FORT MYERS, Fla. — While manager Derek Shelton informed reporters he and his staff will still need a few more days to finalize the Pirates 2025 opening day roster, at least one key decision has been made. The skipper announced Monday morning that right-hander Carmen Mlodzinski will be in the club’s starting rotation to start the season, joining right-handers Paul Skenes and Mitch Keller and left-handers Andrew Heaney and Bailey Falter.

“He was pretty consistent all spring,” Shelton said. “His velocity held. I think the way he took care of himself this winter, we’ve seen the breaking ball continue to get better, and he kinda earned that spot.”

A reliable arm out of the bullpen over the past two seasons, Mlodzinski surprised reporters following the first Grapefruit League game this spring when he said his goal for 2025 was to transition into becoming a starter. The former first-round pick made notable strides on that front, adding a pair of new pitches — a split-finger and two-seam fastball — into his mix, while also building up to take on a higher work volume.

"Honestly, I'm feeling good,” Mlodzinski said on March 15 when asked about his transition into becoming a starter. “I think being in the bullpen the past few years versus coming up as a starter in the minors, actually having a bullpen routine has helped me to a degree in terms of what I'm doing in between starts to help my body and help me feel better every day. All in all, I feel pretty good this spring, with being extended."

Advertise with us

Mlodzinski pitched four times this spring, making two starts and two relief appearances. He logged 9⅔ innings total, allowing five runs, four earned, (3.72 ERA) on 10 hits and three walks while striking out eight batters. His spot in the rotation answers a few questions that surrounded the team heading into the week.

The first pertains to right-hander Jared Jones, who, despite there being no updates on his injury status (right elbow soreness), now looks unlikely to start the season with the team. Shelton said the team will have more information on Jones’ injury Wednesday, after a workout in Miami the afternoon before opening day.

“With the fact that Jared has not thrown, that’s obviously going to be a situation where it’s going to be challenging for him to be able to break with us,” Shelton said.

The second question answered from Mlodzinski making the club involves the other pitcher who was in contention for the final opening in the rotation, Thomas Harrington. A 23-year-old right-hander, Harrington remained in camp with the big-league squad despite him having no major league experience.

MLB Pipeline rates Harrington as the No. 79 prospect in baseball. Despite not making the team, Harrington will start for the Pirates on Monday afternoon against the Twins. He entered the contest having pitched three times this spring, allowing a pair of earned runs on three hits and three walks over 6⅔ innings.

Advertise with us

“Really impressed with the spring he’s had,” Shelton said of Harrington. “We think that he’s very close to being a big-league pitcher.”

Shelton said Monday morning the team’s starting rotation order has yet to be determined, saying the club won’t likely establish a true, concrete one-through-five order in the rotation until the second week of the season due to the early off days on the April schedule.

Other decisions remain

With the starting rotation announced, the main questions surrounding the Pirates opening day roster heading into Monday pertained to the final bullpen and position-player spots.

“I think we’re going to be in a situation where we are not going to make final roster decisions, especially on the last bullpen spot and the last position-player spot, probably as late as Wednesday,” Shelton said Monday morning.

For the bullpen, returning contributors such as David Bednar, Colin Holderman and Dennis Santana all figure to be locks to make the team, as do major league free agent signings Caleb Ferguson and Tim Mayza. With those five established, three openings remain up for grabs.

Advertise with us

On the 40-man roster, right-handers Peter Strzelecki, Hunter Stratton and Justin Lawrence and left-hander Joey Wentz all remain in the conversation. Nonroster invitee Ryan Borucki is also in contention but would force a corresponding move if he were to make the team.

On the position-player side, 11 of the 13 spots have been locked in. Shelton confirmed Sunday that Joey Bart and Endy Rodriguez will be the two catchers on the opening day roster. Adam Frazier, Nick Gonzales, Isiah Kiner-Falefa, Ke’Bryan Hayes and Jared Triolo will all make the squad as infielders, and Oneil Cruz, Tommy Pham, Bryan Reynolds and Andrew McCutchen will be rostered as outfielders.

After the Pirates announced Monday evening they sent DJ Stewart to minor league camp, it appears the final two position-player roster spots will go to Jack Suwinski and Ji Hwan Bae. Suwinski and Bae are both outfielders, while Stewart also received a notable look at first base this spring.

Of that duo, it was Bae who had the best showing at the plate this spring, leading the club with 16 hits and 13 runs scored. Bae finished the preseason hitting .381 with a 1.017 OPS in 20 games, while Suwinski was not far behind, batting .375 with a 1.022 OPS over 14 games. Bae and Suwinski tallied just one homer apiece this spring.