Pirates fans might remember reading about Matt Hague, the player. A ninth-round pick in the 2008 draft, Hague demolished baseballs throughout spring training in 2012, earning himself a spot on Pittsburgh’s opening day roster. Back then, Hague was known as “the hit collector.” Twelve years later, he is now known as the Pirates hitting coach.

Sources confirmed to the Post-Gazette on Wednesday morning the Pirates chose Hague to fill the role that opened early last month. Hague is the third hitting coach under manager Derek Shelton, with Rick Eckstein and Andy Haines coming before him.

While his name perhaps rings a bell, Hague has much to prove in 2025. The 39-year-old Bellevue, Wash., native inherited an offense that finished 24th in runs scored, 27th in team OPS and had the fourth-most strikeouts of any club. Paired with that lack of production is the struggle to develop consistent, high-quality major league hitters.

With just one year of major league coaching experience under his belt, Hague’s resume offers little to learn from afar. The Post-Gazette spoke with a few of Hague’s former teammates to learn what could be his greatest strengths, along with his most significant challenges entering his first season as the Pirates hitting coach.

Advertise with us

‘Dirt in his veins’

When one reminisces of the success Pittsburgh’s baseball club experienced from 2013 through 2015, Hague’s name is far down on the list of players connected to that glory. But despite his limited involvement at the major league level, other Pirates from that era spoke highly of the former corner infielder.

“He struck me as kind of a baseball lifer,” former Pirates second baseman Neil Walker told the Post-Gazette, “one of those guys who is a baseball rat, per se, a grinder who could roll out of bed and find a barrel. Of course, he didn’t have an incredibly long major league career, but nonetheless, he was very knowledgeable on the hitting side, with what he wanted to do and what his skill set was.”

“I think Matt Hague is a baseball junkie,” former Pirates catcher Michael McKenry added. “He loves the game. When I played with him, he almost had dirt in his veins. He was a guy that you wanted to compete with.”

Hague appeared in just 33 games with the Pirates. He went on to play in 10 more for the Blue Jays before his time as a big leaguer came to a close. His minor league resume, however, was far more notable.

Coming up in the Pirates system, Hague played a part in some of the most successful minor league clubs the organization has boasted in the past few decades, helping the Altoona Curve capture both a division and league title in 2010 and the Indianapolis Indians win back-to-back division titles in 2012 and 2013.

Advertise with us

During those years, the Pirates organization was loaded with high-ranked prospects. And while Hague never found himself high up on any rankings, his teammates found him to be a valuable asset in the dugout.

“Not everyone is a guy you want to go to for hitting advice,” former Pirates outfielder Alex Presley told the Post-Gazette. “He’s a guy you could go to, that you could trust. ... He knows how to approach things, which I think can sometimes be overlooked. He’s been through a lot of the ups and downs, having to play in tough situations. He’s a good guy to lean on.”

Hague earned his way onto multiple minor league All-Star teams while in the Pirates organization. His success continued after he was claimed by the Blue Jays in 2014, being named the International League’s Most Valuable Player in 2015.

Hague spent 2016 playing in Japan for the Hanshin Tigers. He returned to the United States the following year and spent three more seasons in the minor leagues. According to his teammates, Hague’s wise approach at the plate and ability to help those around him improve paved the way for a decadelong playing career. And now, as a coach, he will look to use those same attributes to provide a jolt to the Pirates offense.

‘A good setup’

Common complaints during Haines’ tenure as the Pirates hitting coach were the team seemingly having a collective approach and the organization’s struggle to complete the development of its top hitting prospects. Hague’s former teammates believe he will break these trends, starting first with an individualized coaching approach designed specifically for the different types of hitters found in the Pirates lineup.

Advertise with us

“I would assume that, given his skillset, that’s something he would excel at,” Walker said. “Taking an individual, knowing what their strengths are and knowing how to get the most out of them, knowing their abilities, mixed with where they’re hitting in the lineup, who they’re facing that day, ... I’m sure that was something that allowed him to stand out during the search. He can relate to hitters across the board — from Ji Hwan Bae types to Oneil Cruz types to Ke’Bryan Hayes types. I see him being able to relate to every guy on the roster on the offensive side.”

While Hague’s playing days weren’t long ago, much has changed at baseball’s highest level as far as hitting approach is concerned. Presley, who has remained close with Hague, has noticed his ability to continually adapt with the game’s new technology and concepts.

“Today, there is so much individual training — not that we didn’t do individual training — but it’s more matchup-focused now, as opposed to, ‘Hey, as a group, we need to do this,’ ” Presley said. “To be successful in coaching now, you have to embrace the data. He’s a great mesh of a guy that knows how to hit the more traditional way but also knows that it’s important to understand and embrace the new stuff. I think he can mesh those two together in a lot of ways. It’s a good setup for right now.”

In addition to developing a strategy, Hague will also need to communicate a message that resonates, a struggle Haines faced during his time in Pittsburgh, per multiple sources. McKenry believes Hague’s background as a minor league journeyman can perhaps create a clear path to open dialogue between players and the coaching staff.

“The first thing he brings is empathy,” McKenry said. “A guy that’s kinda been around the bend understands the different things when the game isn’t going according to plan. The best hitting coaches should have two ears, one mouth and their ears seem to grow as the year goes along, while the mouth seems to shrink. ... He’s going to listen and facilitate a hitting team to pull out the best potential for that guy’s success.”

Advertise with us

‘Through the wringer’

Despite the aforementioned positives listed by his former teammates, Hague’s hiring comes with some clear skepticism among fans. Eckstein and Haines both arrived in Pittsburgh with far more established resumes, having worked with some of the game’s top hitters earlier in their careers.

In three seasons as a minor league hitting coach, Hague’s teams excelled at plate discipline, twice leading their division in on-base percentage. But those clubs also struggled with power production, finishing second to last and last in home runs in those respective years. The numbers, on the surface, match an approach familiar to Pittsburgh, which could lead some to wonder if Hague was hired to teach his own message or continue the organization’s hitting philosophy. But his former teammates believe Hague can provide a different message and overall outlook in the batter's box.

“I think he’s going to bring a competing mindset — or at least I hope he will,” McKenry said. “The best dynamic for me in a hitting situation is having someone I can sit there on the couch or at a bar and just talk about the game. He can talk guys through their issues, which helps them figure things out on their own. The development comes from the team around him. They can focus on the development, and he can focus on the day to day, their approach.”

Unlike Haines, who had previously coached a few of the players he worked with in Pittsburgh, Hague will have to build credibility in the clubhouse. With just one year of major league coaching experience, skepticism could easily arise.

Last season, Hague worked with Isiah Kiner-Falefa in Toronto. He also shared a clubhouse with Andrew McCutchen during his playing days. Assuming both are back in 2025, McKenry believes the endorsement from the Pirates’ pair of veteran leaders could go a long way.

“There is a lot that goes into the trust of the team, and I think he will build that trust fast,” McKenry said. “He can give a lot of insight to guys who are going through the wringer and the movement that we’re probably going to have on our roster in the next couple of years. I think it’s a good hire when it comes to having a guy that’s been in the dirt.”