HOUSTON — As the 2024 baseball season progresses, Derek Shelton’s club continues to improve. After tallying their first winning month in June, the Pirates were even better in July, going 15-10.

The Pirates won five of their eight series last month, losing two and splitting a four-game set against the Mets. Their success catapulted them above .500 for the first time since late April and allowed them to remain in the mix for the National League wild-card race.

With a few new players who were acquired at the trade deadline, the Pirates will look to continue their push forward in August. A key homestand that includes a pair of three-game sets against the Diamondbacks and Padres serves as a valuable opportunity to gain further ground in the quest for October. However, before we turn the page to a new month, let’s take one final look at the past 31 days. Here is the Post-Gazette’s report card for July:

STARTING PITCHING: A

June grade: A+

Advertise with us

The Pirates starting rotation wasn’t the best in baseball like last month, but it wasn’t far off. Paul Skenes continued his dominance, ranking third among MLB starting pitchers in ERA (1.59), hits allowed (13) and batting average against (.157). But Skenes wasn’t the only starting pitcher who shined in July. Arguably the biggest story among the group was Luis Ortiz, who successfully transitioned into a rotation spot. Ortiz posted a 1.75 ERA throughout the month and provides even more optimism with the unit moving forward.

Mitch Keller remained his reliable self. While Martin Perez and Marco Gonzales were both inconsistent, the Pirates rotation as a whole had the second-lowest ERA in MLB (3.02) and the third-best left-on-base percentage (79.9%). With Bailey Falter back from the injured list and Jared Jones expected to return within the next few weeks, this group will give the Pirates a tremendous advantage against the five other teams they are battling in the wild card race.

BULLPEN: A–

June grade: C+

In last month’s report card, the Post-Gazette documented the progress the bullpen showed in the back half of June. That progress continued throughout July, making it one of the more effective bullpens in baseball. The bullpen was sixth-best in MLB in both WAR (1.0) and ERA (3.20) in July.

Leading the charge was Dennis Santana, perhaps the least likely of all candidates. Santana allowed just one earned run in a team-high 13 ⅔ innings of relief in July, good for an 0.66 ERA. His 0.6 WAR last month was sixth-best among all relievers in MLB. While Santana flew largely under the radar, Aroldis Chapman shined in the spotlight, tallying a team-best four wins in July, which is tied with Jakob Junis (Brewers/Reds) and Hans Crouse (Angels) for the most in MLB. Chapman finished the month 4-1 with a save and a 2.79 ERA. His blown save against the Cardinals on July 4 was costly, but he helped the Pirates far more than he hurt them during David Bednar’s time on the injured list.

Advertise with us

Bednar returned just before the All-Star break and has successfully converted each of his three save opportunities. Kyle Nicolas (0.84 ERA) and Carmen Mlodzinski (1.86) were both stellar in their higher leverage roles, both finishing the month with sub-two ERAs. Colin Holderman was the unit’s lone weak point, going 0-1 with a 5.79 ERA in July. However, three of the six earned runs Holderman allowed in July came in his last two outings. He posted a zero in six of his seven appearances prior.

CATCHERS: B

June grade: D

It took four months, but the Pirates finally have their starting catcher. After returning from the injured list in late June, Joey Bart established himself as the club’s primary backstop, hitting .276 with three home runs and 12 RBIs in July. Bart was also a weapon behind the plate, nailing seven attempted base stealers last month, which led MLB.

Behind Bart was Yasmani Grandal, who, despite being involved in more than a few frustrating double plays along with a pair of costly dropped third-strike foul tips, was a proficient backup. Grandal posted a .517 slugging percentage in July, seventh-best among MLB catchers with at least 30 plate appearances. Perhaps more importantly, Grandal has worked his way into becoming Skenes’ personal catcher, a role that he has held well.

INFIELD: C

June grade: C–

Advertise with us

The Pirates’ infield is by far the toughest unit to judge. There have been plenty of highs with this group — clutch hits from Oneil Cruz and Nick Gonzales, stellar defensive efforts from Ke’Bryan Hayes and Jared Triolo — but also more than a few frustrating blunders.

For the second straight month, Rowdy Tellez provided the most consistency among the Pirates’ infield, hitting .297 with five home runs, which is tied with Cruz and Bryan Reynolds for the most on the club. Tellez slugged .578 in July, which is third-best among MLB first basemen with at least 70 plate appearances. Next to Tellez on the right side of the diamond is Nick Gonzales, who prior to getting injured last weekend in Arizona was in the midst of a regression at the plate. Despite a few big-time clutch knocks, including a game-winning RBI on July 19 over the Phillies, Gonzales struggled at the dish, hitting only .214. He was, however, decent in the field, tallying a 1.3 defensive WAR, fifth-best among MLB second basemen.

