BRADENTON, Fla. — Thursday was an important day for the longest-tenured Pirates. Bryan Reynolds was thrilled to learn Mitch Keller won’t be going anywhere. Ditto for Ke’Bryan Hayes.
It was also a big day for Paul Skenes, who soon could anchor a starting rotation with Keller. Drafted first overall last summer, Skenes knew a little bit about Keller’s story before joining the organization. But he has been even more impressed while getting to know Keller this spring at Pirate City.
“That’s pretty dang cool,” Skenes said of Keller’s five-year, $77 million deal. “Watching him compete this past year and watching him work here, it’s no secret why he’s so good. He’s a special guy.”
That’s when Skenes said something that reinforced his goals for this season, as well as the over-arching meaning for Keller’s new deal, which runs through 2028.
“I’m super happy for him and super fired up to be pitching with him hopefully this year and going forward,” Keller said. “Gonna win a lot of games with him.”
It’s fun to think about, no?
Read More
Keller and Skenes anchoring the Pirates’ starting rotation, as early as later this season. They’ll soon be joined by Jared Jones, Anthony Solometo and Bubba Chandler, as well as JT Brubaker and Mike Burrows, when they return midseason from Tommy John surgery.
Johan Oviedo will be back from his own TJ procedure in 2025. There’s still much left to learn with Roansy Contreras, Luis Ortiz and Quinn Priester. Jackson Wolf, Bailey Falter and Braxton Ashcraft have intriguing stories. Thomas Harrington, Hunter Barco and Michael Kennedy are names of Pirates minor league starters to stash for future reference.
At the top of that, of course, is Keller, a reigning All-Star and someone who wasn’t far off from becoming the third pitcher in MLB to notch 200 or more innings and 200 or more strikeouts this past season.
“As we've talked about over the last few years, there's going to be commitment to a core,” Pirates manager Derek Shelton said. “It's important that we continue to build on that."
No arguments here.
For while it’s hard to argue with the Pirates spending $253.75 million on contract extensions to Hayes, Reynolds and Keller the past three years, they can’t be finished. More candidates remain.
Oneil Cruz might be impressive and imposing, but it’s tough seeing that as the next domino to fall. Previous talks with Cruz have not netted much traction. Cruz also changed agencies twice this offseason, potentially slowing the process.
From the Pirates’ side, it would be understandable for them to want to see how the 6-foot-7 shortstop returns from serious ankle surgery. Cruz has looked good thus far, sure, but hasn’t played in an MLB game since the injury occurred.
At the same time, it’s hard to criticize Cruz for wanting to increase his value before signing anything. Also, if he’s looking for $25 million or $30 million a year, well, we are talking about the Pirates here.
Which takes us to a more reasonable option and someone who deserves the certainty an extension would provide: David Bednar. The argument is that relievers are fungible or replaceable, but Bednar should be treated as a special case.
He’s been remarkably effective and consistent. Bednar has also been a tremendous ambassador for the team the past couple of years, volunteering for everything and twice becoming the team’s Roberto Clemente Award nominee.
Similar to Keller, Bednar isn’t looking to get rich. He loves it here. Pittsburgh's his home. It feels like he’d sign for a lifetime supply of IC Light and Steelers season tickets. But the lack of certainty — for Bednar working on one-year deals through arbitration — should be rectified.
Sit down with the two-time All-Star and talk business. Allow Bednar to join the conversation that includes Hayes, Reynolds and Keller. And continue to build a core that soon will include Skenes.
After all, that has long been the perception around the Pirates’ clubhouse with Bednar — that he’s the most likely to sign an extension. It’s time to keep going.
“It’s out of my control, but it’s cool,” Bednar said of the speculation that he could be next. “It just shows how much I love the city of Pittsburgh.”
Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.