Jason Mackey: Hello, everyone. Welcome to my weekly Pirates chat. Thanks for stopping by. You know the drill. We'll get started at noon. Feel free to ask away now.
Jason Mackey: And away we go ...
PrinceBob: If MLB owners decided they were going to close the game down until they got a salary cap no matter how long it took and how many seasons were lost, and assuming they really stuck to their guns and did that, do you think it would ever happen? Would the union ever give in?
Jason Mackey: I mean, I'm sure eventually. But it's a waste-of-time hypothetical. Owners aren't going to go without profits for that long. I question how much they're united in going without profits to get a cap. Look at what baseball just achieved -- the excitement and ratings surrounding the World Series. I think the sport would be better off with a cap/floor, believe me. I'm just saying I think there's probably going to be a line of thinking that doesn't want to disrupt momentum with the national TV bundle expiring.
Baron Dionis: Any buzz not the Pirates bench coach or third base coach? Would love to see Tony Beasley come back and Don Mattingly just left the Jays
Jason Mackey: I'd love to see Beasley, too. Makes a bunch of sense. I'm not sure why Don Mattingly would leave being the bench coach for a World Series entrant to take the same job with the Pirates. Maybe manager, but that job isn't available.
Read More
PrinceBob: I've seen suggestions that the Pirates shorten the outfield fences presumably for them to hit more home runs. Do you think it would help them win more games? After all, visitors would also hit more home runs.
Jason Mackey: I don't. I think they should play better & acquire better players. You're right. Would help both teams. And affect an advantage the Pirates have -- their pitching staff. I also don't think it's as dire as some make it out to be. There hasn't been offense for the home team at PNC because the roster hasn't been good enough, not enough spent. The fence is a much smaller part.
Benson DuBois: Will the Bucs roll with Triolo at 3B in '26? Bat came alive down the stretch. Fits the budget.
Jason Mackey: Maybe as a fill-in. But I think they'll look for an offensive upgrade. I think it's more likely Triolo plays short until Konnor Griffin is ready, then shifts into a super utility role. Which, to be fair, fits him & them perfectly. Especially if he hits.
Slippery Pete: Rank in order of bad to unwatchable: First Take, First Things First, Talk Pittsburgh.
Jason Mackey: Lemme first list all of those I actually watch ...
epiballo: Hi Jason! Thanks for the chats! Triolo is as good defensively as Hayes and came on at the plate late in the season. Hasn't he earned a shot at being the starter at third? I know the power numbers aren't ideal, but I don't want to see a 'he was good three years ago and we are hoping he recaptures that form.' How often does that work?
Jason Mackey: I think they need to go out and buy actual offense at third. Or trade for it. No hoping. No thinking two months is real. Go. Get. Offense. I don't think it's Triolo. It's nothing against him; there's just more evidence saying he's average at best. They need to upgrade at 3B and LF. Triolo isn't that.
demosthenes98: So now that it's over, what are your thoughts on the World Series?
Jason Mackey: Kind of a snooze, no?
demosthenes98: What's your stance on the designated hitter? Kind of seems pointless in a world with Shohei Ohtani, doesn't it?
Jason Mackey: I hate it. I wish pitchers hit. Of course, this is coming from a former pitcher who always at least thought he could hit. (I do have more homers in college baseball than most people here, however -- 1.)
demosthenes98: As someone who's been covering him for a long time, what do you think Ben Cherington's mindset will be heading into the offseason? Will the continuous, unchecked losing humble him? Or will the fact that he hasn't been fired for it give him more unearned/undeserved confidence?
Jason Mackey: I think Ben is very realistic where the Pirates are at. I don't think he's happy. I don't think he's unaware that a lot of it has been his fault. Or, if not directly his fault, he's the one at the controls and warrants blame. I think he sees this as an offseason where he needs to hit on a bunch of stuff to save his job. As he obviously should. I'm not defending anything, but I can't imagine he's having a great time here, either.
demosthenes98: You wrote a story last week with the headline "Pirates largely satisfied with development strides made[.]" I'm not faulting you or whoever wrote that headline, but...given, well, everything, really, does anyone employed by Bob Nutting have any business being even the least bit satisfied?
