In baseball, November is a time for roster deadlines. The Pirates face two important ones this week.
Tuesday at 6 p.m. is the deadline for teams to add prospects to their 40-man roster and protect them from the Rule 5 draft. Friday is the non-tender deadline, when the Pirates will have the option of keeping or parting ways with players like Oneil Cruz, Joey Bart, Jack Suwinski and Johan Oviedo.
But the Rule 5 draft is the first deadline. Held in December at baseball’s winter meetings, the Rule 5 draft allows teams with open 40-man roster spots to select players from other organizations outside their respective 40-man rosters. Two sets of players are eligible: players who were signed before age 18 and have been with an organization for five or more seasons; and players who were signed after 18 years old and have been with an organization for four or more seasons. Selected players must remain in the major leagues with their new team or they will be offered back to their previous organization.
The Pirates have already protected their top two eligible prospects by adding catcher Rafael Flores and left-hander Hunter Barco to the 40-man roster in September, but there are a few others who must be added if the Pirates want to protect them. They currently have two openings. There are officially 39 players on the 40-man roster, and sources told the Post-Gazette that infielder Cam Devanney plans on signing with the Hanshin Tigers in Japan.
The Pirates have a few decisions to make on whom to protect. Here’s a look at five Rule 5 draft-eligible players the Pirates could add to the 40-man roster by Tuesday’s deadline, as well as their respective MLB Pipeline team prospect ranks.
Outfielder/first baseman Esmerlyn Valdez (No. 15)
Valdez should be the easiest decision on this list.
Much has been written about the 21-year-old Valdez’s breakout 2025 season, as he was named as the Pirates farm system’s Willie Stargell Slugger of the Year after batting .286 with 26 homers and 86 RBIs at High-A Greensboro and Double-A Altoona. He then went to the Arizona Fall League, continued his hot stretch and won the competition’s offensive player of the year.
Valdez has played 51 games above High-A and isn’t necessarily majors-ready. However, his greatest strength — power — is something the Pirates desperately need. They can’t take the risk of leaving him unprotected, making Valdez a near-lock to be added by Tuesday.
Catcher Omar Alfonzo (No. 19)
Apart from Valdez, Alfonzo is the Pirates’ highest-ranked Rule 5-eligible prospect. However, he appears far less likely to be protected.
For one, he’s a catcher. Protecting him would mean the Pirates have five on their 40-man roster. He also was eligible for last year’s Rule 5 draft and wasn’t selected, though given he was then in High-A, he wasn’t expected to be taken.
Alfonzo, 22, batted .218 with three homers and 22 RBIs in 51 games at Double-A Altoona. He’s well regarded defensively, and a catcher-needy team could bank on that and use him as a backup while they wait for the offense to develop. However, it’s more likely he goes unclaimed even if he is left unprotected once again.
Right-hander Wilber Dotel (No. 28)
Dotel, 23, had an impressive 2025 campaign at Double-A Altoona, making 27 starts and pitching 125⅔ innings. He dropped his walk rate, increased his strikeouts and developed a splitter that vaulted him onto top prospect lists (Baseball America has him at No. 9). A midseason slump and a few short starts meant he finished with a 4.15 ERA, but Dotel still took major steps forward.
Dotel will probably start 2026 with Triple-A Indianapolis with a good shot at making his major league debut at some point. However, a team with less pitching depth than the Pirates could take the gamble on Dotel. He has the velocity and stuff to pitch in a big-league bullpen in 2026, so a team could stash him with the intent of returning him to a starting rotation at some point. Because of that, the Pirates may opt to protect him — you can never have too much starting pitching.
Right-hander Antwone Kelly (Not ranked)
Kelly is another Double-A right-hander who had a breakout 2025, though Kelly seems more likely to end up as a reliever. The 22-year-old from Aruba isn’t imposing, as he’s listed at 5-foot-10, 183 pounds, yet he boasts a triple-digit fastball and a solid changeup. He had a 3.03 ERA with 116 strikeouts in 107⅓ innings between High-A Greensboro and Double-A Altoona.
After his strong season, there isn’t a consensus for Kelly among prospect rankings. MLB Pipeline has him outside the Pirates’ top 30, while Baseball America has him at No. 7, directly ahead of Barco, Dotel and Valdez. Like Dotel, there’s a chance Kelly could make a late 2026 debut. If the Pirates don’t protect him, a pitching-needy team could try to stash him in a big-league bullpen.
Right-hander Brandan Bidois (Not ranked)
One last pitcher rounds out the Pirates’ possible Rule 5 protections, and it’s their Kent Tekulve Reliever of the Year honoree. Bidois, a 24-year-old from Australia, had a 0.74 ERA in 40 appearances between all four minor league affiliates, including a stretch of 11 consecutive appearances from Aug. 3-Sept. 9 when he didn’t allow a hit.
Unlike the others on this list, Bidois has had success as high as Triple-A Indianapolis, where he allowed one hit in 13 innings spanning nine appearances. He primarily uses a fastball that ranges from the mid- to upper 90s and a mid-80s slider that gets plenty of swings and misses. Whether the Pirates protect him depends on how they value his scoreless streak and how many relievers they are willing to carry on the 40-man roster.
Other eligible players
Other first-time eligible players include Jack Brannigan (No. 21), Anthony Solometo (No. 25) and prospects like Derek Diamond, Po-Yu Chen and Lonnie White Jr. A full list can be found here. After injury-plagued years from Brannigan and Solometo, neither appears likely to be selected.







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.