Oneil Cruz continued his roller coaster of a season in July, slugging five homers and posting a 136 wRC+. He showed notable improvement against left-handed pitchers, tallying a pair of extra-base hits on July 20 against the Phillies. But there were also many bad moments. Cruz struck out in 34.4% of his at-bats in July, the third-worst rate among MLB qualified hitters. He also committed eight errors in July, five of them coming during the Pirates’ most recent series in Houston.

Cruz is far from the Pirates’ biggest problem. He has helped his club more than he has hurt it, but he must find an answer to his fielding woes in the remaining months. Fielding was no issue for third baseman Ke’Bryan Hayes, who compiled a 1.6 defensive WAR in July, which was third-best among big-league third basemen. But for as good as Hayes was in the field, he was just as bad at the bat. Hayes’ .266 slugging percentage in July ranked last among the 26 qualified MLB third basemen. He was also third-worst in wRC+ (53) and WAR (minus-0.1), and 50% of the balls he put in play were hit on the ground. His offense remains an issue and looks to be something that shows no signs of improvement.

OUTFIELD: C–

June grade: D+

Advertise with us

Reynolds didn’t hit safely in 25 games like he did in June, but he was once again an elite hitter. Reynolds batted .325 in July, which led all qualified MLB left fielders. He was also tied for third in home runs (five) and ranked fourth in wRC+ (156). Michael A. Taylor concluded his best month as a Pirate with a pair of towering home runs in Houston. Taylor had a 143 wRC+ in July, which was 10th-best among MLB center fielders with at least 40 plate appearances. Taylor’s play earned himself more opportunities over Jack Suwinski, who was once again optioned to Triple-A Indianapolis. Connor Joe and Joshua Palacios split the bulk of the time in right field last month, and neither played particularly well. The former was worth minus-0.2 WAR and had a 58 wRC+, which ranked 44th out of 47 MLB right fielders with at least 50 plate appearances. The latter was a bit better, earning a 0.1 WAR in tallying a 90 wRC+, which is still below league average.

DESIGNATED HITTER: D

June grade: C

Andrew McCutchen had his worst month since April, batting just .200. The Pirates’ leadoff hitter still managed to put together quality at-bats, but his production ranked among the bottom of MLB designated hitters in July. McCutchen was worth minus-0.1 WAR last month, second-worst among MLB DH’s. His 85 wRC+ was third lowest among the qualified players at his position. McCutchen has not been bad enough to lose his starting spot. But if his regression continues, perhaps a few more off days would help him get back on track.

BENCH: C

June grade: B+

With a starting lineup established, the Pirates relied much less upon their platoon and reserve players in July. Joe did little to contribute against left-handers when playing first base in place of Tellez. Jared Triolo had a few big hits in the club’s recent road trip, but saw a notable drop in playing time last month. Alika Williams and Ji Hwan Bae were both rarely utilized, as well. With new deadline additions to the club, the Pirates now have greater depth at each position. This could allow the bench to have a stronger impact in the final two months.

Advertise with us

COACHING: B

June grade: B+

Always the most controversial grade of these monthly report cards, the Post-Gazette is once again giving Derek Shelton a solid grade. Shelton had a few more questionable decisions than last month. His dedication toward late-game, righty-lefty pinch-hit matchups were sometimes too much. However, Shelton made more than a few good decisions in July.

His management of the pitching rotation continues to pay off. While fans complained about his decision to not use Keller or Skenes against the Phillies coming out of the All-Star break, his club still managed to win the series, allowing the two top arms to toe the rubber later on against the Cardinals. Shelton has also used his bullpen well more often than not. He has successfully allowed Mlodzinski and Nicolas to confidently become reliable high-leverage weapons.

Sure, one could argue his choice to pull Jalen Beeks on Wednesday evening for Holderman was costly, but there was at least a reason behind the decision. Shelton also received heat for pulling Skenes after seven no-hit innings in Milwaukee. But the moves he made helped the Pirates secure a crucial 1-0 victory and series win over the NL Central leader. Pirates hitting coach Andy Haines remains the top target of jeers throughout the fan base, and perhaps deservedly so. But Cruz’s recent success against left-handers and Taylor’s notable uptick in production are his doing.

And as far as the pitching staff goes, it’s hard to find much wrongdoing from Oscar Marin and Justin Meccage, who together have constructed one of the best overall staffs in baseball.

Noah Hiles: nhiles@post-gazette.com and @_NoahHiles on X