Fifteen different pitchers have appeared out of the bullpen for the Pirates this season, and more often than not their performances have fallen short of expectations.

Entering Sunday’s series finale against the Rockies, Pirates relievers ranked 26th in MLB with a bullpen-wide 4.65 ERA. On his weekly radio show with 93.7 The Fan, general manager Ben Cherington addressed the shortcomings of the bullpen he constructed.

“Despite some challenges with guys we've given opportunity to recently — and there's reasons why we did that — still really believe in the core talent in our bullpen,” Cherington said. “Still believe that is and can be a strength over the course of the season.”

The back end of David Bednar, Colin Holderman and Aroldis Chapman has collectively pitched as well as it has all season in recent weeks. However, Holderman has far and away been the most consistent of those hurlers.

Advertise with us

Outside the veteran-laden trio, it’s been a rotating cast of relievers. That includes Dennis Santana, who allowed six earned runs on Saturday and was claimed off waivers from the New York Yankees earlier in the week. Ben Heller is also included on that list, and gave up 11 earned runs in just two innings before he was designated for assignment.

Given the Pirates’ bullpen is down expected contributors like the injured Dauri Moreta, Ryan Borucki and Hunter Stratton, Cherington was adamant the team will continue to explore less-conventional options. Cherington said when it comes to looking outside the organization for solutions via trade, that avenue will be more of a focus for other areas.

“We're gonna keep taking shots. We’re going to keep taking shots on less-proven guys who have pitch qualities that we believe can translate to major league success,” Cherington said. “Some of those are going to be younger pitchers like Carmen Mlodzinski and Kyle Nicolas who come up through the system.

“Some of them are going to be external. And over time, we're gonna hit on enough of those and it's gonna add up to a good bullpen.”

Through the first two months and change of the season, that approach hasn’t yielded results as intended. The Pirates’ bullpen ranked last in the National League in ERA in May, as well as 25th in MLB in June.

Advertise with us

The club has even parted ways with relievers who took on key roles in 2023 like Roansy Contreras and Jose Hernandez, each of whom was traded for cash considerations and to the Angels and Dodgers, respectively. Cherington said with Hernandez, the Pirates “ran out of time” to help the left-hander find his form.

“We didn't see the pitch qualities get back to where we thought they needed to be to be more confident that he could help the major league team,” Cherington said. “So, we made the call when we needed the spot to DFA him.”

At least this season, the Pirates have been reliant upon their advanced analytics when evaluating relief pitchers. Based on their recent transactions and plans for future moves, that will continue to be the case when searching for less-heralded talent that theoretically could perform against MLB competition.

“We got to keep taking those shots,” Cherington said. “That's the way we're going to do it here.”

Rotation reinforcements

In light of the Pirates turning to bullpen games in two of their final three games of the road trip, Cherington discussed the statuses of injured starting pitchers Martin Perez, Marco Gonzales and Quinn Priester.

Advertise with us

Cherington said Perez, who is dealing with a left groin strain, has recovered both well and quickly from his ailment.

“I would probably bet on seeing him first of those three I mentioned, just because anything with the arm, we’re going to take a little bit more time to build up pitch count and volume,” Cherington said in reference to both Gonzales and Priester.

Perez last started for the Pirates on May 26 against the Atlanta Braves, and has yet to pitch in a rehab game. Those three starters are the most likely to make positive impacts on the Pirates in the immediate future, but further reinforcements could be on the way.

Cherington said pitching prospect Mike Burrows, who had Tommy John surgery last spring, is currently throwing simulation games at the Pirates’ spring training complex.

“It's been one step forward consistently since spring training,” Cherington said. “Stuff has looked really good.

Advertise with us

Cherington said it’s possible that live-game activity could begin for Burrows as soon as July. He is the No. 10 overall prospect in the Pirates’ system, per MLB Pipeline.

Offensive upgrades?

While the Pirates’ offense has taken strides since a woeful end of April and beginning of May, Cherington is aware that the output in recent weeks still isn’t conducive to consistently winning games.

“We want to score more runs,” Cherington said. “We know to be winning at the level consistently that we want to, we need to score more runs. So, that part hasn't changed.”

As for how the Pirates go about inciting more offense, Cherington said it’s his job to consider external solutions — which could be in play for the club should they at least remain in the wild card race.

“It's an area of the team again, if we can hang in there, which I expect we will, that we'd like to add to,” Cherington said. “We'd like to be able to find a hitter or more that can come in and provide an upgrade and help add depth to the lineup. And, we're certainly looking at that.”

Andrew Destin: adestin@post-gazette.com and @AndrewDestin1 on X