Pittsburgh sports fans love to date themselves by recalling the regional sports network on which they first watched Pirates and Penguins games.
From KBL to Fox Sports Net to Root Sports, the names all evoke nostalgia for different times in the teams’ respective histories. Some of them good. Some of them not so good. But all of them memorable.
AT&T SportsNet now appears poised to join those names on the ash heap of history amid reports that parent company Warner Bros. Discovery wants to get out of the regional sports network business.
This time, however, the changes to the ways we watch our local teams may be more significant than simply getting used to new branding on an old channel. Rather, the great cable unbundling of the last decade may be about to cause permanent changes to our habits that could bring major economic disruption for both teams.
The reason isn’t particularly complicated. The advent of streaming services has freed millions of people who don’t care about sports from having to pay for RSNs as part of a cable bundle. So they’ve taken their entertainment dollars elsewhere in droves, with some estimates putting the drop in cable subscriptions at nearly a third since 2013.
That means millions fewer paying customers for RSNs nationwide and thousands locally. All while RSNs have agreed to increasingly richer television contracts for the rights to broadcast games.
Read More
Eventually, something had to give economically. And it appears it has, as WBD has reportedly set a March 31 deadline for teams including the Penguins and Pirates to negotiate a return of their rights. WBD has deals with 10 teams in total, mostly in Denver, Seattle and Houston. Elsewhere, the parent company of Bally Sports RSNs has missed an interest payment of billions of dollars of debt and appears headed for bankruptcy.
“[Cord cutting] is disrupting what’s been the bedrock of local revenue for teams for going on four decades,” the Score’s Travis Sawchik told the Post-Gazette in a video interview Tuesday morning. Sawchick covered the Pirates for the Pittsburgh Tribune-Review a decade ago and has since earned acclaim for his work explaining the business of sports, first in his book titled “Big Data Baseball,” and at various outlets since. One year ago, he published a series of articles explaining the RSN predicament that’s boiling over today.
His warning now is that it’s going to be hard to replace the revenue that the bundle once provided.
MLB commissioner Rob Manfred has promised that the league will handle distribution of any games RSNs fail to or refuse to carry in the short-term. In the Pirates’ case, you’ll probably be able to find a local option on MLB.TV, the the league owned-and-operated Internet service where it has streamed primarily out-of-market games for over a decade. There will probably be some kind of short-term traditional television home, too, though Sawchik predicts that home could change from year to year as the teams avoid getting locked down contractually with the hope of finding a more permanent home.
But that availability does not necessarily equate to the profitability leagues and teams have been able to rely on under the bundle model.
“It won’t be, dollar for dollar, the same revenues,” Sawchick said. “It’ll be less. Sports Business Journal had a report yesterday in which they spoke to an NBA executive and some MLB executives, too. The estimates were that it could be up to a 70% loss in TV revenue, going from what was existing before to what comes next for these affected clubs. And that is significant.”
On the surface, a direct-to-consumer streaming subscription for the Pirates and/or Penguins seems more consumer friendly in the same way streaming services are more attractive to non-sports fans. Instead of having to pay for Bravo or CNN or the Home Shopping Network, individual fans could, in theory, pay only to watch their favorite teams’ games.
No matter how you slice it, though, the number of people who’d pay for such a service is always going to be smaller than the number of people who were paying for RSNs in the bundle. So that solution doesn’t solve for the shortfall in revenue unless subscribers are charged a huge premium compared to the former RSN carriage fee.
Another potential complication is that the Pirates and Penguins may no longer be able to exist symbiotically. Under the RSN model, people who only watched the Penguins had to pay the same price for the same channel as people who only watched the Pirates. And vice versa. So economically speaking, a fan of one team equaled a fan of both.
Now fans of just one team could be freed from the obligation to subsidize the other with their cable subscription fee. Which means less money rolling in for both unless they start a joint venture.
Solving these problems at a national level isn’t easy, either. Because MLB, NBA and NHL teams have sold their rights locally for decades, every team has a different deal with a different RSN. As long as those RSNs hold the rights, the leagues can’t bypass them to distribute games locally outside the bundle, as Major League Soccer is attempting to do through it’s new deal with Apple TV.
