As the Pirates find themselves battling for playoff position, one active conversation surrounding the team involves a different position — finding the appropriate one for Oneil Cruz.

Following a lousy series for the 6-foot-7 shortstop in Houston, it has become popular to suggest that Cruz will soon have to move somewhere else on the diamond.

I’m not there yet, although it’s hard to overlook his MLB-high 21 errors, which included another one Friday in the Pirates’ 9-8 loss to the Arizona Diamondbacks at PNC Park.

Cruz balanced that out, of course, with the first five-hit game of his career, the continuation of an up-and-down season for the 25-year-old in 2024.

Advertise with us

“It always feels good to have a 5-for-5 game,” Cruz said, with major league coach Stephen Morales translating. “But the most important thing is that you learn from your mistakes. [Friday] I was able to bounce back and contribute to my team.”

The frustration over Cruz’s defensive issues has led some to suggest that he should move to third base and have Ke’Bryan Hayes play shortstop, which I don’t see as a logical solution here.

I went into this season wanting to see how Cruz would handle himself defensively over 162 games, and I refuse to make any proclamations now, with 53 games left.

This remains the first full MLB season of Cruz’s career, which is the result of the serious ankle injury he suffered in 2023. Furthermore, we’ve seen his offense and defense endure plenty of peaks and valleys.

One example: While Cruz has made nine errors in his past 10 games, he made just two over his previous 37. More than anything, I want to see how Cruz responds to what has transpired over the past 13 days and whether he can improve this part of his game.

Advertise with us

If he does, that’s the path of least resistance with Cruz — leave him at shortstop and help him grow at a position he has played his entire life.

It’s also fair for someone to doubt whether that will be possible. Entering Friday, Cruz had a .939 fielding percentage, which was last of 126 qualified defenders in MLB.

When it comes to FanGraphs’ calculation of defensive runs saved, Cruz has been worth -8; only two defenders, regardless of position, have fared worse.

At the same time, Cruz is hitting .257 with a .777 OPS that includes 23 doubles, two triples and 17 home runs, as well as 56 RBIs and 51 runs scored.

“He's a good baseball player, and he didn't let anything affect him,” Pirates manager Derek Shelton said after Friday’s loss. “Tough game the other day in Houston. He made an error in the first. He responded and played well the rest of the game. He was engaged. He had great at-bats.”

Advertise with us

The play everyone freaked out over in Houston was certainly ugly, with Cruz running back and failing to peel off on a ball that clearly belonged to Bryan Reynolds.

Cruz explained that crowd noise complicated their communication. He also botched the subsequent throw, which speaks to some of what I think has been going on here: Cruz has been trying way too hard to cover for his mistakes.

If the defensive stuff wasn’t enough, Cruz went just 1 for 13 with nine strikeouts against the Astros. However, he also posted a .271 average and .876 OPS in 22 July games, which included seven doubles, a triple and five home runs.

The Pirates absolutely need Cruz’s bat in the lineup. Calls to bench him Friday to send some sort of message were flat-out ridiculous, both from a competitive standpoint for the Pirates and doing what’s best for Cruz.

More than anything, the Pirates must get him to relax. They need to help him learn how to separate his inevitable struggles at the plate from whatever happens in the field — and vice versa.

Advertise with us

The Pirates also can’t guarantee Cruz the starting job at shortstop in perpetuity. The way their team is built, their pitching staff needs to have strong defense up the middle. But the time to act is not now.

Moving Cruz to third makes little sense to me, the same for wasting his arm and athleticism at first base. The outfield? Maybe. But there’s no way I’m doing that now. It’s not the best thing for Cruz or the team, especially with Bryan Reynolds, Michael A. Taylor and Bryan De La Cruz there now.

You acquired De La Cruz to play him. Taylor has gotten better with regular playing time and had an .894 OPS in July. You also need to take into account Cruz’s previous hesitancy with shifting to the outfield and realize that it’s not setting anyone up for success to do that midseason.

It’s why I think the best thing the Pirates can do right now is preach patience, try to support Cruz in whatever way possible, coach him and keep trying to help him become a better defensive shortstop. Maybe it happens, maybe it doesn’t.

If we get to the end of the year and the recent trend has continued, sure, it might be time to talk to him about right or center field. One easy comparison to cite might be San Diego’s Fernando Tatis Jr., who made 21 errors in 102 games at short in 2021 … but won a Gold Glove two years later when he embraced a move to the outfield.

Advertise with us

That discussion, if it happened, would probably be centered around doing what’s best for the team — moving to the outfield and letting either Isiah Kiner-Falefa or someone else take over at shortstop. As much as Cruz loves the position, I don’t see him prioritizing his own desires over winning.

It’s also not a new thing.

We’ve seen Cruz go through periods where he shows improvement with things like plate discipline, hitting breaking staff and left-on-left at-bats. In fact, since July 1, Cruz — who supposedly couldn’t hit lefties — has hit .310 with a 1.034 OPS against southpaws, evidence of how much things can change with a young player.

So, while it certainly doesn’t OK all the errors, doing anything now would also be a reactionary move that the Pirates should avoid.

Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and @JMackeyPG on X