OAKLAND, Calif. — While Kevin McClatchy is best known in baseball circles for his 11-year run as the Pirates’ lead owner, he came quite close to running a different MLB franchise.

In 1994, McClatchy put together a group that finished runner-up to Stephen Schott and Ken Hofmann to purchase the Oakland Athletics. McClatchy now resides in Ligonier, but he was born in Sacramento, lived in the Bay Area until he was in eighth grade and grew up going to both A’s and San Francisco Giants games.

“We didn’t get it because we were considered outsiders, because we were from Sacramento,” McClatchy told the Post-Gazette over the phone on Wednesday. “And, they were worried that we were going to move the A’s to Sacramento, which we weren’t, actually. Never our intention.”

Instead, McClatchy pivoted and became the leader and plurality investor in a group that paid $95 million for the Pirates in February of 1996. The Pirates failed to produce a winning season with McClatchy operating as the team’s chief executive officer, but he was integral to the construction of PNC Park.

Advertise with us

Shortly after McClatchy acquired the Pirates, he helped the franchise secure public money to finance PNC Park’s construction. Before McClatchy took over the reins, though, he believed the Pirates’ relocation threats to areas such as northern Virginia and Orlando, Fla., were quite legitimate.

“In my opinion, the Pirates probably would have moved to northern Virginia or Orlando had they not got a new ballpark,” McClatchy said, “and I think you’re seeing that there’s a point with any organization where it gets to a tipping point.

“I think Oakland’s in that situation, and you’re seeing it play out.”

The Athletics’ Thursday afternoon game against the Rangers will mark their last at the Oakland-Alameda County Coliseum after 57 years at the venue. The franchise is slated to play at least the next three seasons in Sacramento before moving to Las Vegas on a full-time basis as soon as 2028.

Given his background, McClatchy considers himself one of the few people who understands the plight of both A’s ownership and the club’s fans, to whom he is amply sympathetic. McClatchy believes the city of Oakland’s “biggest mistake” was making a deal with former Raiders owner Al Davis.

Advertise with us

In exchange for the Raiders returning to Oakland from Los Angeles in 1995, the city constructed a 20,000-seat section beyond center field. Known by fans as “Mount Davis”, it cost $500 million to build and was promptly criticized for being both too steep and far away from game action.

Ultimately, the Raiders left for Las Vegas in 2020, and the A’s are doing their best to follow suit.

“I think it would have been great if the A’s would have stayed in Oakland. And, I think it was a missed opportunity,” McClatchy said. “I think Oakland was trying to juggle too many things, and they picked, I guess, the wrong partner in Al Davis.”

The A’s are departing the Bay Area for myriad other reasons, such as ownership and local politicians failing to make tangible progress during negotiations. McClatchy questions if A’s ownership, which currently is headed by John Fisher, ever invested the necessary time to convince politicians they truly wanted to keep the team in Oakland.

McClatchy was in favor, though, of a few of the team’s stadium proposals and believed there was plenty of potential with a waterfront stadium. So, too, does he think Sacramento has a great opportunity in front of it.

Advertise with us

While the Athletics intend to only play at the Giants’ Triple-A home of Sutter Health Park in West Sacramento for three years, McClatchy sees that stretch as a trial run for an area he hopes will one day get its own MLB franchise.

“I think Sacramento could definitely host Major League Baseball. It’s a baseball town. It’s a baseball city, I’d say,” McClatchy said. “I think it would have a great fan base. So, I think they could.

“They’re a little bit light on the corporate side, but I think they could still be successful.”

Fans of the Pirates, meanwhile, need not worry about the club moving anytime soon. Their lease at PNC Park isn’t set to expire until 2030, and the team has given no public indications of seeking to depart Pittsburgh.

While McClatchy’s time as lead Pirates owner was not without warts, he takes great pride in the construction of PNC Park, which he believes is the best stadium in the big leagues.

Advertise with us

“It was great to see when they had the wild card game there against Cincinnati,” McClatchy said. “And then some of the playoff games they had — that’s the way you want it. That’s the way you want to see PNC Park. And we have great fans in Pittsburgh. They definitely came out, and they supported us, even when we struggled.”

Unfortunately for Athletics fans, they won’t get to do the same in Oakland beyond Thursday. Successful collaboration never took place between A’s ownership and the city of Oakland, ultimately prompting the team’s impending departure.

After he failed to acquire the Athletics nearly three decades ago, McClatchy said he never looked back. He considers himself lucky the Pirates received a “beautiful” piece of property to build along the banks of the North Shore, and that they could successfully partner with the city and state.

Still, McClatchy can’t help but wonder if the Athletics’ fate could have mirrored that of the Pirates with PNC Park had his group taken ownership of the Bay Area baseball franchise.

“[PNC Park] was a real collaboration between public and private, and it just was the right time and everything sort of worked. It’s tough to speculate — I would think and I would hope that it would have been the case in Oakland,” McClatchy said. “But we weren’t that far down the road with the city in trying to get them to guarantee building a ballpark or anything like that.

“We were just trying to purchase the team at that time.”