Ben Cherington traded away fan favorites Josh Bell, Jameson Taillon and Joe Musgrove. The Pirates general manager has also revamped how the organization develops players, changed how it leverages data, spent more than Monopoly money in free agency this offseason and over the past couple weeks has finally started promoting homegrown prospects.

Yet, on Sunday night, it’s possible — no, likely — Cherington faces the biggest decision of his Pirates tenure.

Do the Pirates do what the majority of MLB draft observers and evaluators still think they should do and select LSU outfielder Dylan Crews? Or do they prioritize pitching and add the best college arm since Stephen Strasburg in Crews’ teammate, Paul Skenes? What about neither and crafting an entirely different plan?

The decision isn’t easy, and it involves way more than simply taking the best player available.

Advertise with us

Cherington has said a bunch that the Pirates’ available options run far deeper than two, which means they also include University of Florida outfielder Wyatt Langford and high school outfielders Walker Jenkins and Max Clark.

While it might be possible to separate the college and high school outfielders, creating a group of three, MLB rules create more inputs. In other words, signability matters. Crews might be the best outfielder available, but saving $2 million by going with Langford (or anyone else) could allow the Pirates to spread those savings around to later rounds.

They paid Anthony Solometo and Bubba Chandler, a pair of talented high school pitchers, more to sign. Jared Jones, too. It’s a way for teams to improve the quality of their overall talent pool.

“The first choice is really important,” Cherington said last weekend. “Every team’s job is to get as much total talent out of every draft as they can. Historically, when you have the first pick, the biggest portion of that is gonna be from the first pick.”

If the Pirates go with Crews, they’re getting an athletic outfielder with incredible bat speed and elite plate discipline, a combination of skills so rare that the 21-year-old Longwood, Fla., native has been the presumed top pick from the moment the 2022 MLB draft ended.

Advertise with us

“Everything we’ve done throughout this year-plus of covering the draft makes me think that Crews is the guy,” said Baseball America draft analyst Carlos Collazo.

Plenty agree, especially when you look at this through the best-player-in-the-draft lens, but there’s more to consider.

Most notably the presence of the 6-foot-7, 250-pound Skenes, a right-hander who regularly throws 100 mph and was also the best two-way player in college baseball only two years ago.

Whether Skenes can become a Shohei Ohtani type is a fascinating question, but the Pirates must ask themselves a simpler one: Is it worth absorbing the risk of taking a pitcher first overall when arm issues are as prevalent as ever?

For as much as the Strasburg comparison sounds great, baseball fans are plenty aware of his laundry list of injury issues. At 34, he may never throw again. An easy argument could be made for Crews. It also might make sense to go with Langford, who has 47 home runs and 120 RBIs the past two years in the SEC.

Advertise with us

There’s a difference between Langford and Crews, obviously. But are the Pirates comfortable with that drop if the upshot is spending the savings other places? They might be.

“Wyatt Langford, in another year, would be the best college hitter in the country,” said Jonathan Mayo of MLB Pipeline.

“Wyatt Langford is probably underrated,” Collazo added. “Tool for tool, performance and track record, he’s very close to Crews.”

If the decision wasn’t hard enough, shift your attention to the high school kids, Jenkins and Clark.

There have been weighty comps thrown around on the former, with scouts likening the the Southport, N.C., product to Austin Meadows and Josh Hamilton. Jenkins has a fluid and powerful left-handed swing — and a 6-foot-3 frame with which to work.

Advertise with us

“I personally love Walker Jenkins’ swing,” Collazo said. “I think it’s probably the best swing in the class.”

The issue, of course, is Pirates fans likely don’t care.

And they surely aren’t interested in waiting around until, say, 2027 or 2028 for an 18-year-old to be major-league ready. They got a taste of winning with the team’s 20-8 start, and they view Crews and Skenes — rightfully so — as players who can help in the not-too-distant future.

Which brings us, of course, to the final option at No. 1 overall: the Indiana prepster Clark. Mayo thinks Clark “has the best chance to become a superstar from this group, just because he is a true five-tool guy.”

The 70 grades (on the 20-to-80 scale) on his running and fielding are exciting. Ditto for his power and ridiculous 1.222 slugging percentage as a senior. But we’re also talking about someone who’s 190 pounds and has a ways to go before he reaches the major leagues.

Advertise with us

Clark may sign for the least money, and the Pirates can do what they did in 2021 with Henry Davis, to a much larger degree. But what will the cost be of those savings? There’s zero chance fans want to hear about how a player projects in five years.

For them, it’s already been too long. They had a taste, and they want more.

Which is why I ultimately think they wind up with Skenes.

Crews will take up too much of their allotted pool money, prohibiting the Pirates from seeking value later in the draft. Skenes also gives them something they never could or would buy on the free agent market: premium pitching.

With Cherington confronting the weightiest decision of his tenure, it makes sense.

Advertise with us

They make their team better in the relatively near future while also feeling good about the work they’ve done outside of the first round of the draft and not immediately infuriating those making this whole thing work: the fans.

Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG.