Welcome to the Pirates mailbag, where Post-Gazette reporter Noah Hiles answers all of your questions about the ball club. If you have a question, find him on X at @_NoahHiles or email him at nhiles@post-gazette.com. Noah will answer your questions in full length each Thursday. Below are this week’s top questions:
Dana: What young prospect could realistically be offered a longer contract and actually accept it?
Hiles: Bubba Chandler would be the candidate who makes the most sense. I haven’t heard anything on that front, but this offseason would be the time for the Pirates to act. Paul Skenes is too close to arbitration and is simply too far out of their price range. Konnor Griffin is still only in Double-A, although they should also start to explore the idea of extending him early.
Chandler is in that sweet spot, where he’s a major leaguer, but will still be a rookie all of next year. I can’t speak on the likelihood of an extension for him or anyone else at this point. Big money helps in most cases, but as I’ve said before, the players need to see the front office make a bigger commitment to winning.
Extensions are nice, but external help is desperately needed. Until that help arrives, inking those extensions will probably be harder.
1986-1992 Pirates: How much impact did the dismissal of game planning and strategy coach Radley Haddad have on the club’s better play since Kelly became manager? How much influence did Haddad actually have?
Read More
Hiles: It’s hard to quantify. From the conversations I’ve had, the biggest difference seems to be with the starting rotation. They’re now allowing guys to pitch to their strengths, rather than attacking the opponent’s weaknesses, if that makes sense. Perhaps that’s why we’re seeing so many guys use their changeups more often. I can’t say I’ve heard many changes on the hitting side.
John: Do you think the Pirates will start 2026 with a bulk reliever concept, given that Ashcraft, Jones, Oviedo, Barco, and others will still have innings limitations?
Hiles: I think that could be a legitimate option, although it would depend on health. If some of those guys start the season on the injured list, the others will likely have to begin the season as true starters and then probably be moved into the bullpen later on to control their workload.
I could also see a few of them being slowly built up in spring training and the minor leagues to start the year. Barco would likely be the most likely candidate for that.
Dan: Do you believe a combo of Triolo and Peguero could hold down an infield spot until Griffin gets called up midseason 2026? Thus allowing for the GM to get two power bats for the outfield.
Hiles: I wouldn’t say it’s a combo. If anyone on this roster is going to have an opening day starting spot on the left side of the infield, it will be Triolo. He’s probably the most ideal placeholder you can draw up, especially if he can just be a league-average hitter. I’m still not huge on that idea. I’d rather Triolo be used as a rotating utility man, the first guy off the bench.
I think he’s a fine player, but one good month at the plate shouldn’t win him a starting job for next season. Peguero, meanwhile, hasn’t shown me enough to think he deserves an opening day roster spot. If he plays well next spring, I’m fine with him making the big-league club. But he still has a lot to prove.
Chris: Why do you think Ben Cherington seems to prefer multiple low-cost bets over one or two higher-cost options in free agency? Is it to fill out the roster or hope one of the low-cost options will boom and have a better ROI than a higher-priced free agent?
Hiles: Obviously, part of this factors into how much money Ben has at his disposal. You can’t make “big bets” if you don’t have the chips to do so. However, I get the overall point. Why not sign two, $15 million deals, rather than six 1-year, $5 million deals? I think historically, Ben has always prioritized internal talent.
Even in Boston, he was known to focus more on building a championship team through the draft and international markets, rather than free agency. Ironically, his 2013 championship team, something I recently wrote about, was anchored by a series of “small bet” agent signings that all hit at the same time. It seems like he’s stayed true to that philosophy.
He’d rather spread his chips out on the roulette table than make one big bet on a specific number.
Thanks for reading the Pirates mailbag! If you haven’t already done so, subscribe to our new Pirates YouTube channel here.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.