Jason Mackey: I mean, the headline doesn't say they're satisfied with the major league win-loss record, does it? Doesn't say they're satisfied with the offensive numbers put up by the big club. They've made strides in the minor leagues. They've stunk offensively in MLB. I don't think it's crazy to say both can be true.
epiballo: What are your thoughts on Cutch? Some think he does not bring enough to DH, and signing him is more PR than improvement of the club.
Jason Mackey: I'm sort of in the middle. Any other place, I'd move on. Cutch does have a legacy here, and I think you have to respect that. My offer would be a part-time DH for like $3 million. And this has to be it. If he's not willing to do that, I'll wear it. The ultimate charge should be improving the club, and they can go other places to do that. As long as they actually do it, of course.
Benson DuBois: If the Pirates trade Keller, should we prepare to be disappointed in the return? At 3 years and $54MM owed, other teams could simply sign a comparable FA.
Jason Mackey: If I said you shouldn't be disappointed, I should cite a recent example where they traded a player with term and proven performance for multiple pieces, right?
That example doesn't exist. So, yeah. Can see why anyone would be skeptical.
They obviously need to hit on a potential Keller trade after plenty of swings & misses.
PhilinCT: Mr. Mackey, always grateful for your time and insight. So Bae and Perguero are off the 40 (a necessary decision). Who else SHOULD be removed from the 40 (including those who may come off the 60-day IL) to make room for Rule 5 and acquisitions? Thanks as always.
Jason Mackey: My pleasure. Thank you for participating and making this chat special.
They need to bring guys off the 60-day injured list today by 5 p.m. That shouldn't be hard. Believe they're only at 40 now.
For Rule 5 stuff, which is again down the line, could easily look at Darrell-Hicks, Sanders, Simon, Valdez or Canario.
epiballo: Will this be the offseason the Bucs finally make a splash addition or (gasp) two that energizes the fan base, or more of the same potential prospects and fading stars?
Jason Mackey: I'm not expecting them to make a splash because when I think of that, I think of like Tucker, Schwarber or one of the big-time names. But I do think they're going to do something that's more aggressive than they've done in the past. (Low bar, I know.)
Johnny: I saw in your last Q&A you said that you asked Bob Nutting what it's like to be hated. I don't ever recall reading that you asked him that. But if you say so, I would absolutely love to know how he feels about being the most absolutely hated, most despised, detested, abhorred, person in Pittsburgh(and possibly all of the sports world). I mean the guy is just absolutely execrated everywhere, and for very good reason. What do you think his true feelings are on that? And not the generic HR answer he drivels out about "appreciating the passion of the fans". Give me break, winnutting.
Jason Mackey: Sure. Here's the quote. From March 2021: "I respect that they care so much to get mad. They deserve the team to perform better certainly than it did last year. They expect me to make the decisions, frankly, that we made. It was time for a fresh direction. They deserve to expect that. They should know that I appreciate and respect the passion and the caring."
Nippleponi: Still pretty sore over here. Great job on the chats. Looking forward to another off season of lousy free agent signings.
Jason Mackey: I can't believe the Poni nipple talk has made its way over here.
Firsthoff: Still surprised at the lack of any real outcry at the retention of Cherington at GM. I recall reading around the end of August about his departure being a foregone done-deal. Then when it was announced he was staying - nothing really in print or by fans. Have we all just given up and moved on?
Jason Mackey: There's been a lack of outcry over Cherington staying? I thought there was a fairly decent outcry myself.
epiballo: Do you know if the two most frustrating Pirates, Davis and Cruz, are playing winter ball? If not, any word on what they are doing to prepare for spring training? They need to step up if the Bucs are to compete in 2026.
Jason Mackey: Same answer. Nothing communicated to us. I have not heard if they are. I'd frankly be shocked if it happened. They need to improve, but I'm not sure winter ball is the setting.
russellhalloffame34: Jason, I know you have been a critic of Cherington and Nutting rightfully so. With the lockout looming this the last chance in the Skenes era to get bats to get competitive, because once arbitration hits he's gone. What's your percentage of the trust you have of those two to make the Pirates competitive in 2026?
