When the Pirates made the unusual decision to move on from Oscar Marin as pitching coach earlier this month, they did so because they felt there was another level to reach.
They appear to have found an excellent candidate in Bill Murphy, hiring the 35-year-old away from the Houston Astros, a source confirmed to the Post-Gazette on Monday.
As easy as it might be to criticize the Pirates at times, this makes plenty of sense, as Murphy comes from an organization that absolutely knows what it’s doing on the pitching front.
“We have a lot of resources here,” former Pirate Gerrit Cole told the Post-Gazette in 2019, at the height of his Houston ascent. “We’re always talking through things, always talking pitching. … We’re constantly trying to evolve and stay ahead of the curve.”
Murphy was obviously a huge part of that success, the stuff that saw the Astros consistently produce some of the best pitching numbers throughout Major League Baseball.
And, not to mention, take Cole from very good to ridiculously elite during a two-year stretch where he went 35-10 in 65 starts, striking out 602 over 412 2/3 innings, pitching to a 2.68 ERA and racking up 11.8 wins above replacement, per Baseball Reference.
Read More
A Cranford, N.J. native, Murphy joined Houston's major league staff in 2021. Over the past four seasons, only Dodgers and Phillies pitchers have more wins above replacement (per FanGraphs) than Houston at 75.3.
That elite staff is something the Pirates obviously feel they could have with Paul Skenes, Bubba Chandler, Mitch Keller, Braxton Ashcraft, Johan Oviedo, Mike Burrows and others.
Only six teams had a better ERA than the Pirates (3.76) this season, while Pittsburgh’s starting rotation was responsible for 13.9 fWAR, fifth-most in baseball.
It’ll be on Murphy to take the pitching staff to another level. To marry analytics with feel. To monitor innings and keep everyone fresh. To help a bunch of talented pitchers add and improve pitches.
Murphy certainly has a history of doing that stuff in Houston, helping the Astros win the World Series in 2022 amid a flat-out dominant pitching season.
There’s a link here to Pirates manager Don Kelly, who spent 2019 as a first-base coach with the Astros, although it’s unclear how much that had to do with the hire.
Murphy joined the Astros organization and worked his way up from a rookie-ball coach with Greeneville in 2016 to a job with short-season Tri-City the following year. Murphy was in Double-A Corpus Christi in 2018 and the following year became Houston’s minor league pitching coordinator.
After spending the 2020 season at Houston’s alternate site, Murphy joined the major league staff in 2021, over the next four years helping the Astros lead the American League in ERA (3.65) and strikeouts per nine innings (9.27).
Murphy was integral in the development of Hunter Brown, Spencer Arrighetti and Ronel Blanco, as well as the improvement of Yusei Kikuchi after joining the team at 2024 trade deadline.
A neat personal nugget on Murphy: He’s bilingual and also worked a lot with Latin American pitchers such as Framber Valdez, Cristian Javier and Luis Garcia.
Everything came together in a big way for Murphy and the Astros in 2022, when they led the AL in ERA (2.90), batting average against (.212) and WHIP (1.09). Those were also franchise-best marks for a 162-game season.
Also that year, in '22, Houston’s bullpen ERA of 2.80 was the best in the majors and the third-best in franchise history before Astros pitchers held opponents to a .172 batting average against and 0.95 WHIP that postseason.
Murphy is a Rutgers graduate and pitched four years there. He also majored in psychology, had a history minor and later earned his MBA — meaning he’s probably not a dummy.
The move to not bring Marin back was met with some skepticism, the result of the pitching success the Pirates achieved. At the same time, the best pitching organizations in MLB are places like Tampa Bay, Cleveland, Houston and Philadelphia.
That the Pirates would try and pluck someone from the Astros makes a lot of sense. They believe in power stuff and challenging hitters in the zone, the same as Skenes, Keller, Ashcraft, Chandler, Burrows and Oviedo.
It’s not just the starters, either. Astros relievers have also been among the best in the game, Houston relying on analytics to inform matchup decisions, as well as tailoring a pitching plan to each guy’s individual strengths.
All of it should play very well here, giving the Pirates a legitimate chance to take their staff to another level.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.