Bob Nutting wasn’t in attendance at PNC Park on Monday afternoon when his club officially announced that Don Kelly had been extended as the Pirates manager. No one said where Nutting was, but his absence wasn’t a surprise.
Following the 2025 season, which resulted in the ninth last-place finish since he assumed primary ownership of Pittsburgh’s baseball team, it’s easy to understand why Nutting was unwilling to show his face on the North Shore. Heck, it’s something to which many of the fans that support his ball club can relate.
What Nutting missed was a glowing first press conference for his club’s manager, someone who takes over a team that openly questioned the owner’s commitment to winning. Those questions will almost certainly persist into the offseason, now that it’s known both team president Travis Williams and general manager Ben Cherington will return in their respective roles for a seventh season.
But don’t worry. Nutting said, through a team-issued statement, that winning is a priority.
“This season, we fell well short as an organization both on and off the field,” Nutting said. “It has been unacceptable. Our focus must shift to execution, to delivering wins. Results are the only thing that matter. We owe it to our fans, to the city, and to the legacy of this team to get it right. Ben and everyone in the organization fully understands what is expected, and that the work ahead demands urgency. Today’s announcement of Donnie is the first of many steps we will take this offseason to bring winning baseball back to Pittsburgh.”
Everything Nutting said in that paragraph is fine on the surface, unless one is familiar with the messenger. For those who’ve been paying attention, it’s rather easy to see where things are heading. It’s because we’ve all seen this movie — and we’re set to watch it again, for a seventh time.
Read More
‘Well short’
Let’s start here. Nutting said the Pirates fell “well short” as an organization, both “on and off the field.” He’s correct. The 2025 season was a disaster from the very beginning. Things fell so south, so quickly that by May, the year had gone to complete waste.
But let’s view this from a different context. Did the Pirates fall short? Or did they once again meet an organizational standard that they seemingly can’t elevate?
Had Nutting been in attendance — and, for the first time in years, took time to collectively speak with the media that cover his team — one question this writer would’ve loved to ask was this: What does he believe the Pirates do well as an organization?
It’s a rather simple ask, but it might not be an easy answer.
The Pirates don’t win — their overall record as a franchise sunk below .500 this year.
They don’t attract large crowds — attendance dropped 11.4% this season.
They don’t necessarily bring out the best in the city — all three sellouts at PNC Park this year resulted in “sell the team” chants by the seventh inning.
So where exactly did they fall short?
Most national experts projected the Pirates to finish in last place at the start of the season. It was easy to understand why. The team had obvious flaws throughout 2024, ones that led to a dreadful second-half collapse that began immediately after they added a few players at the trade deadline.
There was a clear need for change, but nothing happened. They started 2025 with the same team president, the same general manager, the same manager and a very similar roster. The only thing that was different was the end-of-season record — which was worse (91 losses in 2025, 86 in 2024).
The Pirates might have wanted to win. But when nothing of substance was done to change the process, it’s wrong to call this year a failure. The 2025 Pirates achieved exactly what they were built to do.
‘Unacceptable’
Perhaps Nutting is unfamiliar with the definition of the word listed above. A quick google search tells me that “unacceptable” means “not good enough to be allowed or approved of,” or “something so bad it is intolerable, often because it goes against standards, rules, or expectations.”
If this is the case, then why has nothing changed? The Pirates are quick to highlight the good Kelly will bring as the team’s manager. They have continually raved about his strong connection with the players, his burning passion for the city and his devoted drive to help this team win.
“Donnie is the first of many steps we will take this offseason to bring winning baseball back to Pittsburgh,” Nutting concluded in his team-issued statement.
But, again, haven’t we already seen what this looks like?
Kelly was extended, not hired. He managed this year’s team for 124 games, in which they boasted a .475 winning percentage. That’s indeed an improvement compared to 2023 and 2024, when they finished with a .469 winning percentage. But it’s still not good enough.
Make no mistake, this is not a slight against Kelly. Having covered him all season, it’s easy to see why the Pirates believed he was the right man for the job. Kelly makes this team better as its manager. But his management will not be enough. Other changes were needed, and those changes didn’t happen.
Cherington, whose Pirates teams have gone a combined 365-505 since he was hired before the 2020 season, is back. As is Williams, who as team president should be held responsible for this year’s many off-field gaffes.
So if the only major change, at least for now, is simply retaining the manager who already ran the team for most of the season, was this year truly unacceptable? And if other, true changes in leadership aren’t included in the first step after an “unacceptable” season, then how serious will the next steps actually be?
‘Sufficient resources’
While Nutting didn’t speak Monday, Cherington and Williams were kind enough to answer questions. The former regularly speaks with reporters, and while his answers aren’t often remarkable, one can normally at least grasp a sense of direction when he is laying out a plan.
The same can’t be said for the rhetoric Williams delivered Monday afternoon. He entered the availability with some talking points and recited them — again and again — without adding much of anything else.
The area where Williams was questioned most extensively pertained to resources. Player payroll has been the unrivaled top area of contention since Nutting has owned the team. Many believe the only way this mess can be fixed, especially with the same individuals running the show, will be through an additional investment.
So will payroll be higher in 2026?
"We're not going to speak to payroll,” Williams said. “We never have in the past. But we have the resources sufficient to be able to win, to make the playoffs in 2026."
While Williams was wrong — he actually has discussed payroll in the past, with this very outlet as a matter of fact — we can overlook the first part of that statement because the second half is far more of a jaw-dropper.
“We have the resources sufficient to be able to win.”
According to whom, exactly? Since when? And if so, where have they been?
Year after year, the Pirates continually rank among the bottom 5-10 teams in major league payroll. Their last multi-year free agent signing occurred before America’s first diagnosed case of COVID-19. The franchise’s last division title came in 1992, well before most of the active roster was even alive.
So how exactly would this organization know what “resources sufficient to be able to win” looks like? Because they haven’t been on display on the North Shore — something that the players themselves noted this season.
There is only one real way this can all change.
Similar to what was written at the start of this disaster of a season, the Pirates have to prove everyone wrong. No one expects them to make a splash in the offseason. No one believes they will make the right trade, acquire the right free agents or fork over the cash necessary to ensure the few established talents that the organization does have won’t leave whenever their current deal expires.
The entire city, the entire fanbase, the entire baseball world is tired of hearing how the Pirates plan to improve. Talk is cheap, which is fitting for this notoriously frugal organization.
Words are the only thing this leadership group consistently delivers — except for Nutting, unless he can do so via a team-issued statement.
Enough of the same rhetoric. It’s time for action.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.