Welcome to the Pirates mailbag, where Post-Gazette reporter Noah Hiles answers all your questions about the ball club. If you have a question, find him on X at @_NoahHiles or email him at nhiles@post-gazette.com. Noah will answer your questions in full length each Thursday. Below are this week’s top questions:

Andy: Why is Bubba Chandler being used in a bulk role? Why not let him start games?

Hiles: I think it’s important to view Chandler’s body of work in 2025. The first half of his season was really, really good. In his first 11 starts of the year, he went 2-1 with a 2.03 ERA over 48 ⅔ innings. Opposing hitters posted a .541 OPS against him. But his production dramatically flipped at the start of June. He is 3-5 with a 5.96 ERA in his last 13 starts (51 ⅓ innings). He reached the fifth inning in just four of those 13 outings.

Opposing teams also posted an .871 OPS against him over that stretch. So, he has been notably worse as of late. Arguably, the worst he’s ever been since switching to pitching full-time in 2022. I think the bullpen, for now, makes sense. Some argue his slump was due to the Pirates keeping him in the minor leagues for too long, and he got it into his own head.

Advertise with us

If that’s the case, then he now has a chance to prove so in the majors. They’re going to use him in a role similar to what Braxton Ashcraft occupied earlier in the year. I think he will still start some games, but he has to show he’s capable of covering at least four innings in the majors first. I have no issue with the strategy.

The timing, however, is the bigger story in my eyes. If this was the plan they fell on, why couldn’t it have been thrown into motion earlier? They could’ve used Bubba’s arm in the bullpen to cover multiple innings earlier this month. And he could’ve used the additional big-league reps.

George: How much of Andrew Heaney’s move to the bullpen was due to his innings bonus?

Hiles: As I said on our YouTube channel, I don’t think this is similar to what happened last year with Rowdy Tellez. First off, Heaney is still on the team. They would've designated him for assignment if they didn’t want him to get any bonus money.

Second, they made this move with a month and a half of the season remaining. Rowdy’s situation unfolded in the final week of the regular season. Third, unlike Tellez, who ended the season with a 120 wRC+ from June on, Heaney just isn’t performing.

Advertise with us

He failed to reach the fifth inning in five of his last six starts. He even said himself that he didn’t deserve a spot in the rotation. He’s more valuable for the Pirates in this new role. He can cover multiple innings in blowouts, preventing younger pitchers from having to inherit unfavorable situations. He can also continue to mentor their younger pitchers in the system.

I understand some have highlighted that Mitch Keller is also struggling. Keller, however, still has three years of remaining team control after this year. Getting him back on track is in the club’s best interest. He’s also just a better overall pitcher than Heaney.

Even after this poor stretch, his numbers are far more favorable. Heaney is still likely going to pitch over 130 innings this year. And if he doesn’t reach that mark, it’s more his own doing than the Pirates. And at the end of the day, if he hadn’t regressed, they would’ve traded him to a contender, where the innings milestones would’ve been reached with ease.

James: Had Matt Arnold been hired instead of Ben Cherington, do you sincerely believe the Pirates would be substantially better? Who's to say Nutting wouldn't have interfered with his trades like he did with Cherington's trade of Bednar last season?

Hiles: I think it’s really easy to argue things would’ve been better under Arnold, but there were some things that would’ve also been challenging for him, along with any other general manager. The timing of this rebuild was incredibly unfavorable. Starting a new regime during a pandemic would’ve likely been a setback for any organization.

Advertise with us

I’m not saying it’s the lone reason things haven’t worked out under this regime, but it’s absolutely fair to note that they started under very challenging circumstances. The biggest difference one could make for Arnold’s case involves trade returns. Cherington has consistently failed to get equal value in his big deals.

Perhaps Arnold could’ve landed better talent for Josh Bell, Jameson Taillon, Starling Marte, Joe Musgrove, etc. That would’ve been the big difference maker in his fantasy scenario.

Devin: If Cutch re-signs for the 2026 season, is there any chance we see him get some work at first base?

Hiles: Ah, I see it’s time for this conversation again. I personally don’t see that happening. I haven’t heard much, which leads me to believe McCutchen or the Pirates would be interested in him getting reps at first base next season.

I guess an argument could be made for it. He could platoon well with Horwitz and start there against left-handers. But I don’t know. That, to me, doesn’t seem like much of a change. If he’s back, I think it’s probably again as a designated hitter.

Advertise with us

Matthew: It seems to be smart business to try to sign minor league superstars to long-term deals as they first reach the majors (Red Sox with Roman Anthony), or even before (Brewers with Jackson Chourio). Should the Pirates approach Konnor Griffin with such a deal? When would be the right time, and what might he actually consider?

Hiles: I think it would be a really smart idea. But I don’t think it will be easy. First things first, you have to wait until Griffin at least has some success in Triple-A before truly exploring the idea. His development is far from complete. After that, you have to look at the team’s situation. I truly think the Pirates need to show their players they’re committed to winning.

We’ve seen multiple players voice their desire to see more activity this offseason. They want to see the front office acquire a few established hitters. That’s the first step. After that, they need to start playing winning baseball.

After that, you can explore numbers. No one is signing up for extra time in the current situation. They want to know that if they ink a long-term extension, they’re not the only ones who will get paid over that time. That money will be nice, but it has to come with the assurance that it won’t be used as a reason not to keep adding payroll as the years go on.

Once that’s established, I think they might have a chance at Griffin. The deal would likely need to be higher than Roman Anthony’s, as Griffin is already a more valuable asset. However, I don’t think that price tag is out of the question. The harder part is giving Griffin a reason to commit extra years of his career to this franchise.

Advertise with us

And that reason has to be more than a nice payday, as he can just wait a few years to land that somewhere else.

Thanks for reading the Pirates mailbag! If you haven’t already, subscribe to our new Pirates YouTube channel here