Jason Mackey: First off, I don't think he's gone once he hits arb. Let's start there. Two, I'm not good at percentages, but here's how I think about that:
I have skepticism now, sure. On the spending front with Nutting and the execution of productive deals relative to Cherington. There isn't much evidence to convince anyone otherwise.
However, look back at the 2013 Pirates. They pitched it well and sat around 18-21 in most offensive categories. Do I think the Pirates can get there? I do. And I think if they do, they could have a pretty decent season.
Ryan: Good afternoon Jason with Fred agency Starting today anyone you think the pirates will be signing also i think Tony Beasley comes back as a coach GO PIRATES
Jason Mackey: Would love to see Beasley back. I think that makes a ton of sense.
Obviously not any of the upper-tier free agents. I think about guys in need of playing time who might have a bounce-back. Max Kepler would make sense. Michael Conforto or Cedric Mullins, too. I like lefty bats at PNC. I also think trades will be important.
Firsthoff: Do you think Henry Davis will be on the roster next year. I feel he is burning through his 9-lives. I would love for him to turn it up a notch and get over .240. Do you feel he is a poster-child for the Bucs lack of player-development over the past 5-10 years?
Jason Mackey: I think he will be on the roster, yes. I don't think he's a poster-child for the Pirates' lack of player development. Oddly, Firsthoff, he's developed a lot as a defensive catcher. He just hasn't been able to hit. I think there comes a time where you need to see offense. That's fair. But right now he's far better than Joey Bart defensively. He's also a 1-1 pick who works his butt off. I'm willing to hear him out a little longer to see if he can figure it out.
epiballo: I am with you on ditching the DH. It took away late inning drama and managerial decisions. Who didn't love when a pitcher ... a pitcher ... came through with a key hit! Oh ... a question. What was your W-L record in college?
Jason Mackey: Right. I miss the strategy associated with it.
I don't know, honestly. Probably not very good. I was a reliever. Made a few starts. They weren't good. I had 2 1/2 pitches, a flat four-seamer I struggled to locate (with OK velo), a cement mixer of a breaking ball and a halfway decent change/split. I wasn't dominating anyone.
Joe Starkey: Limits, Limits, Limits, Limits, Limits, Limits, Limits, Limits, Limits, Limits, Limits, Limits, Limits, Limits, Thank you Mr Hester, Limits, Limits, Limits
Jason Mackey: You OK, Joe?
Wayward: Jason, thanks for the chats. Colin's article got me thinking. What is Keller's trade value? Is he enough to get someone like Westburg?
Jason Mackey: Yeah, I think could make sense. I don't know his trade value, primarily because it's whatever anyone will give up. But a package centered around those two could certainly make sense.
epiballo: This came up elsewhere and I turn to you for an answer. Bae was often put in to pinch run, and then stayed anchored at first. Do the players have the option of stealing if they think they can, or are they told when to steal. I know it is situational ... I am asking in general. Thanks!
Jason Mackey: It depends on the player. If you're a veteran, you steal bases and know what you're doing, you have more latitude than the young guy who runs into outs (like Bae). You also have to figure, someone like Bae may be less willing to take a chance because if it doesn't work out, he's jeopardizing his career. I'm not talking about going when told. I'm talking about going on his own.
Cullen: Cherington got lampooned prior to last season for spending dollars on analytics, tech, and development instead of free agents per yours and Noah's reporting. Would you attribute any of the leaps forward in minor league development to that spending?
Jason Mackey: I can't say they're not linked. If that makes sense. But I don't think it's the biggest input. You could maybe say coaching, too. There are a lot of things that could explain some improved development. It's also not all the way where it should be.
Cullen: Any chance the Pirates go after one of the Japanese international free agents this offseason? Okamoto is projected to get under $20 million for 4 years and should be able to stick at 3B.
Jason Mackey: It would make sense for them to try, certainly. But these guys have their pick of teams. Why would they come over here, with leverage, and choose to play for the Pirates when other, more competitive teams are offering multi-year deals? They could try to find a diamond in the rough out of Japan or Korea, but that's getting harder and harder to do.
