On Thursday, the Pirates relieved manager Derek Shelton of his duties. Shelton managed the Pirates for six seasons, starting with the pandemic-shortened season of 2020. He was the 46th manager in franchise history and 40th since the Pirates joined the National League in 1887.
Shelton’s Pirates’ tenure started with three difficult seasons, including consecutive 100-loss campaigns in 2021 and 2022, before showing some progress with a 76-86 season in 2023. That progress flatlined last season with an identical 76-86 season, including a 10-game August losing streak that knocked the Pirates from contention, but Shelton retained his job. He was fired just 38 games into the 2025 season with the Pirates 12-26, third-worst in the majors, and in the midst of a seven-game losing streak.
In his six seasons, Shelton’s teams went 306-440, good for a .410 winning percentage. Here’s a look at how his tenure compared to the other 47 Pirates managers, including six who managed the Pirates in the American Association (1882 to 1886) and nine more who were in charge for less than 60 games.
Historical ranks
Shelton managed 746 games, the 10th-most in Pirates history. He managed in parts of six seasons, more than all but six Pirates managers.
His 306 wins are the 12th most in Pirates history, just between Billy Meyer’s 317 from 1948 to 1952 and Gene Lamont’s 295 from 1997 to 2000. Meyer had a similar record, losing 452 games in five seasons before resigning at the end of the 1952 season, while Lamont lost 352 in four seasons before he was fired in September 2000.
Shelton’s 440 losses are the ninth-most in franchise history. Five of the eight above him made at least one playoff appearance: Fred Clarke, Danny Murtaugh, Jim Leyland, Clint Hurdle and Chuck Tanner.
Read More
Winning percentage
Of the nine managers to have 440 or more losses, Shelton has the worst winning percentage, narrowly edging Meyer’s .412 mark.
Shelton’s winning percentage is 32nd of the 41 Pirates managers since 1888. Of the nine with worse winning percentages, three managed five or fewer games, two lasted just one season, two managed just two seasons and the other two, John Russell (2008 to 2010) and Fred Haney (1953 to 1955) managed just three seasons.
Shelton’s record is the worst since Russell, who managed the lean years of a rebuild that culminated with three consecutive playoff appearances under Hurdle. Before Russell, the last time a Pirates manager to have a sub-.415 winning percentage was Bobby Bragan in 1956 and 1957.
The fired skipper finishes his all-time Pirates career 134 games below .500. Only Meyer (135 games) and Haney (136 games) finished further below even.
In baseball history, 216 managers have been in charge for 700 or more games. Of those 216, Shelton ranks 214th in all-time winning percentage, ahead of Jimmie Nelson (1934-1944) and Preston Gomez (1969-1980).
Offensive and defensive stats
His teams scored an average of 3.88 runs, which would have ranked 28th out of 30 last year. The Pirates are averaging 3.11 runs this year, worst in the big leagues.
His teams give up an average of 4.90 runs, which would have ranked 26th last year. The Pirates are allowing 4.59 runs this year, 22nd in the majors.
This year’s runs allowed mark is the second-best of Shelton’s tenure, but the offense has struggled. 3.11 runs scored per game is not just the worst in the majors but would be the worst by any Pirates team since the 1916 squad scored just 3.08 runs per game. By batting average, this year’s .219 mark is the second-worst in Pirates history and worst since 1884.
With the team struggling, the organization determined it was the right time to make a change.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.