DETROIT — While there is never truly a calm period throughout the baseball season, the months of June and July provide an extra long to-do list for those within a front office. For Pirates director of amateur scouting Justin Horowitz, this week specifically marked the beginning of a gauntlet that was to come.

Horowitz and a few other Pirates employees hit the road to Phoenix on Monday for this year’s MLB scouting combine. The event, which took place at Chase Field from Tuesday through Saturday, served as a showcase for 322 amateur players hoping to hear their name called in next month’s draft. For all 30 MLB teams, it also marks the beginning of the final stretch toward two of the most important days on the baseball calendar.

“We’re really ramping up now,” Horowitz told the Post-Gazette on Monday. “We’ve got a little less than 30 days to go until the draft. We’re in a good spot. Our group has done a great job, working really hard. We’re really excited. This is our Super Bowl, as you know, so we’re looking forward to it.”

This year’s MLB draft is scheduled to take place on July 13-14. The Pirates will select 21 players whom they believe can provide a positive impact on the organization’s future. Four of those picks are inside the top 85 spots, including their sixth overall position in the first round.

Advertise with us

This year marks the second straight year Horowitz will oversee the Pirates’ draft strategy. General manager Ben Cherington hired Horowitz in November 2023 after his scouting efforts helped the Red Sox build one of the game’s best farm systems. The hope was he could replicate those results in Pittsburgh, a franchise far more dependent on successful internal development because of its market size.

With less than a month until the Pirates are on the clock, Horowitz took some time to speak with the Post-Gazette. He gave a one-year review of his first draft in Pittsburgh, discussed the differences in MLB’s draft compared to other sports’ and provided some insight into what the Pirates’ strategy could look like when it comes time to make their picks. Below is a transcribed layout of that conversation:

Post-Gazette: Before we get into this year’s process, let’s review last year’s draft. I want you to give us a one-year review of your first draft as the Pirates director of amateur scouting. Is it safe to say you’re feeling pretty good about the early returns of your decision making?

Horowitz: We’re excited about the guys we were able to bring into the organization. Obviously, there is a long way to go and plenty of things can and will change over the next few years. But yeah, so far, so good. Credit to our scouting group, coaching and player development (CPD) and so many people that went into that process of identifying guys that we wanted to bring in and target throughout the draft. We were able to land a few of them. Obviously Konnor [Griffin] kicked us off. He has been exceptional in terms of performance but also everything we could’ve hoped for and more with the human being. He’s an exceptional kid, a leader and an incredibly hard worker, a good human being that we’re really excited to have. Moving on down from there, we were able to land a number of pieces that we’re very excited about. Many of them are off to good starts to their professional careers. Honestly, a few of them, too, we traded over the past year for major league value, which is a big deal. So so far, so good. Like I said, I appreciate all the hard work our group did last year identifying some of these guys, and we hope to see some continued improvements as they develop in their pro careers.

PG: You hit on a couple of points I’d like to circle back to. The first one is Konnor Griffin. Like you said, he’s off to a very strong start in his minor league career. He looks to have a bright future. It’s hard to believe eight teams passed over him last year. While, yes, there were other talented players and it’s easy to look back at it now and see he should’ve probably gone earlier, what led your group to take a gamble on the top high school prospect in a draft that was very college player-heavy?

Advertise with us

Horowitz: To your point, there were a number of talented players in the draft last year. Especially toward the top, there were a number of guys we were really excited about that got selected in front of us. When it came to our pick, we were ready. Darren Mazeroski, our area scout, had done an incredible job, well over a year’s worth of work and beyond, that put us in a position, gave us real confidence Konnor was obviously extremely talented but also had the makeup to be able to come in, grind, perform and be open-minded to a few changes we might be able to approach him with that may help him in a player-development environment.

So credit to [Mazeroski], credit to our scouting group for giving us the confidence to be able to pull the trigger on Konnor and credit to our CPD staff with the work and development with him. And, most importantly, credit to Konnor, who has come in, worked his butt off and done everything asked of him and more. It’s showing up on the field, which is always nice to see. We’re excited for his future, for sure.

PG: Did you think he’d be this good this early?

Horowitz: It’s hard to say how good he really is right now. Did I think he’d go out and perform? Yes, honestly, I did. I thought he’d go out and do well. To the level he’s doing it at? I don’t know. He just had one week in High-A. Obviously it was a great week. I don’t know. I knew I was confident Konnor would go out and hold his own because he had so much underlying talent.

He, throughout the course of his amateur career, made a lot of contact, hit the ball hard, was a freak athlete and worked really hard. I was very confident in all of those things. He had a little bit of an adjustment, a learning curve, and after that point — I think we’ve seen it over the last couple of months, really — he’s really hitting his stride, which is great for him.”

Advertise with us

PG: Konnor Griffin will more than likely be the player everyone remembers from this draft class, but as you noted, you were able to trade three players from last year’s class for major league talent. Matt McShane, your 13th-round pick, was traded for Chase Shugart. Joe Vogatsky, your 19th-round pick, was flipped for Enmanuel Valdez. And, of course, third-round pick Josh Hartle was included in the trade package that brought in Spencer Horwitz. Did you anticipate that happening when you were drafting so many college arms last season, or did that just sort of happen organically?

Horowitz: I would say it happened more organically than anything. Coming in last year, in my first year, I was so impressed with our scouting staff and how they evaluated all demographics but especially pitching. And then the infrastructure that we have, the people, the personnel throughout CPD that we have to support arms, that gave us a lot of confidence, [gave] me a lot of confidence, going into the draft last year.