Cullen: Could Isaac Parades be a realistic trade target for the Pirates now that the Astros have a full infield after acquiring Correa and their top prospect being MLB ready? They desperately need pitching so it seems to be a good fit
Jason Mackey: I've certainly heard worse suggestions. Especially with Bill Murphy. Might have a lens on the clubhouse character, that sort of thing. They need more lefty power -- Parades hits right-handed -- but would just depend on the ask.
Steve Bonanno: Hey, Buddy, welcome home. Missed you. If you were the G.M., and had an extra $100 million, how would you try to save my team that hasn't been to the World Series since I was 15?
Jason Mackey: An extra $100 million? Holy Lord. So the Pirates would spend $190 million? Can you imagine? I'd buy bats. Pretty easy. I'd probably get 3 for $75 million or 4 for $80, then use the rest to bolster my bullpen.
Wayward: Jason, who do you think the Bucs best potential trade partners are? Orioles, Rangers, Angels, maybe the Blue Jays?
Jason Mackey: Orioles are up there. Could be the A's because of Bleday, who I think would make sense. Good with some of those you mentioned. I'd put the Rays on there because of Brandon Lowe. The Isaac Parades suggestion doesn't stink, so maybe the Astros, too.
JuniataKid: Is Cherington’s thinking that if he can lower the overall club ERA by around half a run or so, he won’t need to acquire all that much hitting in the off-season?
Jason Mackey: I think his thinking is that if they can lower the ERA by a half run, it'll help. Because there'll only be so much ceiling on the offense.
I say it that way because I don't think they're resigned to stinking offensively. They know they have a lot to fix. But if you're going to be pitch-first and hit-enough, a half-run could actually matter.
Joe Starkey: No, I’m the farthest from ok.
Jason Mackey: Alright, Joe.
epiballo: The Bucs have the pitching (and then some) to compete. They need a power bat or two and have their players (Reynolds, Cruz, Horwitz) step up. They WILL compete in 2026 and be over .500! Bucs fan since the '60s ... am I delusional?
Jason Mackey: I don't think so. If you told me they were going to spend $100 million and actually hit on their offseason moves for bats, I actually think they could be pretty good.
Firsthoff: To f/u on Henry Davis. I love the kid. Unlike others, he really shows how much he cares and is trying. His defensive improvment was so obvious. This is not so much a reflection on him but Bucco PD - if he improves significantly on D but digresses offensively, what does that say? Would he benefit from some new blood mentoring/
Jason Mackey: Yeah, I can personally attest that Henry Davis obsesses over this. Dude cares a crazy amount. I know he hasn't hit. He'd be the first to tell you. It ain't for lack of effort. If he was hurting the team, I'd say to get him out. He's not. He's actually been pretty good defensively.
epiballo: Who will qualify for the post-season first: the Pirates or the Penguins?
Jason Mackey: Very possibly the Penguins. This coming April.
Johnny: Again, spare us the generic, HR-fed drivel about "appreciating the passion". You mean appreciating the hatred? What do you think his true feelings are? Not that it's important. We all hate him, we all want him gone, yesterday. Just sell the team and go away forever, loser.
Jason Mackey: Dude, I can't make him answer a certain way. You said you would love to read his answer, so I went back to the interview and got the quote. Don't know what you're looking for me to do. Not interested in perpetuating the conversation because no matter what I say, you're just gonna use me to express your vitriol.
And, to be clear, you have every right to be mad. I just don't understand what yelling at me accomplishes.
epiballo: Most think that Keller will be traded this offseason. Do you see any position players being moved out?
Jason Mackey: None of any consequence. Like, if they packaged Termarr or Yorke, does that count? I think if someone made an offer for Bart, they would listen. But coming off a down year offensively, and one where he also struggled behind the plate, not sure that's gonna happen.
JuniataKid: Their ceiling on hitting relies on a ton of “ifs” breaking their way. If Reynolds, Cruz, Gonzales, insert-catcher-here and Triolo can hit consistently, if Griffin is ready. Please tell me they’re looking for a LOT more than just a third baseman and left fielder.
