When Derek Shelton met with his club before the start of spring training, he made the standard for this year’s Pirates crystal clear.

“I don’t know if I’ve been more excited about the beginning of camp since the first time I took this job,” he told the team prior to its first official practice of the 2025 season. “The main message at the beginning of pitcher-catcher camp was the word ‘win.’ Winning, and the conversation around it.”

That speech was given in February. By early May, Shelton was fired as the club’s manager, following a 12-26 start to the regular season.

The Pirates played so poorly through their first 38 games of the year that very little mattered afterward. They never spent a day above .500 and finished in last place for the fifth time in the past seven seasons.

Advertise with us

Shelton’s replacement, Don Kelly, brought forth better play. But even that, to the tune of a 59-65 record, wasn’t good enough. There were a handful of good moments, but overall, the year was one many players should hope to forget.

The team took a step forward on the mound, leading MLB with 18 shutouts. The defense improved as the year progressed. But their offensive woes from start to finish were too significant to overcome.

The Pirates played in an MLB-leading 60 one-run games in 2025. The offense’s inability to provide a timely hit led to a 25-35 record in those contests. Had there been a few more big hits, perhaps this end of season review would have gone differently.

But nonetheless, the Pirates’ 2025 campaign is officially in the books. The team has deemed both Kelly and general manager Ben Cherington worthy of another shot to get things right, with the former being extended and the latter being retained.

The entire organization must analyze the past 162 games to ensure a similar mess can be avoided. And while they take their first steps toward 2026, allow us to give one final glance at the year that was.

Advertise with us

Below is the Post-Gazette’s Pirates report card for the 2025 season:

Starting pitchers: A

2024 grade: B

The starting rotation earned the highest grade in last year’s end-of-season report card. They did so again in 2025 with an even better showing. The Pirates had one of the most impactful starting rotations in MLB this year. The unit ranked fifth in fWAR (13.9), sixth in both ERA (3.71) and Fielding Independent Pitching (3.87), and tied for sixth-best in WHIP (1.19). And all of this was achieved by a group that included numerous young arms with workload constraints.

Leading the charge, of course, was Paul Skenes. Last year’s National League Rookie of the Year is the favorite to win this year’s National League Cy Young Award, and it’s easy to understand why. Skenes led MLB’s 52 qualified starting pitchers in ERA (1.97) and FIP (2.36).

He was second in fWAR (6.5), losing to Detroit’s Tarik Skubal by a tenth of a point. He had the fourth-best WHIP (0.95) and was tied for the fourth-most strikeouts (216). He logged 187 ⅔ innings, a total that could’ve been much higher if the team were competitive this year. He still finished with the 10th-most in the league.

Advertise with us

But Skenes wasn’t the only one who improved. Mitch Keller was his steady, consistent self. Johan Oviedo looked solid in his first season post-Tommy John surgery. Rookies Braxton Ashcraft, Mike Burrows and Bubba Chandler all looked good after getting their call to the show.

Left-handers Bailey Falter and Andrew Heaney both ended the year on different teams, but at least the former had another good showing while in Pittsburgh. Heaney fell off after a decent start to the season. Carmen Mlodzinski, meanwhile, proved he’s better off in the bullpen.

Overall, this group was very good. It could’ve likely been better if the second-half schedule held any sort of meaning, thus giving the Pirates a reason to use the younger arms earlier and often. Nonetheless, it’s hard not to feel optimistic about the rotation moving forward.

With Jared Jones set to return in 2026 and top-100 prospect Hunter Barco also likely to join the mix, this unit won’t require much attention this offseason. Few additions are required. All resources should go toward ensuring another year of their collective effort doesn’t go to waste.

Bullpen: B+

2024 grade: D

Advertise with us

The bullpen wasn’t as productive as the starting rotation, but it was much, much better than last year. David Bednar, after getting optioned to Triple-A on April 1, returned to his old self upon return. He was arguably the best closer in baseball throughout his final stretch as a Pirate. Cheers to him going out on top.

Dennis Santana looks to be a more-than-capable replacement for Bednar. He had a few hiccups this year, but the good far outweighed the bad. While this current regime has failed many times, Santana might go down as their best overall success story.

On the note of stories, good luck finding a better one than Isaac Mattson. After pitching just a few major league innings last year, Mattson established himself as a reliable high-leverage option in 2025. Time and time again, he was thrust into the most unfavorable of settings and walked out unscathed. His pitch mix isn’t complicated, but it works. He should enter 2026 as a virtual lock to make the opening day roster.

Of course, not every mid-to-late inning reliever was as productive as Bednar, Santana and Mattson. Some players showed flashes of potential, such as Chase Shugart and Dauri Moreta, the latter in his first year back from Tommy John. There were also a few flops, such as Ryan Borucki and Tanner Rainey, who were both designated for assignment.

The Pirates will have a few projects to continue in 2026. Kyle Nicolas is the most notable of the bunch, as he wasn’t as good as last year but still has potential. Justin Lawrence, who looked really good in April before suffering an injury that cost him most of the season, is another. But there are also a handful of relievers who could probably use a change of scenery, such as Colin Holderman and Yohan Ramirez.

