MILWAUKEE — The six-man rotation experiment lasted all of one week.

Prior to Wednesday afternoon’s rubber match against the Brewers, the Pirates optioned right-handed starter Quinn Priester to Triple-A Indianapolis. Right-handed reliever Carmen Mlodzinski was recalled from the Pirates’ top affiliate in a corresponding move.

Since top prospect Paul Skenes made his MLB debut last week, the Pirates had operated with only seven relief pitchers. The club has three off days remaining this month, too, which only reduced the value of a six-man rotation.

Mlodzinski, 25, was originally pegged to crack the Pirates’ opening-day roster after going 3-3 with a 2.25 ERA in 32 MLB games last season. But Mlodzinski started the 2024 campaign on the 15-day injured list with right shoulder inflammation and spent the first two months of the season with Indianapolis.

Advertise with us

Mlodzinski told reporters in Milwaukee that he’s physically in a “really good spot” these days and he’s made some progress in terms of his health over the last few weeks. Still, he was not pleased to be shelved with an injury coming out of spring training.

“I think any time you’re out with injury or a setback, it’s going to be a little frustrating,” Mlodzinski said. “But just have to have a different perspective, take a step back and understand what’s going on — I think, all in all, it’s just part of the process.”

Priester, meanwhile, returns to the minors on the heels of yielding a season-high nine hits in a 4-3 loss to the Brewers on Tuesday night. All four runs Milwaukee scored against Priester came in the second inning, in line with a troubling trend for the 23-year-old right-hander.

After his start, Priester lamented the fact that crooked innings have blemished his stats through 15 career MLB appearances. Manager Derek Shelton agreed, noting that’s been the one thing Priester has “battled” dating back to last season.

“Very frustrating,” Priester said. “I felt that aside from that inning there, we threw the ball extremely well — and probably better than we have — [on Tuesday night]. The stuff was there.”

Advertise with us

Home runs have also plagued Priester. In 77 career innings, he’s given up 19 four-baggers, including seven in 27 frames this season.

Priester will return to Indianapolis, where he began the season, with an 0-4 record and 4.33 ERA in five MLB starts. For the foreseeable future, the Pirates rotation will instead be composed of right-handers Skenes, Jared Jones and Mitch Keller, as well as southpaws Martin Perez and Bailey Falter.

Mlodzinski, meanwhile, joins a bullpen that’s been reeling as of late. Since the beginning of May, Pirates relievers have a combined 5.40 ERA, tied for fifth worst in MLB, per FanGraphs.

While Mlodzinski has plenty of pedigree as a former No. 31 overall pick, he struggled in Triple-A to the tune of a 6.60 ERA this season. The time he spent in Pittsburgh in 2023, however, provided Mlodzinski with plenty of valuable information.

“Just being able to watch these guys in the clubhouse and watch these guys on the field and see what they do every day and try to apply that into what I’m doing,” Mlodzinski said. “And then just understanding — what does it look like to get through a full season at this level?”

Advertise with us

Last season, Mlodzinski eventually assumed a role as a setup man in the Pirates bullpen. It’ll be curious to see how Mlodzinski, who was a starter in the minors until getting to Triple-A, is deployed.

In the interim, he’s looking to build off the results that were much better in MLB last season than what he produced during a couple months in the minors this spring. From his MLB tenure last season, Mlodzinski learned that his repertoire plays, and he’s not afraid to say as much.

“[I] have the confidence to be able to say that I want to stay here and I have the stuff.”

Andrew Destin: adestin@post-gazette.com and @AndrewDestin1 on X