Anyone who has ever been in a relationship is familiar with the honeymoon phase. Early on, nothing ever seems to go wrong. Things are so fresh, so exciting — but eventually, reality starts to set in. That looks to be the case for Pirates manager Don Kelly.

The first month of “Donnie Ball” consisted of far more highs than lows. The team went 14-14 in the first 30 days with him in charge, a steep improvement from what had occurred this year under his predecessor, Derek Shelton.

The Pirates were — trigger warning — “winning on the margins,” by successfully supplementing their pitching staff with quality defense, aggressive base running and, at least more often than earlier in the year, timely hitting.

“There's been some changes, obviously, and he's been out front on that communication, and putting people first, as you'd expect him to do,” Pirates general manager Ben Cherington said of Kelly on May 22, just two weeks into him being the club’s manager. “I’ve been very encouraged with how he's handled the job so far.”

Advertise with us

Things were by no means fixed, but at least seemed to be on the up and up. The city began to support its homegrown skipper, and the team looked to be responding well to its new voice. There was an undeniable spark between Kelly and the organization. But after a few rough road trips, the honeymoon phase is officially over.

In the past two weeks, Kelly has received the true Pirates manager experience.

There have been controversies, such as Dennis Santana’s altercation with a fan in Detroit, or Oneil Cruz getting benched due to “energy or effort” in Milwaukee. There have been strategic challenges, such as the team’s decision to once again take a stronger stance on monitoring Paul Skenes’ workload. The club’s play has been a bit sloppier, especially in the field and on the bases. And of course, the offense remains a gigantic issue.

Similar to what couples experience when they first move in together, Kelly and the Pirates are now getting their first real taste of what this partnership could be like moving forward.

“I’m hanging in there,” Kelly said during a 1-on-1 with the Post-Gazette following Wednesday’s loss in Milwaukee. “I would defer to others on how things have been going, but I’m trying to be as consistent as I can be with the guys, with the team, and show them that I have their backs.”

Advertise with us

Although Kelly has plenty of familiarity with Pirates related drama, having served as Shelton’s bench coach in each of the past five seasons, he’s now the man in charge.

Rather than offering his two cents when called upon, he is making the final decisions. Kelly is no longer the friendly, down to earth assistant coach who can provide a different perspective. When anyone on the team messes up, both on or off the field, it’s now his job to not only answer for it, but ensure it doesn’t happen again.

“There are times it’s going to be tough,” Kelly said. “There are always going to be borderline calls, or things that go for or against us. But it’s how we continue to have each other’s backs, to fight, and grind and win.”

So far, Kelly has lived by those words. He’s had no issue standing up for his players, from getting ejected three times in his first 20 games — a stat he’s far from proud of — to the way he handled the aftermath of Santana’s incident. He’s also had no problem holding his team accountable, something that was perhaps missing throughout the last manager’s tenure.

“With Oneil, I told him, ‘I love my kids, but sometimes I have to discipline my kids,’” Kelly said. “That’s because I care about them, and it’s the same thing with all the players. If I didn’t [do anything], that shows that I don’t care about them.”

Advertise with us

Kelly cares, but has also had help. As Cruz noted the evening he was benched, veteran teammates such as Andrew McCutchen and Tommy Pham both spoke to him as well. But due to the timing of the season and the Pirates’ place in the standings, some of those leaders won’t be around much longer.

By the end of July, there is a strong chance that most of the veteran voices within the Pirates’ clubhouse will be in a different uniform.

Players such as Pham, Adam Frazier, Isiah Kiner-Falefa, Andrew Heaney and Caleb Ferguson, who have all provided guidance for their inexperienced teammates, will almost certainly be traded before the deadline. They might not be the only ones either, as sources have indicated that other known voices on the team such as David Bednar and Mitch Keller could also be on the move.

Come August 1, the Pirates’ roster as a whole will likely be much younger than it was when Kelly first took over. And while some of those leaders will be missed, Kelly’s hope is that those who are still around can continue to build upon the culture he’s worked to establish during his brief time as the head man.

“Everything that’s happened, it’s all been part of what I feel we need to do every day to continue to get better, in order to win.” Kelly said. “The veterans that were here set that example, but now it’s up to Oneil to learn from that, Bryan [Reynolds] to learn from that, for all of the guys that are going to be here to learn from that example.

Advertise with us

“We have to build off that and carry it on regardless of who’s in the clubhouse.”

So far, Kelly has said and done the right things. But similar to a relationship, you truly don't know what you have until you’ve been tested, until things haven’t gone according to plan.

For Kelly, those tests are just beginning. Plenty of discomfort awaits. The Pirates entered the weekend having lost each of their past four series’ and have a multitude of key players in the midst of ugly slumps.

It falls on Kelly to find a way to turn things around, as he did when he first took over. Preventing the team from reverting back to what it was before his promotion is paramount, and will ultimately determine if he will remain the manager heading into 2026.

We will see in the next few months, if Kelly and the Pirates are meant to be.

Advertise with us

Three up

  • Home tahn advantage: Entering the weekend, the Pirates were 13-9 at PNC Park since Kelly took over as manager.
  • All good, Pham: Tommy Pham entered the weekend series against the Mets having tallied a multi-hit effort in each of his last three games.
  • Dang, Dennis: Dennis Santana entered the weekend with a 1.57 ERA on the season, seventh lowest among MLB qualified relievers.

Three down

  • Catch up: Pirates catchers Joey Bart and Henry Davis entered the weekend a combined 0-for-16, each having gone hitless in their last eight at-bats.
  • Oh no, Oneil: Oneil Cruz has been struggling as of late, entering the weekend with just a .148 batting average in the month of June.
  • Skenes stunned: Paul Skenes’ four earned runs allowed in the top of the second inning against the Brewers were the most he has allowed in one inning as a major-leaguer.

On deck

  • Red bird hunting: The Pirates next opponent, the St. Louis Cardinals, entered the weekend just a game out of the National League’s third and final wildcard spot.
  • Clean play Cards: The Cardinals entered the weekend with a .989 fielding percentage on the season, tied with the Braves, Phillies and Mariners for second best in MLB.
  • One of a kind: After facing the Cardinals, the Pirates will head west to Seattle for a three game showdown against the Mariners. The Mariners are led by star catcher Cal Raleigh, who entered the weekend with an MLB leading 32 home runs on the season.

Bottom of the ninth

Some eyebrows were likely raised Wednesday afternoon when Pirates announcer Greg Brown reported that Skenes was likely going to have a light workload in his start against the Brewers. From the moment the Pirates selected Skenes first overall in the 2023 draft, his work volume has always been a hot button topic. The Pirates, of course, want to get the most out of their star pitcher, but also have to ensure he’s not overused to the point where it leads to injury. In this year’s case, conserving Skenes’ innings count every now and then makes sense. This year’s season is over. Allowing Skenes to log north of 220 innings would be irresponsible, as they will not help the team get back into contention. This isn’t to say the Pirates’ star should be shut down, but a few bullpen games to get him an extra day of rest, or perhaps an early hook or two from here on out is a very reasonable plan. The goal should be to get Skenes around the 200 inning mark at the end of the year. That number an appropriate build up from last year’s workload (160 ⅓ innings total between Triple-A and the major leagues), which will safely allow him to progress to an even higher number (220-230) next season. The 200 inning mark will also likely sill keep him in contention for the Cy Young, which Skenes still deserves a shot at.

Numerology

1 — The Pirates sweep of the Phillies earlier this month remains their only sweep of the season. On the flip side, Kelly’s club has been swept five times.