The Pirates are trying to show frustrated fans that they can do right by them.
Months after the team removed and demolished approximately 10,000 “Bucco Bricks” outside PNC Park, the team said it will replace them with a permanent fixture — bronze plaques mounted to the stadium’s exterior walls, bearing the same names and wording as the bricks.
“We understand how important these messages and the memories associated with them are to our fans, and we believe we have developed a display for these messages that will stand the test of time,” Pirates President Travis Williams said during a presentation to the the city’s Sports & Exhibition Authority board, which unanimously approved the project Thursday morning.
The Pirates are footing the bill for the project, and there is no public investment whatsoever, Mr. Williams said. The plaques will be “much more expensive” than the original bricks, but he did not disclose the cost.
The brick pavers were part of a program introduced in 1999 during the construction of PNC Park that allowed fans to purchase personalized bricks — many of which became memorials to loved ones.
They were displayed in front of the ballpark’s home-plate and left-field entrances, and proceeds from the bricks’ sales went to the Roberto Clemente Foundation.
Read More
The team removed the bricks during a sidewalk replacement project earlier this year, sparking fan outrage. An SEA investigation found that the team had bypassed plans to preserve the bricks and instead dumped them at a recycling center, causing even more anger as the team struggled on the field and faced several PR nightmares at the start of the season.
The first misstep came before the first pitch was even thrown.
The Pirates — riding an atypical wave of fan optimism with the historic debut of Paul Skenes at the end of the 2024 season — sat mostly idle in the offseason, failing to sign significant offensive additions even though scoring was a weakness last year. Fan frustration mounted — to the point where a movement coalesced to try to pressure owner Bob Nutting to sell the team.
The Pirates then started the season with a disappointing road trip in Florida, winning just two of seven games. When they returned to PNC Park for the first time this year, the traditionally festive atmosphere of the home opener was overshadowed by a plane flying over the North Shore with a sign urging Mr. Nutting to sell the team, and several fan chants of “sell the team” during a lopsided 9-4 loss.
As the losses mounted, the team decided to replace a tribute logo for Roberto Clemente with an advertisement — prompting Roberto Clemente Jr. to post on X: “WOW…………..”
Then came the uproar over the missing Bucco Bricks — which had been replaced by slabs of gray concrete.
Team leaders, including Mr. Nutting and Mr. Williams, took full responsibility for the bricks’ removal, with the owner sending personal emails of apology to fans. They acknowledged their mistake and promised to fix it.
On Thursday, they made good on that promise.
Mr. Williams explained at Thursday’s SEA meeting that the team had “significant issues” with the old bricks, which had been worn down over the years by the weather and wear and tear from foot traffic, creating “unsafe conditions for the fans.”
He noted that the bricks had been replaced at least three times — in some instances four times — since they were installed more than 25 years ago.
The Pirates designed the new installation with Major League Baseball architect and urban planner Janet Marie Smith to resemble the layout of the original bricks, with the larger square messages and smaller rectangular ones maintaining their proportions and font size.
The plaques, 60 in all, will be approximately 5 feet high by 6 feet wide, and each will include around 170 messages, organized by year. The team will also launch an app to help fans locate their bricks.
North Shore-based memorialization company Matthews International will make the plaques, and another local company, Mascaro Construction, will handle the installation.
The Pirates plan to install the plaques between next January and March and expect to have them ready by opening day of the 2026 season.
In addition to the plaques, the Pirates are offering to send replica Bucco Bricks to any fans who previously owned one, free of charge. So far, the team has produced around 3,000 replica bricks in response to fan requests, Mr. Williams said.
The Pirates have not set an end date for the replica brick program.
“We went out to everybody that we had contact information for, going back to the early 2000s,” Mr. Williams said. “If people want to come back and ask for one, we still have continued to honor them and work with them.”
Meanwhile, fans are clamoring for the Pirates to address their ongoing issues on the field.
As of Thursday, the team remained buried in last place in the National League Central Division with 38 wins and 56 losses — tied for the third-worst record in Major League Baseball.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.