During Ben Cherington’s tenure as the Pirates’ general manager, perhaps no more concrete an example exists of a player responding well from a stint in the minors than Nick Gonzales.

The former first round pick has driven in 23 runs since making his season debut on May 10, fourth-most in MLB over that stretch. Gonzales is hitting over .300, thanks in large part to the swing changes the Pirates asked him to make over the offseason.

Like manager Derek Shelton has numerous times in the past few weeks, Cherington on Saturday afternoon highlighted a late-March chat with Gonzales in which he was informed he would start the year with Triple-A Indianapolis.

"When we sat Nick down in spring training,” Cherington said. “It was one of the sort of like clearest 'send down' conversations I can remember in terms of how he, what he was thinking about and how clear he was on what he needed to do, and even what he needed from us.”

Advertise with us

Rather than being a poster child for the Pirates’ success with developing position players, though, Gonzales has been an aberration for the club in 2024. Jack Suwinski and Henry Davis, each of whom were expected to play pivotal roles in the Pirates’ lineup this season, have been demoted to Triple-A at different junctures because of difficulties to consistently produce offensively.

Since returning to the big leagues, the duo has combined to go 4 for 23 with 14 strikeouts. Yet, according to the franchise, each player’s minor-league production warranted respective promotions.

The trouble is, in Shelton’s opinion, that there’s a stark contrast between MLB pitching and what hitters like Suwinski and Davis see a step below it.

“There’s never been a bigger difference between Major League Baseball and Triple-A baseball and we’re seeing that potentially good major league players are coming up and struggling,” Shelton said. “I think that’s the question we’re trying to figure out as an industry.”

One adjustment that’s hardly specific to the Pirates is that since 2021, each MLB franchise has operated with four fewer affiliated minor-league teams. That adjustment to farm systems’ compositions prompted hot-shot prospects like Davis, a No. 1 overall pick in 2021, to ascend it perhaps quicker than other top draftees would have in seasons passed.

Advertise with us

Shelton, though, is quick to point out that a gap between Triple-A and big-league pitching isn’t a sufficient excuse for scuffling Davis, who has a .474 OPS this season and a career .607 mark in 88 games.

“He went down, did exactly what we asked him to do,” Shelton said of Davis. “But he’s struggled a bit up here, and he’s got to figure it out.”

As demonstrated through Davis’ exploits with Indianapolis, for whom he smacked seven home runs in 23 games this season, there isn’t much more for the 24-year-old to learn against minor-league pitching. Rather, the franchise is likely to gather more about Davis, for instance, by keeping him with the Pirates.

“I've heard the argument that when it comes to position players, at least, at some point learning from the major leagues is important because this is where the best pitching is,” Cherington said. “and this is the level that ultimately we want players to perform at, so at some point they need to get that feedback.”

In a similar vein, the Pirates are open to the notion of adding a few minor-league starters to their bullpen at some point this season. Though they have since cemented themselves as bullpen arms, the likes of Carmen Mlodzinski, Kyle Nicolas and Luis Ortiz were each once viewed as top prospects and potential starting options.

Advertise with us

Considering the Pirates’ rotation currently features stalwarts such as Mitch Keller, Paul Skenes and Jared Jones, starters in Double-A like Braxton Ashcraft or Anthony Solometo could theoretically join the Pirates for a late post-season push if needed.

“I think we're getting into a new point of the season now, that kind of middle part of the season,” Cherington said. “where if we have a pitcher who is capable of helping us in the major leagues in a different role, and then especially if we think we can do that in a way that is consistent with their long-term development, then sure, that's obviously something we'll consider.”

Such discussions highlight the changing landscape of how prospects are handled, not just by the Pirates but by all MLB teams. It’s hardly a straightforward process anymore. Instead, as more data is accrued against big-league competition, it will become clearer whether the Pirates’ more coveted players are busts, cornerstones, or somewhere in between.

Gonzales, who endured plenty of tribulations in 2023, has enjoyed all sorts of success on the heels of a month and change in the minors and looks the part of a No. 7 overall pick. But Cherington is aware the league will ultimately challenge Gonzales again in the never-ending cat-and-mouse game facing MLB pitching.

“There will be something else in front of him at some point that he'll need to adjust to,” Cherington said. “and we bet on him doing that again at that point."

Andrew Destin: adestin@post-gazette.com and @AndrewDestin1 on X