Advertise with us

Overall, regardless of who was healthy and who wasn’t, the group consistently worked well throughout the season. A large reason for this is due to the overwhelming success among the hybrid, long-relief projects that began in late May and lasted through the end of the year.

Ashcraft started the trend, offering the Pirates quality length in both low- and high-leverage spots. Mlodzinski, after failing as a starter, followed and was arguably even better in this role. Burrows made some nice contributions in September out of the bullpen, as did Chandler, who was electric in his three relief appearances before earning a spot in the rotation.

The bullpen could probably use a few veteran additions over the offseason. But overall, it already has the bones of a unit that can be an asset next season, especially if the pitching group continues to use the hybrid strategy for young, high-level prospects.

Pitching depth ruined last year’s bullpen. It was the complete opposite in 2025 and should be the same come next spring.

Catchers: D

2024 grade: C

Advertise with us

Now that the fun reviews are out of the way, it’s time to address the real problems of the team, and catcher is a perfect place to begin. The Pirates started the 2025 season with three backstops — Joey Bart, Henry Davis and Endy Rodriguez — competing to make the opening day roster. None of them were anywhere close to the player the organization likely hoped to get.

We’ll start with Bart, who after showing decent pop in 2024 — earning him the nickname “Joey Barrells” — slugged .122 points less this year. He played in 13 more games, had 50 more plate appearances, but finished with nine fewer homers and drove in 15 fewer runs.

To make things worse, offense still remains the best part of Bart’s game. His defense is subpar at best, making him difficult to consistently play on a team that’s built to win through pitching.

Next we have Henry Davis. We can start with the good news: Davis is a good defender. He, at the very least, will likely remain in MLB for the foreseeable future due to his ability to aid a pitching staff. Starters and relievers alike rave about his ability to call a game behind the plate. But for as good as he’s become defensively, he’s even worse with the bat.

It’s truly worth wondering if Davis will ever even come close to being a league-average hitter, which is all he really needs to be to secure the primary catching spot. This year he needed to take a step forward at the plate, but instead he dramatically regressed.

Advertise with us

Last we have Endy Rodriguez, who, after suffering yet another elbow injury, will enter 2026 with legitimate questions pertaining to his future at the position. And only part of those questions have to do with health. Whenever Rodriguez was healthy, he was by far the worst backstop among the trio. And now with Rafael Flores in the system, having already gained a taste of the big leagues, it’s hard to see a future where Rodriguez becomes the everyday catcher in Pittsburgh.

As a unit, Pirates catchers were worth 1.0 fWAR, sixth-worst in MLB. They were an above-average group defensively but hit for a 71 wRC+, meaning they were 29% below league average for their position. Davis’ defense and Flores’ potential as a hitter might not make this position group the top priority to address this offseason, but no one here is above replacement.

Overall, they had a bad year, one worse than 2024.

Infield: D+

2024 grade: C-

The hardest group on the team to grade. Defensively they were rather good, especially after the first month of the season. Offensively they were bad, despite having the lone qualified hitter on the team to finish with an above-league-average OPS.

Advertise with us

That honor belongs to Spencer Horwitz (119 wRC+), who was the best performer among the group. After missing nearly the first two months of the season due to a wrist injury, he found his footing in his first year as an everyday major league starter. His glove was reliable and his bat improved more and more as the season progressed. He’s by no means a superstar, but he’s someone the organization should feel good about heading into 2026.

At second base, primarily, was Nick Gonzales. It’s worth wondering how much Gonzales’ season was hampered by an ankle injury that forced him to miss extended time. He hit well in spurts but struggled with consistency. The pop is still missing, and his entire slash line dropped from 2024, despite playing two more games this year.

Adam Frazier was a decent fill-in for Gonzales, while others who saw time at second base at the end of the year played so sparingly they’re not even worth completely assessing. Overall, the Pirates’ second base position hit for an 80 wRC+, which ranked 23rd of out the league’s 30 clubs.

Shortstop was by far the worst overall spot in the infield. Isiah Kiner-Falefa hit for a decent average in the first half but provided hardly any form of pop at the bottom of the order. His defense was also an issue.

Jared Triolo looked better at short when he was recalled from Triple-A in August. But for some reason, the Pirates stopped playing him there in September. The team’s shortstop position hit for a 77 wRC+, 25th-best in MLB.

Advertise with us

Last we have third base. The good news was Pittsburgh’s hot corner was home to the best defense in MLB. Pirates third basemen, per Fangraphs, led the position with a 19.8 “Def,” a metric that combines fielding runs above average and positional runs. But paired with that defense was the worst offensive production of any infield position group, boasting a 57 wRC+.

Leading the charge on that front was Ke’Bryan Hayes, who was traded to the Reds on July 30. While his departure created opportunities for others, none of the replacements did much better at the plate.

