Wyatt Hendrie remembers the first time he saw Wilber Dotel’s new splitter.

“He threw one and I was like, ‘Oh, boy,’” the catcher at Double-A Altoona said. “If he can do that consistently, they're in trouble.”

Dotel has thrown that pitch consistently, and Double-A hitters have been in trouble. Through 12 starts in Altoona, the 22-year-old right-hander from the Dominican Republic has a 3.54 ERA and is third in the Eastern League with 74 strikeouts.

Dotel wasn’t on MLB Pipeline’s top-30 prospect list before the season, but he’s certainly close — Baseball America considers him the Pirates’ No. 27 prospect.

Advertise with us

And that was before Dotel found this splitter.

“I mean, he already throws 100,” Hendrie said. “And then you add a splitter that has the same plane and just falls off. It's hard to hit.”

It’s something Dotel started working on in spring training. He’d largely relied on a fastball and a slider since the Pirates signed him in October 2020, with a changeup as a third pitch. But that changeup wasn’t where it needed to be. Dotel eliminated it for the splitter, and it’s led to him striking out almost two more batters per nine innings (8.97 in Greensboro last season to 10.92 now) and going from 4.57 walks per nine innings to 2.95.

He’s at a higher level, going from High-A to Double-A, but he’s allowing fewer runs, striking out more batters, walking fewer and getting more guys out.

It’s something that’s surprised many, but not him.

Advertise with us

“Since spring training, I’ve been grinding,” Dotel said, with Curve infielder Kervin Pichardo translating. “I’ve been working on the new pitch. Everything's been going good so far. I’m not really surprised.”

He says it hasn’t surprised people inside the organization, either.

“People around the organization, they believed in me throughout all the years I’ve been with the organization,” Dotel said. “I feel like everybody in the organization has been waiting for these results.”

It’s not like Dotel had struggled since signing with the Pirates. He had had some success largely relying on his fastball and slider — his fastball sits mid-90s and can go as high as 100 mph, while the slider plays well off of it. He went 7-2 at Single-A Bradenton in 2023, then went 9-5 at High-A Greensboro in 2024 despite an ERA over 5. But his work, plus the splitter, has led to this season’s eye-opening success.

Altoona coach Andy Fox has seen Dotel develop not just season-to-season, but from start-to-start this year.

Advertise with us

“Very impressive," Fox said. “He's another younger guy. Him being able to go out there and toe it every five days and [do] everything it takes in between starts to do that. I think the fastball has been really, really good. Being able to maintain velocity and really understanding — these guys, they go through so much and they learn so much each inning, let alone each game.”

Dotel feels it, too. Especially with a new pitch, he sees that it’s getting more effective as he uses it. Given that it’s been successful so far, it can only get better, especially as Dotel continues to study the game.

“I’ve been feeling comfortable with the pitch,” Dotel said. “I’ve been working on the pitch before the games and all that stuff. It’s only been the first two months. I feel like I could make the pitch even better throughout the whole season.”

Another thing going for him is his dependability. Apart from a month-long IL stint in 2023, Dotel has been able to keep himself healthy. He hasn’t always thrown this hard, so his durability still needs to be proven, but he was able to make 25 starts spanning 106 1/3 innings last season.

Being an “innings eater,” as he puts it, is something he takes pride in.

Advertise with us

Of course, success in Altoona isn’t Dotel’s ultimate goal. Nor is a call up to Indianapolis, which certainly could happen later this season if he continues pitching as well as he has. The Pirates may have several arms ahead of him in the rankings, but Dotel has the same big-league goals.

“Just be consistent,” Dotel said. “I don't just want to pitch in Indiana. I want to play and pitch for the Pirates in the big leagues.”