Welcome to the Pirates mailbag, where Post-Gazette reporter Noah Hiles answers all of your questions about the ball club. If you have a question, find him on X at @_NoahHiles or email them at nhiles@post-gazette.com. Noah will answer your questions in full length each Thursday. Below are this week’s top questions:
Hunter: Where does Valdez fit in when Gonzo and Horwitz return?
Hiles: That’s an interesting question to start things off, and it’s one that I’m not sure anyone truly knows the answer to right now. Enmanuel Valdez is hitting the ball well, but we have to see if this continues. Let’s not forget that he was designated for assignment in December, so he is far from a proven talent. However, if he keeps hitting consistently, they have to keep finding him a spot. I think he will move over to second base once Spencer Horwitz returns. Once Nick Gonzales is back, maybe we see him get a look in right field — I know he’s played there a bit in the minor leagues. Overall, I’m not really sure. I just know that they have to play nine guys who can hit, every single day. Right now, he is one of those nine.
John: When Endy Rodriguez comes off the IL. Does that mean Henry Davis goes back to AAA? Or is there a chance one of the struggling outfielders might be removed?
Hiles: If it were my decision, I would option Endy to Triple-A after his rehab assignment ends. Davis hasn’t been that impressive, either, but at least he is a reliable defender. Endy just looked like a player who needed more development during the first few weeks of the season. I’m by no means giving up on the guy. He has talent. I just think some reps at a lower level — at both first base and catcher — would be what's best for him in the long-term.
Scott: Was Cutch forced onto BC & Shelty by Nutting? Is that why there appears to be resistance to play him more?
Read More
Hiles: I don’t know if “forced” is the right word, but I do know that Nutting played a big role in Cutch’s original return. I think the “resistance” has more to do with a discrepancy in Cutch’s durability. The team thinks that Cutch needs regular rest to ensure he will be healthy enough for the full grind of a 162-game season. Considering the injuries he has suffered over the past five or six years, that’s not a terrible assessment. They clearly weren’t planning on having him see much time in the outfield, and when Bryan Reynolds sustained that shoulder injury, it put them in a tough spot. Cutch didn’t get any reps in the outfield throughout all of spring training, so they were concerned with the idea of having him play there regularly with no buildup. Cutch, however, has continued to express that he was conditioned enough to play every day. While I think he understands their plan, he is willing to take on more of a workload because he thinks it will help the team win. That’s why he made those comments.
Opened creations: Where would you prefer Spencer Horwitz in the lineup? For me, I would prefer him leadoff. I think it would be better for Horwitz and Rey to get on base, and in position for Cruz to knock in 1-3 runs.
Hiles: You can’t move Oneil Cruz out of the No. 1 spot right now. They’re getting better production from both him and Reynolds, their two most dangerous bats. The lineup as a whole has been so much more productive with him at the top. I have always viewed Horwitz as a great leadoff option, but you can’t mess with something that is clearly working. I would have Horwitz hit eighth, that way, you have him and Isiah Kiner-Falefa turning the order over. Ideally, Horwitz and IKF will reach base regularly, giving Cruz a chance to drive home runs when facing a pitcher for the second or third time, while also maintaining his value hitting in front of Reynolds and Cutch.
Alec: Do you have an idea where the Pirates' heads were at with making Carmy a starter? Early returns haven’t been good, and starting pitching is the one thing they have depth at from a system standpoint. If they call up Bubba, does Carmy go back to the pen?
Hiles: I understand their thinking behind giving Carmen Mlodzinski a chance to start games. You can never have enough starter depth, and this is something he has always wanted. He is already a proven reliever, and this transition does nothing to impact his ability to pitch in that role. They weren’t likely planning to have him start the year in the rotation, but that changed when Jared Jones and Johan Oviedo went down in spring training. Mlodzinski made the most sense as a temporary replacement. They’re slowly building Bubba Chandler’s volume in a similar way to what we saw them do last year with Paul Skenes, so he wasn’t really an option. And while others such as Thomas Harrington, Mike Burrows and Braxton Ashcraft might have higher ceilings, Mlodzinski pitched better than all three this spring. Mlodzinski wasn’t the long-term answer, which is fine, because they didn’t need a long term fix. They needed someone who could fill that fifth spot until the other arms, who were either injured or needed further development, were ready. If he pitched well, then perhaps he could’ve made their decision more difficult. But I think it’s clear that he isn’t ready to be a regular starting pitcher at this level. Once Chandler is ready, we will likely see Mlodzinski back in the bullpen.
Thanks for reading the Pirates mailbag! If you haven’t already, subscribe to our new Pirates YouTube channel here.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.