As a whole, the infield has a few decent pieces, but no true foundation. That will perhaps change next year if Konnor Griffin, the game’s top-rated prospect, successfully establishes himself as the Pirates’ everyday shortstop. But it will take a lot more than one talented rookie to get this group where it needs to be. Another addition, ideally at third base, is an absolute must this offseason.

As is, the Pirates infield just isn’t good enough. It’s even a bit worse than last year.

Outfield: F

2024 grade: D-

Advertise with us

While the infield was the hardest group to grade, the outfield was the easiest. Once again, this area of the team absolutely killed the Pirates, both in the field and at the plate. And a big reason for this can be attributed to the team’s two biggest disappointments of the season: Oneil Cruz and Bryan Reynolds.

Cruz started the year looking as though 2025 would be his breakout season. He brought life to the Pirates’ lineup after being moved into the leadoff spot mid-April, terrorizing teams with his combination of raw power and speed. But as the year continued, Cruz cooled down. He eventually started to struggle, and by August, he was essentially a lost cause.

Cruz finished the year with a .200 batting average, the lowest among the 145 qualified hitters in MLB. His 86 wRC+ also ranked 11th-worst among that group. Paired with that poor production at the plate was questionable effort, which led to heavy scrutiny and even a mid-season benching. There were still some highlights. He led the club with 20 home runs, tied with Mets superstar Juan Soto for the National League lead in stolen bases (38), but his year was still nowhere close to good enough.

Reynolds was equally upsetting. After earning himself All-Star honors in 2024, the team’s highest-paid position player was a no-show for the first half of the season. His defense regressed once again, and his bat didn’t heat up until the season’s final few months.

Excluding the 2020 pandemic-shortened season, Reynolds experienced career lows in fWAR (1.1), batting average (.245), on-base percentage (.318), slugging (.402) and wRC+ (99). His 16 homers were tied for his lowest total in a full season since his rookie year in 2019, when he played in 20 fewer games. He also reached a career high in strikeouts (173), 17 more than last year’s mark.

Advertise with us

Behind those two were a group that again, provided little to no assistance.

Tommy Pham was the primary third outfielder. He started the year playing well in the field but doing absolutely nothing at the plate. His bat warmed up mid-season, potentially due to him fixing an issue with his vision, but he fell off in the final month. Others, such as Jack Suwinski and Alexander Canario, weren’t even good enough to replace Pham.

For the second straight year, the Pirates outfield held the entire club back. Its defense was horrible, ranking 22nd in the league per Fangraphs. Its offense was even worse, posting a collective wRC+ of 84, which ranked 27th out of the 30 major league outfields.

Of all the areas that need to be addressed over the winter, this is where the heaviest focus should be. No player should be above replacement, regardless of their potential or current contract.

Designated hitter: D

2024 grade: B-

Advertise with us

It might be time for a difficult conversation. Andrew McCutchen has long been the face of the Pirates’ franchise. He was the first true superstar a large chunk of the fanbase was able to watch throughout the entirety of his prime. His return went well in 2023. He was still solid in 2024. But he regressed in 2025, which leaves his future with both the Pirates, and perhaps even MLB as a whole, in question.

McCutchen was worth minus-0.1 fWAR this season, making him the fifth-least qualified hitter in MLB, per FanGraphs. He also boasted the 13th-worst slugging percentage, an ugly mark for a full-time hitter.

He wasn’t the biggest problem in the lineup, but unlike the past two years, he wasn’t an asset, either. It’s not hard to detect his frustration with the franchise. He wants to win — and in Pittsburgh. But as McCutchen himself has noted, he has to uphold his end of the agreement, as well.

McCutchen was not good enough in 2025. Not by league standards, and not by his own standards. Should he return in 2026, it might be best for him to do so in a lesser role. If others who regressed in 2025 should have to earn their spot next year, he should, as well.

This might not be goodbye for the franchise legend, but this was arguably the worst year of his long, distinguished career.

Advertise with us

Coaching: C+

2024 grade: D+

Should this grade pertain to Kelly alone, it might be a bit higher. But even still, the Pirates finished below .500 under Kelly’s 124 games at the helm. That’s nowhere close to good enough, as he himself noted Monday after being extended as the club’s manager.

There were many things Kelly did well this year. He revived an essentially dead clubhouse. He fought for his players, embraced the hardest challenges that came with his new role, and at times had the Pirates playing good baseball.

But there were still a handful of ugly moments under Kelly. The team suffered a few extended losing streaks. The fielding improved, as did the pitching, but the offense remained inconsistent. With the right group around him, the Pirates can potentially take a step forward in 2026. But Kelly can’t do this alone.

The pitching group was better under the continued coaching of Oscar Marin. The offense, however, was even worse than last year under first-year hitting coach Matt Hague. Other assistants also delivered highs and lows throughout the season. But after another last-place finish, the coaching staff should have its share of changes heading into 2026. Just because Kelly is back doesn’t mean everyone else should be as well.

Note: Analysis on the front office and ownership can be read here