CINCINNATI — Paul Skenes needed just 3 ⅓ scoreless innings to finish his season with a sub-2.00 ERA and presumably lock up the Cy Young Award. He did that easily.

Then he threw a fourth. And a fifth. And a sixth.

On a day Skenes could have focused on personal accolades, he reached two milestones and went further, throwing six scoreless innings in a game the Pirates were playing for pride. The Reds staged a ninth-inning comeback against Dennis Santana that cost Skenes a win, but Spencer Horwitz’s game-winning double in the 11th inning led the Pirates to a 4-3 win against the Reds on Wednesday night at Great American Ball Park.

“What a game,” manager Don Kelly said. “Starting with Paul and the way that he went out. What a start today and what a season he's had. He just did what Paul does.”

Advertise with us

The performance was Skenes’ season finale. He’ll end 2025 with a 1.97 ERA, the lowest by a Pirates starter with at least 140 innings pitched since 1916.

The Pirates have now won four in a row, the last two in front of raucous crowds in Cincinnati. The Reds entered the series with a five-game winning streak and in control of the final wild-card berth, but now sit one game behind the Mets with four games to go. The Diamondbacks were ahead of the Reds by a half-game going into Wednesday night’s game in the wild-card race.

The Pirates have relished playing spoiler, but they’re hoping to play a different role in 2026.

“The atmosphere was just electric,” Skenes said. “I wasn't out there most of the game after I came in, but just watching, it was unbelievable. Hopefully we have that in Pittsburgh next year."

Skenes was impressive. He retired the first six batters, three by strikeout, to set the Pirates’ single-record for strikeouts by a right-hander with 211.(Mitch Keller had 210 in 2023). He went on to strike out seven in total, finishing his season and extending the record to 216. After four innings, he could have left the ballgame with both that record and his sub-two ERA, but he stayed in to finish his season strong.

Advertise with us

“He doesn't back down from anything,” Kelly said. “... He doesn't look at personal stuff like that. He was going out to win a baseball game and that just speaks to who he is and the game he had today and the season was just unbelievable.”

Skenes said his focus was “just winning.”

“Really, the biggest thing, I wanted to savor [this start] knowing this was my last outing of the year,” Skenes said. “I won't be doing that again for six months or so. It's kind of a tough realization. The past few days have been pretty tough for me, knowing that. Nice to have it over with. Wish I could keep pitching, just for the joy of pitching. The sub-two [ERA] is a nice little by product of it, I guess."

The Reds’ only real threat against him came in the fifth inning, when catcher Tyler Stephenson smashed a double off the top of the center field wall. Stephenson’s knock would have been a homer in six major league ballparks. Skenes left him stranded with two strikeouts.

In all, Skenes allowed just four hits and didn’t walk a batter. He left with a no-decision and finishes with a 10-10 record. It was a fitting conclusion to a stellar season, one that will likely end with Skenes’ first Cy Young Award.

Advertise with us

Skenes didn’t thump his chest and make his own case for the award, but his teammates did.

“He better be,” catcher Henry Davis said. “... He’s the best pitcher in baseball, and it’s not close.”

“He’s the best in the world,” Horwitz said, before going further. “And if he keeps doing this every year, I think he could have a chance to be one of the best to ever do it.”

It was over when...

Right-hander Yohan Ramirez managed a scoreless 11th for the win, but made it interesting. After walking the bases loaded, with two outs and a 3-1 count, he got right fielder Noelvi Marte to ground into a fielder’s choice to third. As Jared Triolo touched third for the forceout, more than 30,000 Reds fans left unhappy.

“That's what you play for,” Kelly said, “and that [playoff atmosphere is] what we're working towards, getting that back at PNC [Park].”

Advertise with us

On the mound

The Pirates turned to their leverage arms after Skenes left, assigning Justin Lawrence, Isaac Mattson and Santana with the task of finishing the game and protecting a 2-0 lead.

The Reds halved their deficit against Mattson in the eighth on an inside-the-park home run from Marte. Marte hit a ball to deep center field and Oneil Cruz, attempting to make a leaping catch, crashed hard into the wall. Cruz went down in pain, allowing Marte to run around the bases before Tommy Pham could retrieve the ball from left.

Cruz was originally able to stay in the game, but was removed for the bottom of the ninth with what the Pirates called left ankle discomfort. Jack Suwinski took his place in center.

Santana was able to get out of a two-on, two-out jam in the eighth, but couldn’t get out of the ninth scoreless. Stephenson’s homer came on a slider Santana hung over the heart of the plate.

Dauri Moreta allowed an unearned run in the 10th on two singles and a sacrifice fly from designated hitter Gavin Lux. With two on and two outs, Ramirez struck out pinch-hitter Miguel Andujar.

Advertise with us

At the plate

Besides Horwitz and Bryan Reynolds, the Pirates managed little offense until extras against Reds ace Hunter Greene and a flurry of relievers.

Reynolds scored both Pirates runs in the first nine innings, going 1 for 3 with a walk and a double, while Horwitz scored him twice and finished 3 for 5 with a single and a two doubles. Both runs were charged to Greene. The duo combined for the winning run in the 11th, when Reynolds, as the automatic runner on second, scored on Horwitz’s double down the right field line.

“We haven't played in an atmosphere like this in a while,” Horwitz said. “It brings a little more inside of you, and you can see it on their players. ... It just brings out the best in competitiveness, and I think that's what showed today.”

Suwinski had an RBI double off Reds reliever Tony Santillan in the 10th, scoring automatic runner Nick Yorke.

Most valuable player

Skenes. The right-hander has started his major league career with consecutive sub-two ERA seasons, although he only threw 133 innings in 2024. In 2025, he’ll finish with 187 ⅔ innings.

Advertise with us

Up next

The Pirates and Reds will conclude their three-game series at 12:40 p.m. Thursday. Braxton Ashcraft (4-3, 2.62) will face Reds lefty Nick Lodolo (8-8, 3.44). The game will be televised nationally on MLB Network and locally on SportsNet Pittsburgh. It can be heard on the radio on 100.1 FM and KDKA 1020 AM.