The day after the Pirates’ 2025 season ended, Henry Davis’ cellphone unexpectedly rang. It was Paul Skenes, who had a question and a request.

“He asked for a full report on everything I thought he could do to improve,” Davis said over the phone Thursday. “Obviously you can’t sit there and tell a guy with a 1.97 ERA who just mowed down the league he’s got to reinvent the wheel. But he’s gonna find these things and find ways to be even better next year. That’s what separates him.”

The relationship between Skenes and Davis has become a special one. It’s a friendship, where Davis and his wife, Sofia, hang out frequently with Skenes and his girlfriend, Livvy Dunne. Skenes and Davis also love to exchange baseball ideas and theories and find new ways to challenge one another. After all, they’re nerds trapped in elite athletes’ bodies, routinely obsessing over details and never truly satisfied.

Skenes has helped Davis become a better defensive catcher. Davis has earned Skenes’ trust as his personal catcher — and also someone who helped the Pirates post a 39-35 record when he was behind the plate, Pittsburgh pitchers possessing a 2.87 ERA while throwing to Davis.

Advertise with us

That relationship — and obviously Skenes’ 2025 success — is why Davis (and Jared Jones) flew to Florida to be with the Pirates ace when he was announced as the Cy Young winner.

“Got there in the nick of time,” Davis said. “Had an hour-and-40-minute flight delay, but it was great to be there. I’m just really happy for him.”

As for the request for advice, yes, Davis did oblige. He asked Skenes how in depth he wanted his catcher to go. This is how Davis described Skenes’ answer when he asked what the pitcher was looking for: “As much information as you can possibly give me.”

The day after the season ended.

Davis has never been one to sugarcoat things, although he didn’t want to share publicly the criticisms he had of Skenes or suggested tweaks they’ve come up with for 2026. But asked by a Cy Young Award winner what he saw, what didn’t work and what was really good, Davis knows enough by now that honesty is the best policy.

Advertise with us

“I do sometimes save my bullets,” Davis said. “That way, if I have feedback or he has an idea to do something and I’m like, ‘I think that’s a terrible idea,’ he trusts me.

“He also throws 100 [mph] with 17 pitches. For the most part, everything works when he wants to throw it. But on a few occasions where you might want to hold something back or not shift from something too early, it’s a really nice relationship. We communicate with each other well.”

Catching Skenes, along with several other of the Pirates’ young starting pitchers, has helped Davis develop as a catcher.

That list includes Jones, Braxton Ashcraft, Bubba Chandler, Mike Burrows and others with power stuff that Davis has had to learn how to handle — physically and properly calling games for them.

It’s why Davis has been able to remain with the big club despite hitting just .167 this past season and .181 for his career. He’s a far better defensive option than Joey Bart and has earned the trust of this pitching staff.

Advertise with us

“You’re catching power stuff every single night,” Davis said. “It’s the best practice, repetition and being in the fire. ... Guys with arsenals like Paul, it’s a fun challenge to try and put that together over the course of a game and put him in position to succeed.

“Obviously not too much of a challenge. I think we could call fastballs every pitch if we really wanted to. I enjoy it. It’s definitely like playing ‘MLB: The Show’ back there.”

Not all about Davis’ trip was positive, however. Before he arrived at Skenes’ house, he saw a story from NJ Advance Media about the pitcher reportedly telling an anonymous former teammate that he wanted to play for the Yankees.

Suffice to say, Davis wasn’t happy.

“I’ve never heard him say anything remotely close to that,” Davis said. “I think I spend a decent amount of time around him. The other guys on the team I talked to never heard him say anything about that. It’s frustrating, at least from my perspective, that it came out on a day that was supposed to celebrate him.

Advertise with us

“Paul’s not someone to talk about the future unless it’s about Pittsburgh. Since we’ve been drafted, the extent of our talks about the future have been about, ‘What can we do better in Pittsburgh? How can we turn this place around?’ I was definitely surprised to see it.”

A big remaining piece with the Pirates involves Davis, the first overall pick in 2021, realizing his potential at the plate.

That obviously hasn’t happened in three seasons, with Davis hitting .181 with a .556 OPS.

Davis knows that’s not good enough. He said he feels like he’s in a better place right now but also prefers to not discuss it more until results are there.

But everyone playing a part — from Davis to Skenes to Chandler and more — is what ultimately matters for the Pirates’ young core to succeed and stomp out nonsense like demanding a trade to the Yankees.

Advertise with us

It also helps that Skenes and Davis are similar people — focused, incapable of looking too far ahead or behind and crazy determined to get this figured out.

“The responsibility toward the city and organization to put a winner out there,” Davis said when asked to describe how the team's young core views breaking through and winning here. “I exemplify that more than anyone else in the group. I haven’t answered the call of what I’ve been asked to do when it comes to producing for this team. That’s all I put my energy into every day. I’m not going to stop until it happens.

“I know a lot of people share that sentiment of wanting to do everything we can to win in Pittsburgh. We take it for the challenge that it is and move toward it every day.”