BRADENTON, Fla. — An easy and obvious takeaway from the Pirates’ 9-7 loss to the Phillies on Sunday involved Oneil Cruz, two mammoth homers and what that sort of thing could possibly do for Pittsburgh’s offense this upcoming season.

At the same time, there was an important undercurrent involving young pitchers.

The focal point here is Jared Jones, who has absolutely been one of the best stories of spring training thus far, right along with Henry Davis’ defense, Mitch Keller’s contract extension and the return of Cruz.

Given what we’ve seen from Jones and the others competing for a spot in the starting rotation, there’s an interesting question simmering: How could the Pirates possibly explain the 22-year-old not being in their opening day rotation?

Advertise with us

They’re certainly not too deep considering there are three quasi-established names in the bunch. What we’ve seen from Roansy Contreras, Luis Ortiz, Quinn Priester (Sunday’s starter) and Bailey Falter (Monday’s starter) has been too inconsistent.

There are roster issues that could come into play with options (Ortiz and Priester have them, Contreras and Falter do not), but that’s not germane to the Jones discussion. It’s a simple question, really.

For anyone who has watched Jones pitch this spring, how’s he not one of the Pirates’ top five? Based on what we’ve seen so far, with no earned runs allowed in 7 1/3 innings, that’s absolutely been the case.

Jones’ four-seam fastball averaged 97.8 mph against the Phillies and maxed out at 100.3. That number may have been higher had he not thrown too many pitches in the bullpen beforehand, trying to get and stay loose.

“It is what it is,” Jones said. “I thought I pitched pretty well [Sunday]. Gave up two hits on two off-speed pitches that were left up in the zone. I got punished for it.”

Advertise with us

He’s not wrong. Former Pirate Rodolfo Castro hit a full-count slider up. Garrett Stubbs did the same with an 0-1 curveball. It wasn’t great, and Jones knew it. Also, so what? It’s spring training. He’s young and going to make mistakes.

Jones still struck out three in 2 2/3 innings and settled back down after allowing the runs.

“He's been really good,” Pirates manager Derek Shelton said. “I think the first inning and a half, he struggled executing breaking balls in the zone. The last two-thirds, we saw a better breaking ball. We saw more consistency.

“The fastball comes out of his hand hot, and when he locates it, it's really good.”

Comes out hotter than anybody else this side of Paul Skenes, honestly. When you couple it with two breaking balls, an improved changeup and impressive results ... you get the point. Jones has looked MLB-ready.

Advertise with us

Meanwhile, on the other side, Contreras has seen his velocity return. But he’s also been inconsistent with properly executing his curveball and changeup. When Ortiz has been around the zone, he has also been effective. The problem: That hasn’t always happened.

Falter has mostly struggled, while Priester has been up-and-down, including Sunday.

Priester was sharp through two, flashing a nasty slider, but something happened late. Either he didn’t maintain the execution of it, or the Phillies caught on.

Based on prominence and roster status, Contreras should make the club. He also holds the most value as a starter. If they wanted to, the Pirates could start Ortiz and Priester in the minors or make the former a reliever, which seems like how this will probably end.

What to do with Jones?

Advertise with us

The Pirates are preaching patience with Paul Skenes, emphasizing the need to acclimate to a professional routine. Take suspicious or hard feelings out of it for a second. Jones, a 2020 draft pick, shouldn’t need that stuff, right?

Jones making the big club should be based on merit and how he performs, nothing more and nothing less.

There’s still plenty of time to go — and it’s fair to want a larger sample size — but if this is real, it’s hard to fathom how the Pirates would rationalize keeping Jones in the minor leagues.

“All that stuff is just words,” Jones said of chatter around him competing for a spot. “I have to do what I have to do. No matter where I go, there’s no mindset change. There’s nothing that’s going to change. I just have to go out there and pitch how I pitch.”

Bednar resumes throwing

Shelton said after Sunday’s game that David Bednar has resumed throwing out to 90 feet. He has played catch each of the past two days while retuning from right late tightness. There were no issues reported, and Bednar should soon start increasing his throwing program.

Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and @JMackeyPG on X.