BRADENTON, Fla. — As loyal Iowa athletics fans, few things can interrupt Joni and Al Keller from watching Caitlin Clark and the Hawkeyes women’s basketball team. A FaceTime call from their son Mitch, informing them he would soon become the highest-paid pitcher in Pirates history, was an understandable exception.
While there have been plenty of “good news” calls to the Keller household over the past few years, there were also many tough phone conversations with their son. It was one call, specifically, that was on Joni’s mind moments after watching Mitch wrap up the press conference announcing his five-year, $77 million contract extension.
“I was there for the phone call when he got demoted,” Joni recalled. “It was a gut-wrenching call because he felt like he let people down — his teammates, his team, his hometown. I just remember saying, ‘There’s going to be another chapter, Mitch. You just have to keep going. There is going to be another chapter, and you’re just going to look back on this.’ ”
Similar to how they reacted back then, Keller’s parents wasted no time springing into action to support their son. At 3:30 a.m. Friday, the two were up and on their way to the airport, where they’d soon hop on a flight to Bradenton to be a part of Mitch’s big moment.
Seated at a table atop the left field patio at LECOM Park, between Pirates owner Bob Nutting and general manager Ben Cherington was Mitch Keller. Shaded from the bright Florida sun as palm trees blew from a cool wind in the background, each of the three reflected upon Keller’s journey — one that was far from a happy story not long ago.
“It really is a great day for the Pittsburgh Pirates, a great day for all of our fans and a great day for me personally,” Nutting said. “I’ve known Mitch for a long time. It’s sort of incredible to think that it was nearly 10 years ago when you were drafted and joined the organization, and it really has been fun — mostly fun — watching that progression as you have grown as a baseball player and to see your increasing influence on the team. I just couldn’t be more pleased for you.”
Read More
For the Keller family, those unhappy moments made Friday that much sweeter.
In 2021, Mitch Keller looked to be light years away from an everyday starter at the major league level, let alone a cornerstone of the Pirates franchise. After briefly dipping his toes in the North Shore waters in 2019 and 2020, Keller found himself struggling mightily in his first full campaign at the game’s highest level.
“At that point, we were just trying to get him through every start,” Al Keller said. “You were just holding your breath during every game. It wasn’t because he would do bad; it was because there was pain there. And we couldn’t help that pain. It was tough to see him keep doubting himself.”
Through 12 starts that season, Keller boasted a record of 3-7 along with a 7.04 ERA. In his most recent outing at the time, he had been tagged for four earned runs on five hits and three walks by the defending World Series champion Los Angeles Dodgers. For his second straight start and third time that year, he had failed to make it past the third inning.
“I’m probably the most pissed off guy in this locker room,” Keller said following the poor showing.
Something had to change, and on June 12, it did. Two days after his bad night against the Dodgers, Keller received the news every young major leaguer hopes never to hear. He was heading back to Triple-A.
Although Joni is adamant that she never lost faith in her son, no one in the Keller family anticipated his next chapter would be what occurred Friday. Things, of course, turned for Keller in the back half of 2022, when a more relaxed approach to the game, along with a few pitches added to his arsenal, allowed him to sustain his first string of success with the Pirates.
Things then took off to another level in 2023, when he won 13 games, struck out 210 batters and earned his first All-Star nod. His turnaround was hard to believe and easy to appreciate, especially for Keller’s brother, Jon, a former minor-league pitcher, who could relate firsthand to what Mitch went through in 2021.
“It’s incredible,” he said. “I think I was telling my mom, dad or both about my struggles in Double-A. ... I can’t speak for [Mitch], but I can remember going to the clubhouse feeling embarrassed on a daily basis. I was supposed to be somebody. That is so hard to do, even at that level.
“For me, the contract is great, but the story itself is amazing. It’s cliche to say, but that kid deserves every penny. Not one day did he cheat the work in the offseason, which, again, is easy to do, even when things are going well. He worked so incredibly hard, every single day. He never missed a workout and never made excuses.”
As the 2024 regular season approaches, so too does a new chapter of Keller’s story. The days of being labeled a “bust” are no more, as are the days of having to worry about his long-term future in the game.
“Now, I can just go worry about winning a baseball game rather than stressing out about every little thing,” Keller said Friday afternoon.
And despite the next chapter having yet to unfold, Joni Keller already knows what her favorite part of that story will be.
“Now, he gets to be a role model for players who will struggle in their own careers,” she said. “He can be there to help them.”
Noah Hiles: nhiles@post-gazette.com and @_NoahHiles on X





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.