They say a first impression means everything. But in some cases, a strong introduction sets a high bar moving forward. That seems to have been the case for Pirates outfielder Jack Suwinski.
Acquired from the Padres in 2021 as a part of the Adam Frazier trade, Suwinski looked to be years away from reaching the game’s highest level. A 22-year-old former 15th-round pick, he was just starting to hit his stride in Double-A. Less than a year later, however, Suwinski was in the show.
His successful rookie campaign — which included 19 homers and a .709 OPS over 106 games — came out of nowhere. When it was followed by 26 homers and a .793 OPS in 2023, he quickly went from an unknown prospect to a future piece of the Pirates organization.
“Jack’s obviously become a huge threat against right-handed pitching,” general manager Ben Cherington said during that season. “He’s improved his defense to the point where we believe he not just can play center field, but is a good major league center fielder, a really valuable player.”
Being viewed as a key component of a franchise’s long-term future is an honor every big-leaguer welcomes. But with high praise comes high expectations. When those expectations aren’t met, a steep fall awaits. It is, of course, what has happened to Suwinski, who has now been optioned back to Triple-A three times in the past two seasons.
“It’s a tough game,” Suwinski told the Post-Gazette earlier this month in Indianapolis. “I have high expectations of myself, just like every other player here. Nobody wants to go out there and fail, but hitting is one of the hardest things to do in sports. Even when you do everything right, you might not be successful, in the terms of the game.
Read More
“Honestly, it keeps me humble in the best way possible, just as a person and the man I want to be. So there is definitely a silver lining to it. It’s not going to be all gloomy days when you’re not playing good baseball. We all have lives outside of this place. But while we’re in it, it is our livelihood. We want to be the best we can be at whatever we do.”
While silver linings are admirable, Suwinski understands baseball is a results-based game. Last season, the Pirates sent him to Indianapolis not once, but twice, with the hope that he could re-establish the approach that once allowed him to produce at an above-average rate in the major leagues.
Although nothing clicked in 2024, signs of progress looked to be surfacing this spring. Suwinski perhaps had the best preseason of any Pirates hitter, batting .375 with a 1.022 OPS over 14 Grapefruit League contests. His hot bat earned him a spot on the opening day roster. But inconsistent playing time throughout April led him back into a familiar hole.
“I felt good in spring,” Suwinski said. “I felt good to start the season. I know things change when the season starts in terms of who is going out there and who they think the best nine to win that day is going to be. You can only be ready for your name to be called, whether it’s starting or coming off the bench. The only thing harder than hitting is pinch hitting because the opportunities are shorter and they usually come in a bigger spot in the game. … I would have loved to carry over what I did this spring into the season, for a whole season, but you can’t force results in this game. When you do that, you press. And when you press, you’re not going to be yourself.”
For Suwinski, “being yourself” means maintaining the reserved and relaxed demeanor that fans can notice while watching from home. Many in his situation, big-leaguers who are back in the minor leagues for a second straight season, would easily lose themselves. But those around Suwinski note that he has continued to approach the game in the right way, despite being in the midst of perhaps the most challenging portion of his professional career.
“He’s been phenomenal down here,” former Indians manager Chris Truby said of Suwinski prior to his promotion to the major league coaching staff. “He’s another guy who was sent down because there are some things he has to get better at. But he’s gone to work. He’s had some bad luck here. He’s hammered some balls that have been caught. But he’s positive, he’s working and blended right in with the group.”
That bad luck, however, has seemingly calmed as of late. He entered Saturday’s contest slashing .240/.326/.480 (.806 OPS) with five home runs and 18 RBIs over 23 games in Triple-A. Suwinski believes he’s capable of better, not only in the minor leagues but in the majors. And his mission in 2025 is to earn another opportunity to make it happen.
“Obviously, as a competitor, I want more than what I’ve had,” Suwinski said. “I want the ones back that I haven’t done as good as I can in the box. But that just goes into the process of sticking to what you believe in and trusting your work. I know I can be better.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.