You are likely not alone if you felt conflicted watching the Pirates and Paul Skenes on Wednesday night in Cincinnati.
On one hand, it must have made you proud as a Pirates fan to see the incomparable Skenes finish off the greatest pitching season in franchise history — or at least since Babe Adams in the dead-ball era — in grand style.
Skenes wiped out the Reds over six shutout innings and finished the season with a ridiculous 1.97 earned-run average. He is a lock to win the National League Cy Young Award. He is arguably off to the best 55-game start in baseball history.
On the other hand, even though the Pirates won, it must have been infuriating to watch them blow a 2-0 lead, cost Skenes the win and leave him with a 10-10 record. Not because of the record itself, but because of what it represents. Namely, that the Pirates have positively mangled two seasons of a generational pitcher.
This post from “OptaSTATS” says it all: “Since ERA became an official stat in both leagues in 1913, Paul Skenes is the only MLB pitcher to finish a season with 200+ strikeouts and a sub-2.00 ERA and yet not have a winning record.”
That is an unbelievable indictment of Pirates general manager Ben Cherington and more so the man who hired him. You only get so many chances with a pitcher like this. The Pirates are 0-for-2-and-counting.
Read More
Again, it’s not the 10-10 record. It’s the two years of gross organizational ineptitude that the record represents. Cherington should not get a third strike. Bob Nutting should fire him five minutes after the season finale Sunday in Atlanta.
Skenes in September had one bad start but also three in which he pitched 17 innings with 23 strikeouts, one walk and zero runs allowed. His record in those games was 1-0. That should either make you laugh or cry.
Raise your hand if you want to see a seventh season of Cherington. Somebody else should get a chance to turn Nutting’s pennies into gold. Other markets win on shoestring budgets. The Pirates could, too, but they need a wheeler and dealer to find them some bats.
For what it’s worth, the Pirates did win a scintillating contest Wednesday in 11 innings. I just wonder if that also left people feeling conflicted.
On one hand, what a great game. What a fun watch. And the Pirates have severely damaged the Reds’ playoff hopes over the first two games of the series.
On the other hand, what did it matter? The Pirates have lost 89 games. They have regressed in Year 6 of a rebuild. Their lineup remains an all-time punch line. They are nothing but spoilers.
More to the point, this game provided a painful reminder of what high-stakes baseball looks like and feels like and how the Pirates might not be an actual participant anytime soon if Cherington stays on the job.
Plus, the sight of Skenes pacing around the dugout like “a bull in a cage” before each inning, as broadcaster Greg Brown described it, only underscored how amazing it would be to watch him pitch a game that actually mattered for the Pirates and begged the question: Will he, before he is inevitably traded?
This game only really mattered to the Reds, who made the smart move to hire Terry Francona as manager before the season and still have a chance to make the playoffs.
We’ll see soon enough if Nutting capitulates yet again this offseason. We’ll see if he keeps Cherington and closes the wallet. Maybe he could copy the Baldwin High School athletic director and ask opponents to take it easy on the Pirates next season.
Maybe that way, Skenes could finish 11-10.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.