We were able to land a few arms throughout the draft we were excited about. You never know if or when another team will ask about a player in your organization. It just so happened a few of our guys were targeted by other teams, which resulted in major league deals which helped supplement our major league squad. Philosophically, we’re always looking for the best player we can possibly get. Whatever happens beyond that is honestly out of our hands, to much of a degree. So we’re just trying to capture as much talent as we can, some of the hardest workers we can and hand them off to our CPD group to work their magic with them and see where the chips fall after that.

PG: Is that something you’d like to see happen again? Knowing how good this organization is when it comes to identifying and developing arm talent, could part of your strategy be to simply load up on good pitchers knowing a few are going to be used as trade chips?

Horowitz: Honestly, that’s a good question for [general manager] Ben [Cherington], [assistant GM] Kevan Graves and others, but yeah, I think philosophically, we’re always trying to bring in talent from top to bottom in the organization, but we’re looking to win in the big leagues, man. That goal doesn’t change. Yeah, we’ve had a tough year, but the goal is the goal. However we can do that, we’re looking to do that.

Advertise with us

If we have opportunities to capitalize on players that are proven major league talent, that also might be able to contribute this year or additional years down the road to the big-league team, I think those are opportunities we should always be listening to and open to. Honestly, it’s our duty as leaders of this organization.

PG: As you said, the goal is to win in the big leagues. Traditionally, baseball drafts are simple in the sense you’re supposed to select the best player available, regardless of position. However, the Pirates have a clear weakness at the major league level. The team is struggling to score runs consistently. Does this at all impact your draft strategy? Is there any thought toward drafting to address needs at the major league level? Or does that line of thinking, which is common in sports such as football, basketball and hockey, not necessarily apply to baseball because of the differences in a player’s development process?

Horowitz: We generally don’t, to be honest. From a long-term sustainability standpoint, trying to create success year after year over the long term, we believe we should always be drafting the best player available. That’s definitely the bottom line. Now, are there things that we look at, that we learn from about the major league game or the way things are changing, different trends or park factors or the baseball, anything like that? Those are things we do talk about. But identifying specific things that can really, really help our major league team tomorrow is a little bit short-sighted.

Also, just generally, the draft has been historically proven to be so challenging. The skill level to get to the big leagues is so much higher that most of these kids are still a ways away from reaching that level and/or turning into whatever players they’re going to be for hopefully their major league careers. So attacking specific weaknesses for the major league team through the draft isn’t something we’re entirely focused on, definitely more so in terms of bringing the best player at each pick into the organization as we possibly can.

PG: On the note of this year’s draft, it seems like this projected first-round class is heavily loaded with college pitchers. Would you agree with that analysis? And if so, do you think that puts the Pirates in an advantageous spot, considering pitcher development is the organization’s biggest strength?

Advertise with us

Horowitz: For the first part of the question, yes, I generally do agree with the industry consensus that there are a number of college arms that are considered high-level talents who fit in the first round or the top half of the draft this year, however you want to phrase it. That is true and that’s exciting. And so, for the Pirates specifically and what’s advantageous for us, the more good players in the draft, the better. No matter what demographic they come from, I’m always excited about talent and good kids who work hard, no matter what position they play. I’m super confident, obviously, in the pitching-development group here with the Pirates. The results, in many ways, speak for themselves. Credit to the scouting group for identifying arms that have talent and work hard, and credit to the CPD group who — well before I got here — has helped turn those guys into legitimate impact talent at the big leagues or potential prospects.

So does that give us confidence that whoever we bring in, if we bring in a pitcher toward the top of the draft that we’ll be able to help them accomplish their goals and develop through their impact? Yeah, we’re very confident in that and excited about that. But, honestly, the same goes for the position-player side. I think it’s showing a lot honestly in Konnor’s development over this first year and some of the small changes they’ve helped him make. So we’re getting really confident with some of the progress we’re making in the hitting space, too. So, overall, that is to say I know whoever we bring in, we’re really confident our CPD group is going to make a really positive impact on all of those players.

PG: Final question for you: This is draft No. 2 for you in Pittsburgh. What did you learn from your first draft that you will take with you into this year’s draft?

Horowitz: That’s a good question. Honestly, it’s one I should think about and reflect on more. So thank you for bringing that up because I need to and I will before we get there over the next few weeks so that I’m even more prepared.

Off the top of my head, I think one thing that may be worth mentioning — I don’t know if this is the No. 1 thing I’ve learned — but it is something I did learn and would be cool to shed light on is the draft is a grind. It is a mental and physical beast, especially for the individuals who are leading the event. There is so much work that goes into the preparatory process, years’ worth of work in advance leading up to it with the scouting group, but the event itself takes a ton of logistical coordination and prep work among a ton of different people both in and outside of baseball [operations]. The meetings are intense, man. There is a lot of really good dialogue, critical debate, exercises, different things we do to attack different questions we may have about different players.

Advertise with us

And then the event is intense, man. You’re making a lot of phone calls. You’re on the clock. It’s a very dynamic environment. Things change at a moment’s notice. Things happen that you don’t expect. Players get snaked in front of you you were really planning on selecting. You really have to be focused, flexible, adaptable and mentally tough. Credit to all of the people who have run drafts before me. I was clued into that, but until I had gone through the experience, I hadn’t really entirely understood what it meant. Honestly, now I appreciate someone like [vice president of scouting] Joe DelliCarri, who did this for 12 years, which is an incredible accomplishment because like I said, it’s a beast.

I really respect the people who put in the time and effort to do the best they can. That’s the bottom line here — it’s a beast. Everyone, all 30 of the scouting directors across the league, they’re all doing it. It’s a lot of information to take in. But everyone is doing the best they can to give their organization the best shot they can to win. I think if more people understood that about the draft, I think that would be really cool.