If the version of Mitch Keller you watched on Sunday looked familiar, good. That was by design.
Roughed up to the tune of a 5.92 ERA over his previous 13 starts and with opponents slugging .700 against non-fastballs from Keller over the past six weeks, the first-time All-Star knew a change was necessary.
Keller delivered on those promises Sunday during a 4-2 Pirates victory against the Reds at PNC Park by pitching off his harder offerings more, increasing the velocity on his cutter and also using his sweeper as a mechanism to produce chase.
In other words, getting back to how Keller pitched over the first couple months of the season, when he was one of the best starting pitchers in baseball.
“I went back and watched some previous starts and what made me successful,” Keller said. “We were using hard stuff early and the sweeper and cutter more as chase pitches rather than for strikes.
“Getting back to that mindset and using my good fastballs as an advantage for me to get ahead in the count early was what made us successful [Sunday].”
Read More
By going six innings and allowed two runs (one earned) with seven strikeouts, Keller notched his team-high 13th quality start of the season. Keller racked up 19 called strikes, 12 whiffs and generated way more weak contact than we’ve seen out of him lately.
“I thought it was the best fastball he's had since probably before the [All-Star] break,” Pirates manager Derek Shelton said. “Execution of it on both sides of the plate, being able to throw the comebacker to left-handers … I thought it was as good as we've seen since before the break. But overall, good outing.”
Keller tipped his hand some while discussing this start with the Post-Gazette on Saturday — and no, he didn’t intentionally drift away from what made him good. But as his sweeper became a dominant pitch for him, Keller grew a little obsessed with it, throwing it for a strike and also attempting to nick the zone when ahead late in counts.
At the same time, Keller started treating his cutter more like a slider, intentionally trying to make it move and inherently killing its velocity. Keller took a different approach on Sunday, caring less about movement and more about velocity, challenging Reds hitters to do something with the pitch.
“Throw it hard,” Keller said. “I think when I was getting in trouble, it was 87-88 [mph]. That’s been the mentality: throw it hard and let the movement take care of itself instead of making it move.”
The first few innings for Keller were excellent and efficient, as he threw a ton of hard stuff. In fact, 84% of his offerings through three innings were either four-seam fastballs or sinkers, up from 47.1% on the season.
Keller got ahead with fastballs and cutters before breaking off a terrific sweeper to freeze Reds shortstop Elly De La Cruz for an inning-ending strikeout in the first.
Double plays helped Keller navigate the second and third before the Reds picked up a run against him in the fourth on a cutter that actually wasn’t terrible. The sinker he left up in the fifth wasn’t great, but neither was the defense behind Keller.
Keller hurt himself by not controlling the running game terribly well, but that was small potatoes when looking at this outing. With questions swirling around whether Keller was tired or the past year-plus was a fluke, he likely stomped those out with his best start in weeks.
“Just getting back to what was working,” Keller said. “Using the heater early and the spin stuff late. Going back to fastballs really worked. I just felt really comfortable out there.”
Reynolds stays hot
Reynolds 2-for-5 performance in the nightcap continued what has been a red-hot stretch for Bryan Reynolds, who entered Sunday's doubleheader hitting .333 with two doubles and six home runs in his past 20 games dating back to July 21.
"I felt pretty good the second game," Reynolds said. "Got some good swings off."
After blasting a 3-1 cutter in the first inning, a pitch Reds starter Luke Weaver left middle-middle, Reynolds crushed a sweeper from Ian Gibaut in the seventh.
Through 104 games, Reynolds has 17 home runs and an .801 OPS. He had 20 homers and an .818 OPS through the same amount of games last season.
"Just kind of the ebbs and flows of baseball and how my swing works," Reynolds said. "Whatever it is, just keep it going in New York."
Around the horn
With his pinch-hit, three-run homer, Jared Triolo became the 23rd Pirate in the modern era (1900-present) to hit his first big league homer as a pinch-hitter and first since Rodolfo Castro did it July 9, 2021, at the Mets.
The home run also came with Endy Rodriguez and Liover Peguero. Since 1958 (the first season with official rookie rules), no Pirates rookie had his first career home run come with at least two rookies on base.
Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.