Jason Mackey: They're looking at a lot, Juniata. Will they do a lot? We are talking about the Pirates. Same time, I'm fine with giving Reynolds and Cruz a chance to show they're better. They very well might be. Gonzales shouldn't be a shoe-in. One of the four catchers needs to hit. Then you go buy a couple bats. Again, you should be aiming to be 18-21 in runs, with an elite pitching staff. That would be both doable and effective.
epiballo: Kudos on your article about Bonds and others qualifying for the Hall of Fame. It generated a TON of good discussion. Always look forward to your articles!
Jason Mackey: Thank you. Glad you enjoyed it.
Keemosawbee: Is there any person or persons that Bob Nutting would listen to consider selling the team, or at least be persuaded to listen to offers? Think of it, he could get a billion dollars and no longer be despised in this town. Pirates alumni, Rob Manfred, or anybody else? He's seems hell bent on torturing us.
Jason Mackey: He's convicted in his beliefs, yes. Q a little bit ago had me going back through that 2021 interview. Here's part of an answer on why he continues to own the team.
"Our family has been in a family business since 1890. The team has been around since 1887. I think of myself as a fourth generation. What that teaches you is to think very long-term and to think about stewardship. So, my goal would be to steward and steer and help the Pirates flourish to the greatest degree that they can for as long as possible."
Not defending any of it. Long past time for a change. Just trying to answer the question as completely as possible.
Firsthoff: Thanks for the insight and chat Jason. Johnny will be ok. Bucco fans have no other outlet to vent as we cannot afford an airplane and banner.
Jason Mackey: This made me laugh. Some can afford an airplane and banner!
Johnny: Fair enough. I'm happy to hear you hate the DH in the NL, because I hate it too. That being said, since Ohtani pitches and also hits as a DH in the same game, I think Paul Skenes should do the same. Apparently, he hit really well in college, and I'm sure he'd be an upgrade from the many sub-.200 hitters we pencil in on a nightly basis. What could it hurt? Of course the pirates won't do it. But I think they should. Your thoughts?
Jason Mackey: The Pirates gave him the opportunity. He turned it down. Here's my story on that from 2023: https://www.post-gazette.com/sports/pirates/2023/08/17/pirates-paul-sk...
epiballo: Best Pirate world champion manager? My vote is for Danny Murtaugh who should be in the hall of fame. Will he make the Bucs hall of fame?
Jason Mackey: The only one to win multiple WS. Who am I to argue with that? Believe he's already in the Pirates HOF. Should be in the National Baseball Hall of Fame and Museum.
Matt: Is there any shot that Konnor Griffin breaks Camp as the big league shortstop? Has there been any talk of maybe trying to get a long-term extension done for him or Paul Skenes this off-season?
Jason Mackey: There's at least a chance, yes. I don't know if it's likely because we're talking about the Pirates here; they've typically been pretty cautious about such things. I could see them at least wanting Griffin to start at Triple-A.
That being said, now that we're in the actual offseason, I don't know how they don't at least have cursory conversations on that. Makes too much sense. If I'm the Pirates, that's a way to spend money smartly, make a wise investment AND prove something to your fans.
Johnny: Firstoff is right. We have no other outlet. Yet being a bucco fan is pain, perpetual torture that seems infinite. Thank you for doing this.
Jason Mackey: Haha. I love yinz. You're the best. Just every so often I need to remind that I can question, criticize and talk to these people to convey my feelings and fan sentiment. But I can't control how they act.
epiballo: You are right: Murtaugh is in the Pirates Hall of Fame. He was also inducted into the Irish American baseball Hall of Fame (2024)!
Jason Mackey: Nailed it.
Johnny: PS. When nutting says "stewardship" I see red.
Jason Mackey: Don't blame you. If you've been doing something this long and you've won so little and so many people are upset, maybe it's just not working. Maybe let someone else have a turn.
Jason Mackey: OK, folks. That does it for this week. Gotta run. Thanks so much for the great questions. We'll be back next Thursday for another edition. Stay well!






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.