The demand for No. 30 jerseys continues to build. The local sports talk radio airwaves are focusing mostly on one man. The eyes of the baseball world are honing in on Pittsburgh.

The anticipation on the banks of the Allegheny this weekend is palpable — and unprecedented in the last decade of Pittsburgh Pirates baseball.

And yet, despite the Paul Skenes hysteria sweeping through the city, Pirates fans, jaded from decades of underperformance, are digesting the prospect’s scheduled pitching debut Saturday at PNC Park against the Chicago Cubs with a big side of caution.

These are the Pirates, after all.

Advertise with us

Excitement over prospects isn’t abnormal, but it’s tempered by fans’ concerns over how long they remain with the Pirates — i.e., whether the team will pay to keep them long-term — and whether their individual accolades translate into sustained success for a team that’s been to the postseason just six times since last winning the World Series 45 years ago.

By Friday afternoon, MLB’s top pitching prospect had addressed the media at PNC Park. The Pirates’ clubhouse store and other merchants were working quickly to sew, press and lay out Skenes paraphernalia as the team expected a revenue bump from Skenes’ promotion. His girlfriend, Livvy Dunne, a star in her own right, accompanied him to Pittsburgh. His debut was the talk of the national baseball landscape.

Joe Barnhart, 28, of Cranberry, had been serving in the U.S. Army in Italy. He’s back in the Pittsburgh region for a full Pirates season for the first time in several years.

A Pirates fan since he was 5, he says he’s “tremendously excited” about Skenes’ debut.

“I think it's going to make a huge difference, just in terms of finally having some pressure to win,” Barnhart said. “That pressure is going to be there for some of these younger guys. I think that getting an infusion of such incredible talent is really going to take a load off of other teammates.”

Advertise with us

The buildup to Skenes’ debut transcends Pittsburgh, and it instantly became one of the most anticipated in recent MLB history.

After finishing a junior season at LSU that saw his team win a national title — with him being named College World Series MVP and earning just about every other honor — the 2023 No. 1 overall draft pick made quick work of the minor leagues.

He had one start in rookie ball, two in Low-A Bradenton and two in Double-A Altoona before last season ended. He started 2024 with Triple-A Indianapolis, where he allowed just three earned runs and struck out 45 in 27⅓ innings.

“I think the three best pitching prospects [since 1988] are Paul Skenes, Stephen Strasburg [of the Washington Nationals] and Mark Prior [of the Chicago Cubs],” MLB.com senior writer Jim Callis said Thursday. “I might go Skenes No. 1 because I think he’s the most physical of them. We know Prior and Strasburg were great when they were healthy, but they didn’t hold up. I do think Skenes is physically stronger.”

Graham Raiff, 59, has been a Pirates backer since he moved to the South Hills in 1973. He was more guarded about Skenes.

Advertise with us

“He’s just a player,” he said. “He’s not the god some people are making him out to be.”

Raiff said he wants to see the Pirates succeed, but he’s remaining cautious about Skenes’ potential.

“If he does well, he's going to be a strength to the team,” he said. “He won't be the anchor of the pitching staff. And if he burns out, you're going to hear a lot of couch coaches saying he was brought up too quickly.”

The “too quickly” concerns resonated with others.

“There is way too high of expectations for the rookie,” one social media user wrote in response to a Post-Gazette question about how fans were feeling about Skenes’ debut. “He may be great someday and maybe even on Saturday. Don’t put the franchise on his shoulders!”

Advertise with us

Others said Skenes’ presence doesn’t solve the team’s bigger problems. They rank 27th in MLB in batting average, and only the St. Louis Cardinals and Chicago White Sox have scored fewer runs this season.

“In typical Bucco fashion, he’ll either pitch a great game and get no run support,” one Facebook user replied, “or the Pirates will score a few runs and he’ll get rocked in his debut. A loss either way.”

In many corners of the social media landscape, Skenes is likely better known as Dunne’s boyfriend, not one of the Top 5 prospects in baseball.

The Sports Illustrated swimsuit model and social media star posted on Instagram when the couple arrived in Pittsburgh on Thursday, including a photo as they drove past PNC Park from across the Allegheny River in Downtown. Team officials said Friday she was the only celebrity they were expecting in attendance for Skenes’ debut.

Dunne posted on TikTok — where she has over 8 million followers — that the two were taking a nap when they got the call that Skenes had been promoted. By Friday, that video had been viewed over 3.1 million times and had over 373,000 likes.

Advertise with us

His promotion and the announcement that Skenes would start Saturday’s game triggered a “big spike” in ticket sales, Pirates officials said. But as of late Friday afternoon, the game was not yet sold out, with a sketchy-at-best weather forecast that threatened to literally dampen the mood. Team officials said they expected it would be sold out if the weather cooperates.

Meteorologist Chris Leonardi of the National Weather Service office in Moon said rain will move into the Pittsburgh region around noon Saturday, and the chance of rain and possible thunderstorms increases throughout the day.

If the game goes off as scheduled at 4:05 p.m., the gates at PNC Park will open at 2 p.m., a half-hour earlier than normal to accommodate what will be the biggest crowd of the season outside of the home opener.

At Rally House locations on the North Shore, Skenes jerseys were in the works. Manager Jason Abrahams of the Federal Street store said they planned to make 72 jerseys for that and the West General Robinson locations, with more planned as they sell them.

Abrahams said the Skenes anticipation rivals Andrew McCutchen’s return to Pittsburgh in 2023.

Advertise with us

“This is the most excitement of the season by far,” he said.

For Pirates fans, the concerns over how long a highly touted prospect will stay with the franchise can tend to prevail over any excitement, given the club’s history of trading players who would likely command big money in free agency.

Come first pitch Saturday, those concerns will almost certainly take a backseat to savoring Skenes’ nationally televised debut.

“I'm sure that he will not be here when the time comes for that [contract] to get restructured,” said Mr. Barnhart, the longtime fan from Cranberry. “But for the time being, it's to have loved and lost or never loved.”

Post-Gazette photographer Sebastian Foltz contributed.