.’ What I do say to them is, in addressing this competitive issue that’s real, we should think about whether this [current] system is the perfect system from a player’s perspective.”

Ownership’s clearest reason for a cap is in franchise values. If owners have control over how much they spend on payroll, franchise values will rise like they have in the NFL, NBA and NHL, all capped leagues. However, they claim it will fix baseball’s competitive balance issues, as well.

If the league and players come to an agreement with a salary cap, owners would certainly have to make concessions to the players. Players would likely want to hit free agency sooner, perhaps after four years of service time instead of the current six. The minimum salary would almost certainly rise. In the last round of bargaining, after a three-month lockout in 2022, the MLBPA won a pre-arbitration bonus pool, a $50 million fund that awarded pre-arbitration players success-based bonuses. Skenes, for example, earned a record $3.4 million from the pool this season.

Advertise with us

More discussions will take place over the coming year, as both sides publicly try to avoid a lockout while privately preparing for it. Skenes will be at the center of it, as he is the youngest of eight players on the MLBPA executive subcommittee.

But in all likelihood, a deal isn’t expected before the current agreement expires. At this time next year, a lockout is expected to be underway. Only then will negotiations truly begin.

Buckle up. Only 364 days left to go.