That puts teams like the Pirates and Penguins in a uniquely precarious position if, for example, AT&T SportsNet goes away but the Bally Sports group presses forward with some kind of bankruptcy reorganization, keeping their local deals with teams in more than a dozen markets intact.
Such a scenario would leave homeless only the small handful of teams connected to WBD, while teams in most other markets are less interested in finding a national solution because of existing deals.
At that point, local fans’ best long-term hope may be that Apple, Amazon or some other Big Tech streaming service decides that carrying the rights of teams presently connected to WBD is worthwhile as a proverbial foothold in the sports TV rights markets in which they’ve begun dabbling in recent years. Apple and Peacock began streaming national MLB games last year. And Amazon produced the NFL’s Thursday night package of games in 2022.
The streaming services’ biggest pitfall, after all, is that viewers can subscribe to watch a single TV show or movie, then unsubscribe after paying for just one month of access. A Pirates or Penguins fan wouldn’t have that option, however, if Apple became their teams’ TV home. They’d have to stay subscribed for at least as long as those teams are in-season.
Perhaps that kind of loyalty is worth buying. Especially if it’s a starting point for adding more rights as time goes on and the RSN collapse rolls through other cities the way it is here now.
Think of it as the bundle for the digital age, where instead of getting live TV channels, you get access to “Ted Lasso” or “The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel” included instead.
Might not be too desirable if you’re a fan of cable and the bundle of yesteryear. But if you already like those services, suddenly one that includes your favorite teams looks like a huge bargain compared to cable or even digital options like Fubo TV, which is presently the only in-market streaming option for games on AT&T SportsNet.
Regardless, this is what Pirates owner Bob Nutting meant when he told the Post-Gazette’s Jason Mackey last week that the present environment is a “significant and real risk.” There are no obvious paths for the teams to take, and that may have a direct impact on what they can pay their players in the coming years.
Yes, you’ll still be able to watch the two teams somewhere, in all likelihood. But if the teams can’t find a stable way to make those broadcasts as profitable as they were under the RSN model, then cutting costs is the only way they’ll be able to survive.
That probably lessens the chances that the Pirates will follow through on the extension Nutting spoke of potentially giving star outfielder Bryan Reynolds just a few days ago. And it heightens the chances the Penguins may be forced to trade a star player to make payroll comfortably.
“Any time you lose a significant portion of your revenues, owners are going to trim elsewhere, and player payroll is their greatest expense,” Sawchik said. “You would think situations like that would play out across the league. And certain markets may be more affected than others.”
He doesn’t believe the overall picture is all doom and gloom, though. For one thing, Pittsburgh is market with a lot of sports loyalty. So converting fans from the bundle to whatever comes next may be easier here than in Sun Belt cities where transplant residents may not have a ton of connection to the local team.
Down the road, he also believes the local teams will be incentivized to compete harder for eyeballs.
That hasn’t been a concern for the Penguins, who’ve spent to the salary cap for most years since it was implemented in the mid aughts. But the Pirates are just now emerging from their latest three-year roster purge, their second since Bob Nutting took over as principal owner in 2007.
That burn-and-build model may not be tenable without a guaranteed cable check that’s been valued in the range of $44 million annually, per Fangraphs to $60 million per Sports Business Journal.
“Long-term, I think this is really exciting,” Sawchik said. “If you’re on the consumer side, if you’re a fan, it’s going to force teams, I think, to be more competitive because you cannot string these terrible seasons together and just tank for a high draft pick as often.
“The consumer, the fan, is going to have more say. If we don’t like a product, if we don’t like what you’re doing, we are not going to subscribe. It’s no longer subsidized by people who are not watching. You think about most businesses, usually you produce a product and it has to appeal to a certain customer base to make it work and be relevant. To support the model. So I think transitioning to something more like that is, long-term, going to be healthy.”
Bottom line, it’s probably going to be a bumpy ride for the next handful of years. Conventional wisdom about how the Pirates and Penguins should be operating will probably have to be turned on its head. And not all of what results from this transition is going to be pleasant.
But it’s not as if the existing model has exactly served the Pirates, in particular, very well anyway. They’ve had just seven winning seasons since cable began dominating sports revenues in the 1980s. So perhaps this transition is the start of something better.
Adam Bittner: abittner@post-gazette.com and Twitter @fugimaster24.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.