PHOENIX – Just three months ago, the Pirates used their athleticism and speed to sneak out a plethora of wins against their counterparts.
On Friday night, it was the Pirates who appeared lethargic while their opposition in the desert contrasted with ample amounts of youth and eagerness.
A day removed from traveling after a night game in Los Angeles, a depleted version of the Pirates came out flat defensively against a young Diamondbacks team that exploited the visitors’ shortcomings on several instances, registering five stolen bases in six attempts.
With the likes of Andrew McCutchen, Ke’Bryan Hayes and Ji Hwan Bae all shelved with injuries, the Diamondbacks comfortably earned a 7-3 victory at Chase Field against a Pirates club that hardly resembled the one deployed in the first month of the season.
"Our personnel is a little bit different now than it was in April with the ability to move. I mean, they have superior athletes on the field throughout,” Manager Derek Shelton said of the youthful Diamondbacks. “We're talking the three guys they had at the end of the game are 21 years, 22-years-old, and are really good athletes and can move. And I mean, what [Corbin] Carroll does, this guy's one of the elite players in the game and he's 22-years-old.
“Us being able to move and do things is something that's important and right now, our personnel is a little bit different than it was earlier."
Read More
While a three-run homer by Lourdes Gurriel Jr. in the third inning was difficult enough to overcome for a victory, the Pirates’ defense against the aggressive Diamondbacks hardly did starter Rich Hill any favors.
Although Hill issued a walk to nine hitter Jake McCarthy, he also correctly picked over when the speedy right fielder tried to take second. Unfortunately for Hill, Carlos Santana’s throw to second was off target and McCarthy ultimately came around to score on an RBI bunt single by Carroll.
“They do a great job,” Hill said of the Diamondbacks’ work on the basepaths. “Obviously with being able to execute stolen bases and–just their ability to understand how to steal bases has been good, especially Carroll who’s a rookie. They did a really good job tonight."
It was deja vu an inning later, with McCarthy once again leading off and drawing a base on balls. Hill picked over, Santana’s ensuing throw to second sailed high and McCarthy advanced to third on the first of the Pirates’ two throwing errors on the night.
"They got a good club and that's why they're leading the National League West,” Shelton said. “They put a ton of pressure on you. We saw it tonight."
Just like he did the first time when using his wheels to his advantage, McCarthy strutted across home plate for another Diamondbacks run. It was quite the unusual pair of miscues by Santana, considering he entered the game leading all MLB first basemen by a wide margin for Defensive Runs Saved with eight.
Then in the sixth, Carroll and Gurriel engaged in a double steal, the kind of exciting and risky play the Pirates were more than willing to do earlier in the campaign.
Austin Hedges tried to gun down the trailing runner in Gurriel, but his throw trickled into center field. Carroll proceeded to waltz across home plate and give the Diamondbacks a comfortable 6-1 lead they would not look back from.
"I mean, tremendously,” Shelton said of Carroll’s impact on the game, which was put on full display. “A guy that plays elite defense, he's got, what, 18 homers and almost 50 RBI's in the first half and can run. We're talking about one of the good young players, one of the better young players in the game,"
Unfortunately for the Pirates, such a five-tool talent does not currently exist on their roster. Even so, the youth movement of calling up prospects like Henry Davis, Nick Gonzales and Jared Triolo has been helpful and provided flashes of what’s possible.
Still, there was no avoiding a sixth loss in seven games and 18th in 24 contests against a Diamondbacks squad ready and able to give this banged-up version of the Pirates a taste of their own medicine.
ON THE MOUND
Before Friday evening, Hill had only failed to last at least five innings twice, last doing so on May 10 against the Rockies. On a night in which Hill did not have his best stuff, he labored through the Diamondbacks’ order, walking four while giving up seven hits and five earned runs in just four innings.
He only allowed an infield single in the first two frames, but Hill ran into trouble during a third inning that seemed to last for an eternity. The Diamondbacks initially scratched one across on Carrol’s bunt single, but it was Gurriel’s three-run jack that put the game out of reach for the Pirates.
Hill hung a curveball to Gurriel, who sent out a walloping shot to left. After the game, Shelton said it looked like Hill’s trademark curveball wasn’t as sharp as it’s been in the past.
"He struggled with the command of it and then when it was in the zone, it was up in the zone and they took good swings at it,” Shelton said.
Gurriel drove in another run in the following inning, nearly depositing another home run into the bleachers that came up just short for an RBI double.
After a pair of solid outings to start June, Hill has fallen off in recent weeks. Including Friday’s start, Hill has now given up at least three earned runs in each of his last five outings. His ERA over that stretch is 6.31 and consequently, his season-long mark has risen to 4.78.
“I didn’t throw the ball well and it’s been really frustrating for me as of late,” Hill said. “Putting us in these positions. It’s extremely frustrating, and the ball didn’t come out of my hand the way that I wanted it to.”
AT THE PLATE
The Pirates struggled to do much of anything against Diamondbacks starter Zac Gallen, who entered the evening tied for the second-most wins of any MLB starter with 10. Gallen has now equaled the Rays’ Shane McClanahan’s league-leading number of victories after producing seven innings of one-run ball while only allowing four hits.
"He's good,” Shelton said of Gallen. “It's why he's leading the National League in wins. And, the ability to execute the fastball to both sides of the plate, the addition of the cutter. I mean the changeup's elite, but he was really good."
Gallen coasted through the first four frames, only needing 47 pitches to do so. The Pirates finally got to Gallen in the fifth, with Tucupita Marcano shooting a single up the gut to plate Triolo, who had poked a double to the wall in the previous at-bat.
Once Gallen departed, the Pirates were the benefactors of more success against 21-year-old reliever Justin Martinez, who was making his MLB debut. The Pirates loaded the bases against Martinez and tagged him for two runs, courtesy of a two-out base knock by Santana.
Otherwise, it was a tough go for the Pirates on the heels of being held to just four hits by Dodgers starter Julio Urias and company a night prior.
IN THE FIELD
Davis made his MLB debut behind the plate, replacing Hedges in the bottom of the eighth after Josh Palacios pinch hit for the latter. Catching Dauri Moreta, it wasn’t a particularly noteworthy inning in that no runs came across, nor did Davis make any noticeable positive or negative plays in the squat.
Shelton remarked postgame that he thought Davis did a nice job in the extremely brief appearance. While Davis hadn’t caught in a live game since mid-June for Triple-A Indianapolis, he feels his development at the position has continued behind the scenes in the big leagues.
"It's tough to measure it,” Davis said. “But I feel like I've gotten better every day."
QUOTABLE
“I let the guys down in here and that’s the toughest part,” Hill said. “I need to figure out what I’m doing and go into the All-Star break, work on some things and come back with a different mindset.”
UP NEXT
Mitch Keller gets the ball for the Pirates in their matinee meet-up with the Diamondbacks on Saturday. He was touched up for five runs (four earned) his last time out against the Dodgers after back-to-back starts yielding only a single run.
Andrew Destin: adestin@post-gazette.com and Twitter @AndrewDestin1.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.